Re: Certain accidentals

[Thomas Morley]

Hi Brian,

2014-04-18 8:26 GMT+02:00 Brian Barker <address@hidden>:

> But perhaps you are referring to the method of textual input in Lilypond,
> where notes that are named "sharp" or "flat" need to be qualified as such,
> notwithstanding what the \key indication would appear already to imply.  (In
> this way, Lilypond operates somewhat counterintuitively and against normal
> musical thinking.)

seriously?
"against normal musical thinking"??

Look at the output of

{ \key g\major g''2. fis''4 g''1 }

Do you really _think_ g f g while playing/singing?
Can't believe that.

Imho, it's the opposite, printing fis from { \key g\major f''4 } would
be counterintuitively.

Well, it can be more typing, I don't want it different, though.

Cheers,
  Harm