[Bug-gnubg] Resignation and other problems

[Joseph Heled]

This match managed to confuse (yet again) GNUbg resign logic. It ends with


O: (6 6) 4-off 3-off 3-off 2-off
X: (5 5) 19-24 19-24 19-24 20-off
O: wins

The panel shows

    17 66: 4/off 3/off(2) 2/off  55: 6/1(3) 5/off
    18                           Resigns

   Equity before resignation 71.34%
          after              69.71%


Since it shows the score at 1-away 5-away Crawford, this is complete nonsense.
(Perhaps it got the sides wrong again?)

Comments:

- The resignation analysis is not saved in the SGF. I guess everybody knows
that, but I forgot it. (Given the quality of it, maybe it is a good thing).


- The window simply goes bizarke when I try to resize it. (Linux, KDE 3.2.3).
After resizing, even moving it around changes it
    The board change to ridiculous sizes for no apparent reason, and the panels
too. I attach one example for your pleasure.

Sad to see such deterioration on the Linux version. I guess it is inevitable
when the developers are on windows, still GNUbg was supposed to be
multiplatform, and the only option on UNIX.

-Joseph


Score is 0-0 in a 7 point match.
motif is X - heledy is O
O: (5 3) 8-3 6-3 
X: (3 6) 1-7 12-15 
O: (3 1) 24-21 8-7 
X: (1 4) bar-1 17-21 
O: (6 2) bar-23 13-7 
X: (1 1) 19-20 19-20 19-20 20-21 
O: (6 6) 13-7 13-7 24-18 8-2 
X: doubles
O: rejects
X: wins

Score is 0-1 in a 7 point match.
heledy is X - motif is O
X: (2 6) 1-7 12-14 
O: (4 4) 24-20 24-20 13-9 13-9 
X: (3 6) 1-7 14-17 
O: (2 4) 8-4 6-4 
X: (1 3) 12-15 15-16 
O: (5 6) 9-3 8-3 
X: (3 3) 16-19 19-22 19-22 19-22 
O: (1 2) 8-6 6-5 
X: (6 2) 17-23 19-21 
O: (4 1) 9-5 6-5 
X: (5 4) 12-16 16-21 
O: (6 2) 13-11 11-5 
X: (4 5) 19-23 19-24 
O: (3 6) 20-14 5-2 
X: (5 5) 7-12 12-17 7-12 12-17 
O: (1 5) 14-9 5-4 
X: (1 2) 22-24 21-22 
O: (3 6) 13-7 13-10 
X: (6 3) 12-15 15-21 
O: (6 1) 9-3 3-2 
X: doubles
O: accepts
X: (6 1) 12-18 17-18 
O: (1 3) 10-7 7-6 
X: (1 2) 18-20 20-21 
O: (1 1) can't move
X: (4 3) 17-21 18-21 
O: (1 5) bar-20 6-5 
X: (5 4) 17-21 17-22 
O: (2 5) 20-15 7-5 
X: (6 1) 17-23 24-off 
O: (3 2) 15-12 12-10 
X: (6 2) 21-off 23-off 
O: (6 4) 10-4 4-off 
X: (1 3) 22-off 24-off 
O: (6 6) 6-off 6-off 6-off 5-off 
X: (1 3) 22-off 23-24 
O: (3 6) 5-off 3-off 
X: (1 5) 21-off 24-off 
O: (5 1) 5-off 2-1 
X: (3 2) 22-off 23-off 
O: (4 2) 4-off 2-off 
X: (6 4) 21-off 21-off 
O: (3 3) 5-2 4-1 4-1 3-off 
X: (2 6) 21-off 22-24 
O: (3 4) 2-off 1-off 
X: wins

Score is 2-1 in a 7 point match.
motif is X - heledy is O
O: (3 6) 24-18 13-10 
X: (5 2) 1-3 19-24 
O: (6 6) can't move
X: (4 1) 19-23 23-24 
O: (1 3) bar-22 22-21 
X: (3 5) 17-22 19-22 
O: (6 2) 18-16 16-10 
X: (5 1) 1-2 12-17 
O: (3 6) 21-15 13-10 
X: (1 5) 2-3 12-17 
O: (2 5) 15-13 13-8 
X: (6 1) 17-23 22-23 
O: (6 3) 13-7 10-7 
X: (4 6) 12-18 18-22 
O: (4 1) 6-5 5-1 
X: (6 2) 3-9 17-19 
O: (6 3) 13-7 13-10 
X: (6 1) 3-9 19-20 
O: (5 3) 10-5 8-5 
X: (6 3) 12-18 18-21 
O: (1 5) 8-3 7-6 
X: (4 1) 12-13 17-21 
O: (4 5) 10-5 10-6 
X: (2 1) 17-19 19-20 
O: (4 2) 8-4 8-6 
X: (2 1) 9-11 13-14 
O: (5 1) 7-2 7-6 
X: (5 3) 11-16 16-19 
O: (1 3) 3-off 1-off 
X: (6 4) 9-15 15-19 
O: (2 5) 5-off 2-off 
X: (5 3) 14-19 22-off 
O: (5 5) 6-1 6-1 5-off 5-off 
X: (3 3) 19-22 19-22 22-off 22-off 
O: (1 4) 4-off 1-off 
X: (5 4) 20-off 21-off 
O: (2 4) 6-2 2-off 
X: (2 3) 22-off 23-off 
O: (1 5) 6-1 1-off 
X: (6 6) 19-off 19-off 19-off 20-off 
O: (6 3) 6-3 6-off 
X: doubles
O: rejects
X: wins

Score is 2-2 in a 7 point match.
heledy is X - motif is O
X: (5 6) 1-7 7-12 
O: (4 4) 24-20 24-20 8-4 8-4 
X: (6 3) 1-7 7-10 
O: (5 2) 13-8 6-4 
X: (5 6) 10-15 15-21 
O: (4 6) 13-7 13-9 
X: (4 5) 12-16 16-21 
O: (4 6) 9-5 8-2 
X: (5 6) 12-17 17-23 
O: (3 2) 7-5 6-3 
X: (4 6) 12-16 16-22 
O: (4 4) 20-16 20-16 13-9 6-2 
X: (4 6) 12-18 18-22 
O: (6 3) 16-10 16-13 
X: (2 3) 17-20 17-19 
O: (5 6) 10-5 9-3 
X: (1 4) 19-23 19-20 
O: (2 6) 13-7 13-11 
X: (1 5) 12-13 12-17 
O: (1 3) 8-5 7-6 
X: (2 6) 13-19 17-19 
O: (2 4) 11-7 7-5 
X: (2 2) 17-19 23-off 23-off 21-23 
O: (4 5) 5-off 4-off 
X: (2 5) 20-off 23-off 
O: (1 2) 5-4 2-off 
X: (4 3) 21-off 22-off 
O: (6 1) 6-off 2-1 
X: (4 1) 20-24 24-off 
O: (4 3) 4-off 3-off 
X: (5 2) 19-24 19-21 
O: (5 5) 6-1 5-off 5-off 5-off 
X: (5 6) 19-off 19-24 
O: doubles
X: rejects
O: wins

Score is 2-3 in a 7 point match.
heledy is X - motif is O
O: (2 1) 13-11 6-5 
X: (6 3) 12-18 12-15 
O: (2 4) 8-4 6-4 
X: (6 3) 12-18 15-18 
O: (1 5) 13-8 6-5 
X: (3 1) 17-20 19-20 
O: (6 6) 13-7 13-7 13-7 11-5 
X: (1 4) 19-20 12-16 
O: (1 4) 24-23 7-3 
X: (5 5) 17-22 17-22 18-23 18-23 
O: (4 3) bar-21 24-21 
X: (5 2) 1-3 18-23 
O: doubles
X: rejects
O: wins

Score is 2-4 in a 7 point match.
heledy is X - motif is O
X: (2 3) 12-14 12-15 
O: (1 4) 13-9 6-5 
X: (3 2) 1-4 12-14 
O: (6 2) 13-7 7-5 
X: (1 1) 1-2 2-3 3-4 14-15 
O: (6 1) 24-18 9-8 
X: (3 1) 14-15 15-18 
O: (3 2) bar-22 24-22 
X: (3 5) 15-18 19-24 
O: (1 5) 22-21 21-16 
X: (6 2) 15-21 19-21 
O: (6 4) 22-16 6-2 
X: (6 4) 17-23 19-23 
O: (2 4) 13-11 6-2 
X: (2 3) 17-20 18-20 
O: (6 1) 13-7 8-7 
X: (3 6) 4-10 10-13 
O: (2 5) can't move
X: (5 3) 13-18 17-20 
O: (6 3) bar-22 22-16 
X: doubles
O: accepts
X: (2 1) 18-19 19-21 
O: (5 3) 11-6 8-5 
X: (4 1) 18-19 20-24 
O: (5 5) 16-11 11-6 6-1 6-1 
X: (5 6) 4-9 9-15 
O: (1 4) 16-15 15-11 
X: (6 3) bar-3 3-9 
O: (6 6) 16-10 11-5 10-4 8-2 
X: (2 3) 9-11 11-14 
O: doubles
X: rejects
O: wins

Score is 2-6 in a 7 point match.
heledy is X - motif is O
O: (6 5) 24-18 18-13 
X: (5 2) 12-17 1-3 
O: (4 1) 13-9 9-8 
X: (2 4) 1-5 3-5 
O: (1 6) 13-7 8-7 
X: (5 3) 17-22 19-22 
O: (3 1) 24-21 8-7 
X: (5 3) 12-15 15-20 
O: (6 3) 21-15 6-3 
X: (6 4) 5-9 9-15 
O: (1 6) bar-24 13-7 
X: (5 6) 5-11 15-20 
O: (6 5) 24-18 18-13 
X: (2 4) 11-15 17-19 
O: (4 6) 13-7 7-3 
X: (5 1) 12-17 17-18 
O: (5 6) 8-2 7-2 
X: (5 6) 12-18 12-17 
O: (1 1) 7-6 7-6 7-6 6-5 
X: (2 3) 17-20 17-19 
O: (4 3) 13-10 8-4 
X: (3 4) 15-19 18-21 
O: (6 2) 13-7 7-5 
X: (3 5) 17-20 18-23 
O: (2 1) 13-12 6-4 
X: (5 4) 20-off 21-off 
O: (5 5) 12-7 10-5 7-2 5-off 
X: (6 3) 19-off 22-off 
O: (5 6) 6-off 5-off 
X: (3 1) 20-21 22-off 
O: (4 5) 5-off 4-off 
X: (2 6) 19-off 23-off 
O: (6 6) 6-off 6-off 6-off 6-off 
X: (6 5) 19-off 20-off 
O: (6 6) 4-off 3-off 3-off 2-off 
X: (5 5) 19-24 19-24 19-24 20-off 
O: wins