[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
www/philosophy/po software-patents.es.po
From: |
Dora Scilipoti |
Subject: |
www/philosophy/po software-patents.es.po |
Date: |
Sat, 17 Dec 2022 14:08:56 -0500 (EST) |
CVSROOT: /web/www
Module name: www
Changes by: Dora Scilipoti <dora> 22/12/17 14:08:56
Modified files:
philosophy/po : software-patents.es.po
Log message:
Update.
CVSWeb URLs:
http://web.cvs.savannah.gnu.org/viewcvs/www/philosophy/po/software-patents.es.po?cvsroot=www&r1=1.37&r2=1.38
Patches:
Index: software-patents.es.po
===================================================================
RCS file: /web/www/www/philosophy/po/software-patents.es.po,v
retrieving revision 1.37
retrieving revision 1.38
diff -u -b -r1.37 -r1.38
--- software-patents.es.po 13 Dec 2022 14:30:41 -0000 1.37
+++ software-patents.es.po 17 Dec 2022 19:08:55 -0000 1.38
@@ -2,21 +2,20 @@
# Copyright (C) 2004, 2014, 2019-2022 Free Software Foundation, Inc.
# This file is distributed under the same license as the original article.
# Traducido originalmente por la editorial Traficantes de Sueños, 2004.
-# Dora Scilipoti <dora AT gnu DOT org>, 2014, 2020.
+# Dora Scilipoti <dora AT gnu DOT org>, 2014, 2020, 2022.
# Javier Fdez. Retenaga <jfrtnaga@gnu.org>, 2019-2022.
#
msgid ""
msgstr ""
"Project-Id-Version: software-patents.html\n"
-"POT-Creation-Date: 2022-12-13 14:25+0000\n"
-"PO-Revision-Date: 2022-11-13 11:05+0100\n"
-"Last-Translator: Javier Fdez. Retenaga <jfrtnaga@gnu.org>\n"
+"POT-Creation-Date: 2022-12-17 19:44+0100\n"
+"PO-Revision-Date: 2022-12-17 19:29+0100\n"
+"Last-Translator: Dora Scilipoti <dora AT gnu DOT org>\n"
"Language-Team: Spanish <www-es-general@gnu.org>\n"
"Language: es\n"
"MIME-Version: 1.0\n"
-"Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8\n"
+"Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8\n"
"Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit\n"
-"X-Outdated-Since: 2022-12-12 19:55+0000\n"
"X-Generator: Poedit 2.4.2\n"
#. type: Content of: <title>
@@ -24,10 +23,6 @@
msgstr "Patentes de software - Proyecto GNU - Free Software Foundation"
#. type: Content of: <div><h2>
-# | Software [-p-]{+P+}atents — Obstacles to [-software development-]
-# | {+Software Development+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid "Software patents — Obstacles to software development"
msgid "Software Patents — Obstacles to Software Development"
msgstr "Patentes de software: Un obstáculo para el desarrollo de software"
@@ -50,19 +45,6 @@
"\"><cite>Foundation for Information Policy Research</cite></a>."
#. type: Content of: <div><div><p>
-# | Transcript (<a
-# | href=\"https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~mgk25/stallman-patents.html\">original
-# | version</a>) and <a
-# | [-href=\"/audio-video/philosophy-recordings.html#rms-200203250\">audio-]
-# |
{+href=\"//audio-video.gnu.org/audio/rms-speech-cambridgeuni-england2002.ogg\">audio+}
-# | recording</a> by Nicholas Hill. HTML editing and links by Markus [-Kuhn.-]
-# | {+Kuhn and GNU webmasters.+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Transcript (<a href=\"https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~mgk25/stallman-patents."
-#| "html\">original version</a>) and <a href=\"/audio-video/philosophy-"
-#| "recordings.html#rms-200203250\">audio recording</a> by Nicholas Hill. "
-#| "HTML editing and links by Markus Kuhn."
msgid ""
"Transcript (<a href=\"https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~mgk25/stallman-patents.html"
"\">original version</a>) and <a href=\"//audio-video.gnu.org/audio/rms-"
@@ -70,9 +52,10 @@
"HTML editing and links by Markus Kuhn and GNU webmasters."
msgstr ""
"Transcripción (<a href=\"https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~mgk25/stallman-patents."
-"html\">versión original</a>) y <a href=\"/audio-video/philosophy-recordings."
-"html#rms-200203250\">grabación de audio</a> de Nicholas Hill. Edición HTML
y "
-"enlaces de Markus Kuhn."
+"html\">versión original</a>) y <a href=\"//audio-video.gnu.org/audio/rms-"
+"speech-cambridgeuni-england2002.ogg\">grabación de audio</a> de Nicholas "
+"Hill. Edición HTML y enlaces de Markus Kuhn y administradores del sitio de "
+"GNU."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
@@ -92,27 +75,6 @@
"software."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | [-It is-]{+It's+} not about patenting software. [-That is-] {+That's+} a
-# | very bad way, a misleading way to describe it, because [-it is-] {+it's+}
-# | not a matter of patenting individual programs. If it were, it would make
-# | no difference, it would be basically harmless. Instead, [-it is-]
-# | {+it's+} about patenting ideas. Every patent covers some idea. <a
-# |
href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20150329143651/http://progfree.org/Patents/patents.html\">
-# | Software patents</a> are patents that cover software ideas, ideas
-# | [-which-] {+that+} you would use in developing software. [-That is-]
-# | {+That's+} what makes them a dangerous obstacle to all software
-# | development.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "It is not about patenting software. That is a very bad way, a misleading "
-#| "way to describe it, because it is not a matter of patenting individual "
-#| "programs. If it were, it would make no difference, it would be basically "
-#| "harmless. Instead, it is about patenting ideas. Every patent covers "
-#| "some idea. <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20150329143651/http://"
-#| "progfree.org/Patents/patents.html\"> Software patents</a> are patents "
-#| "that cover software ideas, ideas which you would use in developing "
-#| "software. That is what makes them a dangerous obstacle to all software "
-#| "development."
msgid ""
"It's not about patenting software. That's a very bad way, a misleading way "
"to describe it, because it's not a matter of patenting individual programs. "
@@ -134,9 +96,6 @@
"obstáculos para el desarrollo de software."
#. type: Content of: <div><div><h3>
-# | Table of [-C-]{+c+}ontents
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid "Table of Contents"
msgid "Table of contents"
msgstr "Ãndice general"
@@ -145,78 +104,56 @@
"<a href=\"#copyright-vs-patent\">Differences between copyrights and patents</"
"a>"
msgstr ""
+"<a href=\"#copyright-vs-patent\">Diferencias entre copyright y patentes</a>"
#. type: Content of: <div><div><ul><li>
-# | <a [-href=\"/education/edu-team.html\">The Education Team</a>-]
-# | {+href=\"#patent-system\">The patent system</a>+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid "<a href=\"/education/edu-team.html\">The Education Team</a>"
msgid "<a href=\"#patent-system\">The patent system</a>"
-msgstr "<a href=\"/education/edu-team.html\">Nuestro equipo</a>"
+msgstr "<a href=\"#patent-system\">El sistema de patentes</a>"
#. type: Content of: <div><div><ul><li>
msgid ""
"<a href=\"#dealing-with-patents\">How a developer can deal with patents</a>"
msgstr ""
+"<a href=\"#dealing-with-patents\">Cómo puede un desarrollador afrontar las "
+"patentes</a>"
#. type: Content of: <div><div><ul><li><ul><li>
msgid "<a href=\"#patent-avoiding\">Avoiding the patent</a>"
-msgstr ""
+msgstr "<a href=\"#patent-avoiding\">Evitar la patente</a>"
#. type: Content of: <div><div><ul><li><ul><li>
msgid "<a href=\"#patent-licensing\">Licensing the patent</a>"
-msgstr ""
+msgstr "<a href=\"#patent-licensing\">Obtener la licencia de la patente</a>"
#. type: Content of: <div><div><ul><li><ul><li>
-# | [-Overturning-]{+<a href=\"#patent-overturning\">Overturning+} the patent
-# | in [-court.-] {+court</a>+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid "Overturning the patent in court."
msgid "<a href=\"#patent-overturning\">Overturning the patent in court</a>"
-msgstr "Revocar la patente en los tribunales"
+msgstr ""
+"<a href=\"#patent-overturning\">Revocar la patente en los tribunales</a>"
#. type: Content of: <div><div><ul><li>
msgid ""
"<a href=\"#software-specificity\">Specificities of the software field</a>"
msgstr ""
+"<a href=\"#software-specificity\">CaracterÃsticas del área de la "
+"programación</a>"
#. type: Content of: <div><div><ul><li>
msgid ""
"<a href=\"#software-patent-policies\">Addressing the problem of software "
"patents in public policies</a>"
msgstr ""
+"<a href=\"#software-patent-policies\">Cómo abordar el problema de las "
+"patentes de software en las polÃticas públicas</a>"
#. type: Content of: <div><div><ul><li>
msgid "<a href=\"#footnotes\">Footnotes</a>"
-msgstr ""
+msgstr "<a href=\"#footnotes\">Notas</a>"
#. type: Content of: <div><h3>
msgid "Differences between copyrights and patents"
-msgstr ""
+msgstr "Diferencias entre copyright y patentes"
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | You may have heard people [-using-] {+use+} a misleading term “<a
-# | [-href=\"https://www.wipo.org/about-ip/en/\">Intellectual
-# | Property</a>.”-]
-# | {+href=\"https://www.wipo.org/about-ip/en/\">intellectual
-# | property</a>.”+} This term, as you can see, is [-biased. It-]
-# | {+biased, because it+} makes an [-assumption that-] {+assumption:+}
-# | whatever it is you are talking about, the way to treat it is as a kind of
-# | property, which is one among many alternatives. This term
-# | [-“Intellectual Property”-] {+“intellectual
-# | property”+} pre-judges the most basic question in whatever area you
-# | are dealing with. [-This is-] {+That's+} not conducive to clear and open
-# | minded thinking.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "You may have heard people using a misleading term “<a href="
-#| "\"https://www.wipo.org/about-ip/en/\">Intellectual Property</a>.” "
-#| "This term, as you can see, is biased. It makes an assumption that "
-#| "whatever it is you are talking about, the way to treat it is as a kind of "
-#| "property, which is one among many alternatives. This term “"
-#| "Intellectual Property” pre-judges the most basic question in "
-#| "whatever area you are dealing with. This is not conducive to clear and "
-#| "open minded thinking."
msgid ""
"You may have heard people use a misleading term “<a href=\"https://www."
"wipo.org/about-ip/en/\">intellectual property</a>.” This term, as you "
@@ -228,36 +165,14 @@
msgstr ""
"Probablemente hayan oÃdo una expresión engañosa, «<a
href=\"https://www.wipo."
"org/about-ip/en/\">propiedad intelectual</a>». Como pueden ver, es una "
-"expresión sesgada. Da por sentado que, sea cual fuere la cosa de la que se "
-"está hablando, ha de considerarse como un tipo de propiedad, cuando en "
-"realidad esa es solo una entre muchas otras posibilidades. Con la expresión "
-"«propiedad intelectual» se prejuzga lo más básico en cualquier ámbito
que se "
-"esté considerando. No contribuye a pensar de forma clara y con amplitud de "
-"miras."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | [-There-]{+But there+} is an additional problem which has nothing to do
-# | with promoting any one opinion. It gets in the way of understanding even
-# | the facts. The term “intellectual property” is a catch-all.
-# | It lumps together {+various+} completely disparate areas of law{+,+} such
-# | as copyrights and patents, which are completely [-different. Every-]
-# | {+different from copyrights (every+} detail is [-different. It also lumps
-# | together trademarks-] {+different), and trademarks,+} which are even more
-# | different, and various other things more or less commonly encountered.
-# | None of them has anything in common with any of the others. Their
-# | [-origins historically-] {+origins, historically,+} are completely
-# | separate.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "There is an additional problem which has nothing to do with promoting any "
-#| "one opinion. It gets in the way of understanding even the facts. The "
-#| "term “intellectual property” is a catch-all. It lumps "
-#| "together completely disparate areas of law such as copyrights and "
-#| "patents, which are completely different. Every detail is different. It "
-#| "also lumps together trademarks which are even more different, and various "
-#| "other things more or less commonly encountered. None of them has "
-#| "anything in common with any of the others. Their origins historically "
-#| "are completely separate."
+"expresión sesgada porque da por sentado que, sea cual fuere la cosa de la "
+"que se está hablando, ha de considerarse como un tipo de propiedad, cuando "
+"en realidad esa es solo una entre muchas otras posibilidades. Con la "
+"expresión «propiedad intelectual» se prejuzga la cuestión más básica en
"
+"cualquier ámbito que se esté considerando. No contribuye a pensar de forma "
+"clara y con amplitud de miras."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
"But there is an additional problem which has nothing to do with promoting "
"any one opinion. It gets in the way of understanding even the facts. The "
@@ -279,26 +194,6 @@
"Históricamente, sus orÃgenes no tienen ninguna relación."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | The laws were designed independently. They [-covered-] {+cover+}
-# | different areas of life and [-activities. The-] {+activities, and the+}
-# | public policy issues they raise are completely unrelated. So, if you try
-# | to think about them by lumping them together, you are guaranteed to come
-# | to foolish conclusions. [-There-] {+Whatever they might be, there+} is
-# | literally no sensible {+or+} intelligent opinion you can have about
-# | [-“Intellectual Property.” If-] {+“intellectual
-# | property.” So, if+} you want to think clearly, don't lump them
-# | together. Think about copyrights{+,+} and then think about patents.
-# | Learn about copyright law{+,+} and separately{+,+} learn about patent law.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "The laws were designed independently. They covered different areas of "
-#| "life and activities. The public policy issues they raise are completely "
-#| "unrelated. So, if you try to think about them by lumping them together, "
-#| "you are guaranteed to come to foolish conclusions. There is literally no "
-#| "sensible intelligent opinion you can have about “Intellectual "
-#| "Property.” If you want to think clearly, don't lump them together. "
-#| "Think about copyrights and then think about patents. Learn about "
-#| "copyright law and separately learn about patent law."
msgid ""
"The laws were designed independently. They cover different areas of life "
"and activities, and the public policy issues they raise are completely "
@@ -309,7 +204,7 @@
"lump them together. Think about copyrights, and then think about patents. "
"Learn about copyright law, and separately, learn about patent law."
msgstr ""
-"Esas leyes se diseñaron de manera independiente y cubrÃan diferentes "
+"Esas leyes se diseñaron de manera independiente. Cubren diferentes "
"actividades y aspectos de la vida, lo que dio lugar a medidas polÃticas sin "
"ninguna relación entre sÃ. Si intentamos analizarlas metiéndolas todas en
el "
"mismo saco, seguramente llegaremos a conclusiones disparatadas. No se puede "
@@ -322,6 +217,8 @@
msgid ""
"To give you some of the biggest differences between copyrights and patents:"
msgstr ""
+"Por citar algunas de las mayores diferencias entre el copyright y las "
+"patentes:"
#. type: Content of: <div><ul><li><p>
msgid ""
@@ -329,21 +226,11 @@
"any ideas. It's a {legal fault} to consider copyrights as covering any idea. "
"But patents <em>only</em> cover ideas and the use of ideas."
msgstr ""
+"El copyright cubre la expresión particular de una obra, no las ideas. Es un "
+"error legal considerar que el copyright cubre las ideas. Las patentes, en "
+"cambio, cubren <em>únicamente </em> ideas y el uso de las ideas."
#. type: Content of: <div><ul><li><p>
-# | {+Copyrights happen automatically.+} Patents [-cost-] {+are issued by a
-# | patent office in response to an application. It costs+} a lot of money.
-# | [-They cost-] {+And it costs+} even more paying the lawyers to write the
-# | application than [-they cost-] {+it costs+} to actually apply. It takes
-# | typically some years for the application to get considered, even though
-# | patent offices {+typically+} do an extremely sloppy job of
-# | [-considering.-] {+considering them.+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Patents cost a lot of money. They cost even more paying the lawyers to "
-#| "write the application than they cost to actually apply. It takes "
-#| "typically some years for the application to get considered, even though "
-#| "patent offices do an extremely sloppy job of considering."
msgid ""
"Copyrights happen automatically. Patents are issued by a patent office in "
"response to an application. It costs a lot of money. And it costs even "
@@ -352,23 +239,14 @@
"even though patent offices typically do an extremely sloppy job of "
"considering them."
msgstr ""
-"Las patentes cuestan mucho dinero. Es mayor incluso el precio que hay que "
-"pagar a los abogados para que redacten la solicitud que lo que hay que "
-"abonar al presentarla. Normalmente la solicitud tarda algunos años en ser "
-"estudiada, aun cuando las oficinas de patentes las examinan de manera muy "
-"descuidada."
+"El copyright se aplica automáticamente, mientras las patentes las otorga la "
+"oficina de patentes en respuesta a una solicitud. Cuesta mucho dinero, y "
+"pagar a los abogados para que redacten la solicitud cuesta aún más que lo "
+"que hay que abonar al presentarla. Normalmente la solicitud tarda algunos "
+"años en ser estudiada, aun cuando las oficinas de patentes las examinan de "
+"manera muy descuidada."
#. type: Content of: <div><ul><li><p>
-# | Copyrights last tremendously long. [-In-] {+Nowadays, in+} some cases
-# | they can last as long as 150 years, [-where-] {+whereas+} patents last
-# | {+for+} 20 years, which is long enough that you can outlive them{+,+} but
-# | still quite long by a timescale of a field such as software.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Copyrights last tremendously long. In some cases they can last as long "
-#| "as 150 years, where patents last 20 years, which is long enough that you "
-#| "can outlive them but still quite long by a timescale of a field such as "
-#| "software."
msgid ""
"Copyrights last tremendously long. Nowadays, in some cases they can last as "
"long as 150 years, whereas patents last for 20 years, which is long enough "
@@ -377,18 +255,10 @@
msgstr ""
"El copyright dura muchÃsimo tiempo. En algunos casos puede durar hasta 150 "
"años. Las patentes, por el contrario, duran 20 años, lo cual no es tanto "
-"como para que sobrevivan a su titular, pero es demasiado para la escala "
+"como para que sobrevivan a su dueño, pero es demasiado para la escala "
"temporal de un ámbito como el del software."
#. type: Content of: <div><ul><li><p>
-# | Think back [-about-] 20 years [-ago when a-] {+ago; the+} PC was a new
-# | thing. Imagine being constrained to develop software using only the ideas
-# | that were known in 1982.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Think back about 20 years ago when a PC was a new thing. Imagine being "
-#| "constrained to develop software using only the ideas that were known in "
-#| "1982."
msgid ""
"Think back 20 years ago; the PC was a new thing. Imagine being constrained "
"to develop software using only the ideas that were known in 1982."
@@ -398,17 +268,6 @@
"las ideas ya conocidas en 1982."
#. type: Content of: <div><ul><li><p>
-# | Copyrights cover copying. If you write a novel that turns out to be
-# | word-for-word the same [-with-] {+as+} <cite>Gone with the [-Wind</cite>
-# | and-] {+Wind</cite>, but+} you can prove you never saw <cite>Gone with the
-# | Wind</cite>, {+and that you wrote it on your own,+} that would be a
-# | defense to any accusation of copyright infringement.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Copyrights cover copying. If you write a novel that turns out to be word-"
-#| "for-word the same with <cite>Gone with the Wind</cite> and you can prove "
-#| "you never saw <cite>Gone with the Wind</cite>, that would be a defense to "
-#| "any accusation of copyright infringement."
msgid ""
"Copyrights cover copying. If you write a novel that turns out to be word-"
"for-word the same as <cite>Gone with the Wind</cite>, but you can prove you "
@@ -416,43 +275,22 @@
"own, that would be a defense to any accusation of copyright infringement."
msgstr ""
"El copyright cubre la copia. Si alguien escribe una novela que resulta ser "
-"idéntica, palabra por palabra, a <i>Lo que el viento se llevó</i> y puede "
-"demostrar que nunca antes habÃa visto <i>Lo que el viento se llevó</i>, eso
"
-"le servirÃa para defenderse ante cualquier acusación de infracción de "
-"copyright."
+"idéntica, palabra por palabra, a <cite>Lo que el viento se llevó</cite> y "
+"puede demostrar que nunca antes habÃa visto <cite>Lo que el viento se
llevó</"
+"cite>, eso le servirÃa para defenderse ante cualquier acusación de "
+"infracción de copyright."
#. type: Content of: <div><ul><li><p>
-# | [-A-]{+But a+} patent is an absolute monopoly on using an idea. Even if
-# | you could prove {+that+} you had the idea on your own, it would be
-# | entirely irrelevant if the idea is patented by somebody else.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "A patent is an absolute monopoly on using an idea. Even if you could "
-#| "prove you had the idea on your own, it would be entirely irrelevant if "
-#| "the idea is patented by somebody else."
msgid ""
"But a patent is an absolute monopoly on using an idea. Even if you could "
"prove that you had the idea on your own, it would be entirely irrelevant if "
"the idea is patented by somebody else."
msgstr ""
-"Una patente es un monopolio absoluto sobre el uso de una idea. Aun cuando "
-"alguien pueda probar que concibió la idea por sà mismo, no servirÃa de
nada "
-"si la idea ya ha sido patentada por otra persona."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | I hope you will {+basically just+} forget about copyrights for the rest of
-# | this talk{+,+} because this talk is about patents and you should never
-# | lump together copyrights and patents. [-It is about your-] {+Your+}
-# | understanding of these legal [-issues. It is-] {+issues would be about+}
-# | like what would happen in your understanding of practical chemistry if you
-# | confused water and ethanol.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "I hope you will forget about copyrights for the rest of this talk because "
-#| "this talk is about patents and you should never lump together copyrights "
-#| "and patents. It is about your understanding of these legal issues. It is "
-#| "like what would happen in your understanding of practical chemistry if "
-#| "you confused water and ethanol."
+"Una patente, por otro lado, es un monopolio absoluto sobre el uso de una "
+"idea. Aun cuando alguien pueda probar que concibió la idea por sà mismo, no
"
+"servirÃa de nada si la idea ya ha sido patentada por otra persona."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
"I hope you will basically just forget about copyrights for the rest of this "
"talk, because this talk is about patents and you should never lump together "
@@ -468,28 +306,9 @@
#. type: Content of: <div><h3>
msgid "The patent system"
-msgstr ""
+msgstr "El sistema de patentes"
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | When you hear people describe the patent system, they usually describe it
-# | from the point of view of somebody who is hoping to get a patent[---]{+:+}
-# | what it would be like for you to get a [-patent. What-] {+patent; what+}
-# | it would be like for you to be walking down the street with a patent in
-# | your pocket{+,+} so that every so often you can pull it out and point it
-# | out at somebody and say “Give Me Your Money!” There is a
-# | reason for this bias, which is that most of the people who will tell you
-# | about this patent system have a stake in it, so they want you {+to+} like
-# | it.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "When you hear people describe the patent system, they usually describe it "
-#| "from the point of view of somebody who is hoping to get a patent- what it "
-#| "would be like for you to get a patent. What it would be like for you to "
-#| "be walking down the street with a patent in your pocket so that every so "
-#| "often you can pull it out and point it out at somebody and say “"
-#| "Give Me Your Money!” There is a reason for this bias, which is that "
-#| "most of the people who will tell you about this patent system have a "
-#| "stake in it, so they want you like it."
msgid ""
"When you hear people describe the patent system, they usually describe it "
"from the point of view of somebody who is hoping to get a patent: what it "
@@ -502,33 +321,13 @@
msgstr ""
"Cuando alguien nos habla del sistema de patentes, normalmente lo hace desde "
"el punto de vista de quien espera obtener una patente. Nos cuenta lo que se "
-"consigue al obtener una patente, cómo serÃa si pudiéramos ir por la calle "
+"podrÃa conseguir con una patente, cómo serÃa si pudiéramos ir por la
calle "
"con una patente en el bolsillo y, de vez en cuando, apuntar a alguien con "
-"ella y decirle: «¡Deme su dinero!». Este sesgo tiene su razón de ser, y
es "
+"ella y decirle: «¡Dame su dinero!». Este sesgo tiene su razón de ser, y
es "
"que la mayorÃa de la gente que le hablará acerca de este sistema de
patentes "
"tiene intereses en él, y quiere que a usted le guste."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | There is another [-reason—the-] {+reason: the+} patent system is a
-# | lot like a lottery because only a tiny fraction of patents actually bring
-# | any benefit to those who hold the patents. In fact, <cite><a
-# | href=\"https://www.economist.com/leaders/2011/08/20/patent-medicine\"> The
-# | Economist</a></cite> once compared it to a time consuming lottery. If you
-# | have seen ads for lotteries, they always invite you to think about
-# | winning. They don't invite you to think about losing, even though losing
-# | is far more likely. [-It is-] {+It's+} the same with ads for the patent
-# | system. They always invite you to think about being the one who wins.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "There is another reason—the patent system is a lot like a lottery "
-#| "because only a tiny fraction of patents actually bring any benefit to "
-#| "those who hold the patents. In fact, <cite><a href=\"https://www."
-#| "economist.com/leaders/2011/08/20/patent-medicine\"> The Economist</a></"
-#| "cite> once compared it to a time consuming lottery. If you have seen ads "
-#| "for lotteries, they always invite you to think about winning. They don't "
-#| "invite you to think about losing, even though losing is far more likely. "
-#| "It is the same with ads for the patent system. They always invite you to "
-#| "think about being the one who wins."
msgid ""
"There is another reason: the patent system is a lot like a lottery because "
"only a tiny fraction of patents actually bring any benefit to those who hold "
@@ -565,26 +364,6 @@
"demanda judicial."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | So, [-what is-] {+what's+} the first thing you are going to do after you
-# | have had an idea of what kind of program you are going to write? The first
-# | thing you might want to try to do to deal with the patent system is find
-# | out what patents may cover the program you want to write. This is
-# | impossible. The reason is that some of the patent applications that are
-# | pending are secret. After a certain amount of time they may get
-# | published, like 18 months. But [-that is-] {+that's+} plenty of time for
-# | you to write a program and even release it{+,+} not knowing that there is
-# | going to be a patent and you are going to get sued.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "So, what is the first thing you are going to do after you have had an "
-#| "idea of what kind of program you are going to write? The first thing you "
-#| "might want to try to do to deal with the patent system is find out what "
-#| "patents may cover the program you want to write. This is impossible. The "
-#| "reason is that some of the patent applications that are pending are "
-#| "secret. After a certain amount of time they may get published, like 18 "
-#| "months. But that is plenty of time for you to write a program and even "
-#| "release it not knowing that there is going to be a patent and you are "
-#| "going to get sued."
msgid ""
"So, what's the first thing you are going to do after you have had an idea of "
"what kind of program you are going to write? The first thing you might want "
@@ -595,40 +374,17 @@
"plenty of time for you to write a program and even release it, not knowing "
"that there is going to be a patent and you are going to get sued."
msgstr ""
-"Veamos, ¿qué es lo primero que habrÃa que hacer una vez que se tiene una "
-"idea del tipo de programa que se va a escribir? Lo primero que quizá se "
-"quiera hacer para lidiar con el sistema de patentes es descubrir qué "
-"patentes pueden cubrir el programa que se quiere escribir. Pero esto es "
-"imposible. La razón de ello es que algunas de las solicitudes de patente que
"
-"están pendientes son secretas. Pueden publicarse después de cierto tiempo, "
-"por ejemplo 18 meses. Pero eso es tiempo suficiente para escribir el "
-"programa e incluso publicarlo, sin saber que va a haber una patente y que "
-"nos van a presentar una demanda."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | This is not just academic. In 1984, the [-c-]{+C+}ompress program was
-# | [-written,-] {+written (it was+} a program for data compression.{+)+} At
-# | the time, there was no patent on the LZW compression algorithm which it
-# | used. Then in 1985, the US issued a <a
-# | href=\"https://patents.justia.com/patent/4558302\">patent</a> on this
-# | algorithm{+,+} and over the next few years, those who distributed the
-# | [-c-]{+C+}ompress program started getting threats. There was no way that
-# | the author of [-c-]{+C+}ompress could have realized [-that-] he was likely
-# | to get sued. All he did was use an idea that he found in a journal{+,+}
-# | just like programmers have always done. He hadn't realized that you could
-# | no longer safely use ideas that you found in a journal.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "This is not just academic. In 1984, the compress program was written, a "
-#| "program for data compression. At the time, there was no patent on the "
-#| "LZW compression algorithm which it used. Then in 1985, the US issued a "
-#| "<a href=\"https://patents.justia.com/patent/4558302\">patent</a> on this "
-#| "algorithm and over the next few years, those who distributed the compress "
-#| "program started getting threats. There was no way that the author of "
-#| "compress could have realized that he was likely to get sued. All he did "
-#| "was use an idea that he found in a journal just like programmers have "
-#| "always done. He hadn't realized that you could no longer safely use "
-#| "ideas that you found in a journal."
+"Veamos entonces, ¿qué es lo primero que habrÃa que hacer una vez que se "
+"tiene una idea del tipo de programa que se va a escribir? Lo primero que "
+"quizá se quiera hacer para lidiar con el sistema de patentes es descubrir "
+"qué patentes pueden cubrir el programa que se quiere escribir. Pero esto es "
+"imposible, porque algunas de las solicitudes de patente que están pendientes
"
+"son secretas. Pueden publicarse después de cierto tiempo, por ejemplo 18 "
+"meses. Pero eso es tiempo suficiente para escribir el programa e incluso "
+"publicarlo, sin saber que va a haber una patente y que nos van a presentar "
+"una demanda."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
"This is not just academic. In 1984, the Compress program was written (it "
"was a program for data compression.) At the time, there was no patent on "
@@ -644,32 +400,16 @@
"Esto no es una mera hipótesis. En 1984 se escribió el programa Compress, un
"
"programa para la compresión de datos. En aquel momento no habÃa ninguna "
"patente para el algoritmo de compresión LZW que utilizaba. Más tarde, en "
-"1985, EE. UU. emitió una patente sobre este algoritmo, y durante los "
-"años siguientes los que distribuÃan el programa Compress empezaron a
recibir "
+"1985, EE. UU. emitió una <a href=\"https://patents.justia.com/"
+"patent/4558302\">patente</a> sobre este algoritmo, y durante los años "
+"siguientes los que distribuÃan el programa Compress empezaron a recibir "
"amenazas. No habÃa forma de que el autor de Compress se hubiera dado cuenta "
"de que podÃa ser demandado. Todo lo que hizo fue usar una idea que encontró
"
-"en una revista, como siempre han hecho los programadores. No se dio cuenta "
-"de que ya no se podÃan usar sin peligro las ideas que se encontraban en una "
-"revista."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | [-Let's-]{+But let's+} forget about that problem… The issued
-# | patents are published by the patent office{+,+} so you can find the whole
-# | long list of them and see exactly what they say. Of course, you couldn't
-# | actually read that whole list as there are too many of them. In the US,
-# | there are hundreds of thousands of software [-patents.-] {+patents, and
-# | there is no way you could keep track of what they are all about. So you'd
-# | have to try to search for relevant ones. Some people say that should be
-# | easy in these modern days of computers. You could search for keywords and
-# | so on. Well, that will work to a certain extent. You will find some
-# | patents in the area. You won't necessarily find them all, however.+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Let's forget about that problem… The issued patents are published "
-#| "by the patent office so you can find the whole long list of them and see "
-#| "exactly what they say. Of course, you couldn't actually read that whole "
-#| "list as there are too many of them. In the US, there are hundreds of "
-#| "thousands of software patents."
+"en una revista, como siempre han hecho los programadores. No se habÃa dado "
+"cuenta de que ya no se podÃan usar sin peligro las ideas que se encontraban "
+"en una revista."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
"But let's forget about that problem… The issued patents are published "
"by the patent office, so you can find the whole long list of them and see "
@@ -682,33 +422,13 @@
"extent. You will find some patents in the area. You won't necessarily find "
"them all, however."
msgstr ""
-"Dejemos a un lado este problema... La oficina de patentes publica las "
+"Pero dejemos a un lado ese problema... La oficina de patentes publica las "
"patentes emitidas, de modo que se puede consultar toda su larga lista y ver "
"exactamente lo que dicen. Pero, por supuesto, no serÃa posible leer la lista
"
"entera porque son demasiadas. En EE. UU. hay cientos de miles de "
"patentes de software."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | {+For instance, there was a software patent which, I think, may have
-# | expired by now, on natural order recalculation in spreadsheets.+} This
-# | means basically that{+,+} when you make certain cells depend [-upon-]
-# | {+on+} other cells, it always recalculates everything after the things it
-# | depends on, so that after one [-re-calculation,-] {+recalculation+}
-# | everything is up to date. The first spread[- -]sheets did their
-# | recalculation top-down, so if you made a cell depend on a cell {+that
-# | was+} lower down, and you had a few such steps, you had to recalculate
-# | several times to get the new values to propagate upwards. You were
-# | supposed to have things depend [-upon-] {+on+} cells above [-them.-]
-# | {+them, you see.+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "This means basically that when you make certain cells depend upon other "
-#| "cells, it always recalculates everything after the things it depends on, "
-#| "so that after one re-calculation, everything is up to date. The first "
-#| "spread sheets did their recalculation top-down, so if you made a cell "
-#| "depend on a cell lower down, and you had a few such steps, you had to "
-#| "recalculate several times to get the new values to propagate upwards. "
-#| "You were supposed to have things depend upon cells above them."
msgid ""
"For instance, there was a software patent which, I think, may have expired "
"by now, on natural order recalculation in spreadsheets. This means "
@@ -720,42 +440,18 @@
"times to get the new values to propagate upwards. You were supposed to have "
"things depend on cells above them, you see."
msgstr ""
-"Esto significa básicamente que cuando se hace que ciertas celdas dependan de
"
+"Por ejemplo, habÃa una patente de software, que quizá haya ya expirado, "
+"sobre el «recálculo en orden natural» en las hojas de cálculo. Esto "
+"significa básicamente que cuando se hace que ciertas celdas dependan de "
"otras todo se vuelve a calcular en función de aquello de lo que depende, de "
-"modo que después de una operación de cálculo todo queda actualizado. Las "
-"primeras hojas de cálculo hacÃan sus operaciones de arriba a abajo, de "
+"modo que después de una operación de recálculo todo queda actualizado. Las
"
+"primeras hojas de cálculo hacÃan el recálculo de arriba hacia abajo, de "
"manera que si se hacÃa que una celda dependiera de otra situada más abajo,
y "
"esto se repetÃa varias veces, habÃa que recalcular todo varias veces para "
"que los nuevos valores se extendieran hacia arriba. HabÃa que disponer los "
"elementos de manera que dependieran de las celdas superiores."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | Then [-someone realized why-] {+somebody realized, “Why+} don't I
-# | {+just+} do the [-recalculation so that everything-] {+recalculation.
-# | Everything+} gets recalculated after the things it depends [-upon?-] {+on.
-# | Do it in the right order, and they will all be up to date.”+} This
-# | algorithm is known as topological sorting. The first reference to it I
-# | could find was in 1963. The patent covered several dozen different ways
-# | you could implement topological sorting{+,+} but you wouldn't have found
-# | this patent by searching for [-spreadsheet.-] {+“spreadsheet,”
-# | because it didn't mention that word.+} You couldn't have found it [-by
-# | searching for natural order-] {+to “natural order”+} or
-# | [-topological sort. It-] {+“topological sort,” because it+}
-# | didn't have any of those terms in it. In fact, it was described as a
-# | [-method-] {+“method+} of compiling formulas into object [-code.
-# | When-] {+code.” I think when+} I first saw it, I thought it was the
-# | wrong patent.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Then someone realized why don't I do the recalculation so that everything "
-#| "gets recalculated after the things it depends upon? This algorithm is "
-#| "known as topological sorting. The first reference to it I could find was "
-#| "in 1963. The patent covered several dozen different ways you could "
-#| "implement topological sorting but you wouldn't have found this patent by "
-#| "searching for spreadsheet. You couldn't have found it by searching for "
-#| "natural order or topological sort. It didn't have any of those terms in "
-#| "it. In fact, it was described as a method of compiling formulas into "
-#| "object code. When I first saw it, I thought it was the wrong patent."
msgid ""
"Then somebody realized, “Why don't I just do the recalculation. "
"Everything gets recalculated after the things it depends on. Do it in the "
@@ -769,32 +465,20 @@
"was described as a “method of compiling formulas into object code."
"” I think when I first saw it, I thought it was the wrong patent."
msgstr ""
-"Entonces alguien pensó que por qué no realizar las operaciones de cálculo
de "
-"modo que cada elemento se calcule en función del elemento del que depende. "
-"Este algoritmo se conoce como clasificación topológica. La primera "
-"referencia a él que he podido encontrar es de 1963. La patente cubrÃa
varias "
-"docenas de maneras diferentes de implementar la clasificación topológica, "
-"pero no se podrÃa haber encontrado esta patente buscando «hoja de
cálculo». "
-"Tampoco buscando «orden natural» o «clasificación topológica». En ella
no "
-"aparecÃan estos términos. Se describÃa como un método de compilar
fórmulas "
-"en código objeto. La primera vez que lo vi pensé que no era esa la patente "
+"Entonces alguien pensó: «¿Por qué no realizar las operaciones de
recálculo "
+"de modo que cada elemento se recalcule en función del elemento del que "
+"depende? Haciéndolo en el orden correcto, todos se actualizarán». Este "
+"algoritmo se conoce como clasificación topológica. La primera referencia a "
+"él que he podido encontrar es de 1963. La patente cubrÃa varias docenas de "
+"maneras diferentes de implementar la clasificación topológica, pero no se "
+"podrÃa haber encontrado esta patente buscando «hoja de cálculo», porque
no "
+"se mencionaba esa expresión. Tampoco buscando «orden natural» o "
+"«clasificación topológica» porque en la patente no aparecÃan estos
términos. "
+"De hecho, se describÃa como un «método de compilar fórmulas en código "
+"objeto». Creo que la primera vez que la vi pensé que no era esa la patente "
"que buscaba."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | [-Let's-]{+But let's+} suppose that you got a list of patents. So you
-# | want to see [-k-]now what you are not allowed to do. [-When you-] {+You+}
-# | try studying these [-patents,-] {+patents; well,+} you [-will-] discover
-# | [-they are-] {+it's+} very hard to understand [-as-] {+them, because+}
-# | they are written in tortuous legal language, whose meaning is very hard to
-# | understand. [-The-] {+In fact,+} things {+that+} patent offices say often
-# | don't mean what they seem to mean.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Let's suppose that you got a list of patents. So you want to see know "
-#| "what you are not allowed to do. When you try studying these patents, you "
-#| "will discover they are very hard to understand as they are written in "
-#| "tortuous legal language, whose meaning is very hard to understand. The "
-#| "things patent offices say often don't mean what they seem to mean."
msgid ""
"But let's suppose that you got a list of patents. So you want to see now "
"what you are not allowed to do. You try studying these patents; well, you "
@@ -803,30 +487,13 @@
"things that patent offices say often don't mean what they seem to mean."
msgstr ""
"Supongamos que disponemos de una lista de patentes y queremos saber qué nos "
-"está prohibido. Al tratar de estudiar estas patentes descubriremos que es "
+"está prohibido. Al tratar de estudiar estas patentes descubrimos que es "
"demasiado complicado entenderlas, ya que están escritas en un lenguaje legal
"
-"muy enrevesado cuyo significado es difÃcil comprender. Lo que dicen las "
-"oficinas de patentes a menudo no significa lo que parece significar."
+"muy enrevesado cuyo significado es difÃcil comprender. De hecho, lo que "
+"dicen las oficinas de patentes a menudo no significa lo que parece "
+"significar."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | There was an Australian government study of the patent system in the
-# | 1980's. It concluded that{+,+} aside from international pressure, there
-# | was no reason to have a patent [-system. It-] {+system—it+} did no
-# | good for the [-public and-] {+public—and+} recommended abolishing
-# | it{+,+} if not for international pressure. One of the things they cited
-# | was that engineers don't try reading patents to learn anything, [-as-]
-# | {+because+} it is too hard to understand them. They quoted one engineer
-# | saying “I can't recognize my own inventions in patenteese.”
-# | {+<i class=\"aside\">[laughs]</i>+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "There was an Australian government study of the patent system in the "
-#| "1980's. It concluded that aside from international pressure, there was "
-#| "no reason to have a patent system. It did no good for the public and "
-#| "recommended abolishing it if not for international pressure. One of the "
-#| "things they cited was that engineers don't try reading patents to learn "
-#| "anything, as it is too hard to understand them. They quoted one engineer "
-#| "saying “I can't recognize my own inventions in patenteese.”"
msgid ""
"There was an Australian government study of the patent system in the "
"1980's. It concluded that, aside from international pressure, there was no "
@@ -844,28 +511,10 @@
"internacional. Uno de los hechos que se señalaron fue que los ingenieros ni "
"siquiera intentan leer las patentes para averiguar algo, ya que resulta "
"demasiado complicado comprenderlas. Citaban a un ingeniero que decÃa: «No "
-"logro reconocer mis propias invenciones en las patentes»."
+"logro reconocer mis propias invenciones en el idioma de las patentes»."
+"” <i class=\"aside\">[risas]</i>"
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | This is not just theoretical. Around 1990, a programmer named <a
-# | href=\"https://www.atarimagazines.com/startv2n3/hypercard.html\">Paul
-# | Heckel</a> sued Apple{+,+} claiming that Hypercard infringed a couple of
-# | his <a href=\"https://patents.justia.com/patent/4486857\">patents</a>.
-# | When he first saw Hypercard, he didn't think it had anything to do with
-# | his [-patent, with his “Inventions.”-]
-# | {+“inventions.”+} It didn't look similar. [-When-] {+But+}
-# | his lawyer told him that you could read the patents as covering part of
-# | Hypercard, {+so+} he decided to {+then+} attack Apple.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "This is not just theoretical. Around 1990, a programmer named <a href="
-#| "\"https://www.atarimagazines.com/startv2n3/hypercard.html\">Paul Heckel</"
-#| "a> sued Apple claiming that Hypercard infringed a couple of his <a href="
-#| "\"https://patents.justia.com/patent/4486857\">patents</a>. When he first "
-#| "saw Hypercard, he didn't think it had anything to do with his patent, "
-#| "with his “Inventions.” It didn't look similar. When his "
-#| "lawyer told him that you could read the patents as covering part of "
-#| "Hypercard, he decided to attack Apple."
msgid ""
"This is not just theoretical. Around 1990, a programmer named <a href="
"\"https://www.atarimagazines.com/startv2n3/hypercard.html\">Paul Heckel</a> "
@@ -878,30 +527,14 @@
msgstr ""
"Esto no es una simple teorÃa. Hacia 1990, un programador llamado <a href="
"\"https://www.atarimagazines.com/startv2n3/hypercard.html\">Paul Heckel</a> "
-"demandó a Apple alegando que Hypercard infringÃa dos de sus patentes.
Cuando "
-"vio Hypercard por primera vez, no pensó que tuviera nada que ver con sus "
-"patentes, con sus «invenciones». No se parecÃan. Pero cuando su abogado le
"
-"dijo que se podÃa interpretar que las patentes se aplicaban a una parte de "
-"Hypercard, decidió atacar a Apple."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | When I [-had-] {+gave+} a speech about this at Stanford, he was in the
-# | [-audience,-] {+audience and+} he said “That's <a
-# |
href=\"https://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/classes/6.805/articles/int-prop/heckel-debunking.html\">
-# | not true</a>, I just didn't understand the extent of my protection!”
-# | {+<i class=\"aside\">[laughs]</i> And+} I [-said yes,-] {+said,
-# | “Yes,+} that's what I [-said! So, in fact, you will have to spend a
-# | lot of time talking with lawyers to figure out what these patents prohibit
-# | you from doing.-] {+said!” <i class=\"aside\">[laughs]</i>+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "When I had a speech about this at Stanford, he was in the audience, he "
-#| "said “That's <a href=\"https://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/"
-#| "classes/6.805/articles/int-prop/heckel-debunking.html\"> not true</a>, I "
-#| "just didn't understand the extent of my protection!” I said yes, "
-#| "that's what I said! So, in fact, you will have to spend a lot of time "
-#| "talking with lawyers to figure out what these patents prohibit you from "
-#| "doing."
+"demandó a Apple alegando que Hypercard infringÃa dos de sus <a href="
+"\"https://patents.justia.com/patent/4486857\">patentes</a>. Cuando vio "
+"Hypercard por primera vez, no pensó que tuviera nada que ver con sus "
+"«invenciones». No se parecÃan similares. Pero cuando su abogado le dijo
que "
+"se podÃa interpretar que las patentes se aplicaban a una parte de Hypercard,
"
+"decidió atacar a Apple."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
"When I gave a speech about this at Stanford, he was in the audience and he "
"said “That's <a href=\"https://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/classes/6.805/"
@@ -911,28 +544,13 @@
"\">[laughs]</i>"
msgstr ""
"Cuando di una charla sobre esto en Stanford, él estaba entre el público y "
-"dijo, «Eso <a href=\"http://www.swiss.ai.mit.edu/6805/articles/int-prop/"
-"heckel-debunking.html\">no es verdad</a>, ¡yo simplemente no entendÃa el "
-"alcance de mi protección!». Y yo le contesté, «SÃ, eso es lo que yo
estaba "
-"diciendo». De manera que habrÃa que dedicar mucho tiempo a hablar con "
-"abogados para hacerse una idea de lo que esas patentes prohÃben hacer."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | [-Ultimately-]{+So, in fact, you are going to spend a lot of time talking
-# | with lawyers to figure out what these patents prohibit you from doing. And
-# | ultimately,+} they are going to say something like this: “If you do
-# | something in here, you are sure to [-lose, If-] {+lose; if+} you do
-# | something {+in+} here, there is a substantial chance of losing, and if you
-# | really want to be safe, stay out of this area. And, by the way, there is
-# | a sizable element of chance in the outcome of any [-law suit.”-]
-# | {+lawsuit.” <i class=\"aside\">[chuckle in the audience]</i>+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Ultimately they are going to say something like this: “If you do "
-#| "something in here, you are sure to lose, If you do something here, there "
-#| "is a substantial chance of losing, and if you really want to be safe, "
-#| "stay out of this area. And, by the way, there is a sizable element of "
-#| "chance in the outcome of any law suit.”"
+"dijo: «Eso <a
href=\"https://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/classes/6.805/articles/"
+"int-prop/heckel-debunking.html\">no es verdad</a>, ¡yo simplemente no "
+"entendÃa el alcance de mi protección!». <i
class=\"aside\">[risas]</i> "
+"Y yo le contesté: «SÃ, eso es lo que yo estaba diciendo». <i
class=\"aside"
+"\">[risas]</i>"
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
"So, in fact, you are going to spend a lot of time talking with lawyers to "
"figure out what these patents prohibit you from doing. And ultimately, they "
@@ -942,60 +560,42 @@
"And, by the way, there is a sizable element of chance in the outcome of any "
"lawsuit.” <i class=\"aside\">[chuckle in the audience]</i>"
msgstr ""
-"Al final dirán algo asÃ: «Si haces esto, seguro que pierdes; si haces "
-"aquello, hay serias posibilidades de que pierdas, y si de verdad quieres "
-"estar a salvo, mantente al margen de esta área. Y, por cierto, el azar juega
"
-"un importante papel en el resultado de cualquier proceso judicial»."
+"De modo tal que, de hecho ,pasaremos mucho tiempo hablando con los abogados "
+"para descifrar qué es lo que estas patentes nos prohÃben hacer. Al final "
+"dirán algo asÃ: «Si haces esto, seguro que pierdes; si haces aquello, hay "
+"serias posibilidades de que pierdas, y si de verdad quieres estar a salvo, "
+"mantente al margen de esta área. Y, por cierto, el azar juega un importante "
+"papel en el resultado de cualquier proceso judicial». <i class=\"aside"
+"\">[risas por lo bajo]</i>"
#. type: Content of: <div><h3>
msgid "How a developer can deal with patents"
-msgstr ""
+msgstr "Cómo puede un desarrollador afrontar las patentes"
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | Now[-,-] that you have a predictable terrain for doing [-business(!)-]
-# | {+business, <i class=\"aside\">[chuckle in the audience]</i>+} what are
-# | you going to do? Well, there are three approaches that you might [-try.
-# | Any-] {+try, any+} of which is applicable in some cases.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Now, that you have a predictable terrain for doing business(!) what are "
-#| "you going to do? Well, there are three approaches that you might try. Any "
-#| "of which is applicable in some cases."
msgid ""
"Now that you have a predictable terrain for doing business, <i class=\"aside"
"\">[chuckle in the audience]</i> what are you going to do? Well, there are "
"three approaches that you might try, any of which is applicable in some "
"cases."
msgstr ""
-"Ahora que conocemos el terreno que pisamos para hacer negocios(!), ¿qué "
-"haremos? Bien, hay tres formas de afrontar la cuestión, y todas son "
-"aplicables en ciertos casos."
+"Ahora que conocemos el terreno que pisamos para hacer negocios, <i class="
+"\"aside\">[risas por lo bajo]</i> ¿qué haremos? Bien, hay tres formas de "
+"afrontar la cuestión, y todas son aplicables en ciertos casos."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | They are{+:+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid "They are"
msgid "They are:"
msgstr "Son las siguientes:"
#. type: Content of: <div><ol><li>
-# | [-A-]{+a+}voiding the patent{+,+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid "Avoiding the patent"
msgid "avoiding the patent,"
msgstr "Evitar la patente"
#. type: Content of: <div><ol><li>
-# | [-L-]{+l+}icensing the [-patent-] {+patent, or+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid "Licensing the patent"
msgid "licensing the patent, or"
msgstr "Obtener la licencia de la patente"
#. type: Content of: <div><ol><li>
-# | [-Overturning the patent-]{+overturning it+} in court.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid "Overturning the patent in court."
msgid "overturning it in court."
msgstr "Revocar la patente en los tribunales"
@@ -1007,33 +607,10 @@
"Describiré estas tres soluciones y lo que las hace viables o inviables."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dt>
-# | 1[-)-]{+.+} Avoiding the patent
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid "1) Avoiding the patent"
msgid "1. Avoiding the patent"
-msgstr "1) Evitar la patente"
+msgstr "1. Evitar la patente"
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | That means don't use the idea that the patent covers. This can be easy or
-# | hard, depending on what that idea is. In some cases, a feature is
-# | patented. Then you avoid the patent by not implementing that feature.
-# | Then it just matters how important is that feature. In some cases, you
-# | can live without it. [-A while ago, the users of the word processor
-# | XyWrite got a downgrade in the mail. The downgrade removed a feature
-# | which allowed you to pre-define abbreviations. That when you typed an
-# | abbreviation followed by a punctuation character, it would immediately
-# | replace itself with by some expansion.-]
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "That means don't use the idea that the patent covers. This can be easy "
-#| "or hard, depending on what that idea is. In some cases, a feature is "
-#| "patented. Then you avoid the patent by not implementing that feature. "
-#| "Then it just matters how important is that feature. In some cases, you "
-#| "can live without it. A while ago, the users of the word processor "
-#| "XyWrite got a downgrade in the mail. The downgrade removed a feature "
-#| "which allowed you to pre-define abbreviations. That when you typed an "
-#| "abbreviation followed by a punctuation character, it would immediately "
-#| "replace itself with by some expansion."
msgid ""
"That means don't use the idea that the patent covers. This can be easy or "
"hard, depending on what that idea is. In some cases, a feature is "
@@ -1045,37 +622,9 @@
"puede ser fácil o difÃcil según la idea de que se trate. En algunos casos,
"
"lo que se patenta es una funcionalidad, de modo que la patente se evita no "
"implementando esa funcionalidad. Entonces la cuestión es cuán importante es
"
-"esa funcionalidad. En algunos casos, se puede prescindir de ella. Hace algún
"
-"tiempo, los usuarios del procesador de textos XyWrite recibieron una "
-"actualización regresiva por correo. La actualización eliminaba una "
-"funcionalidad que permitÃa predefinir abreviaturas. Es decir, cuando se "
-"escribÃa una abreviatura seguida de un signo de puntuación, se reemplazaba "
-"inmediatamente por la secuencia de caracteres completa."
+"esa funcionalidad. En algunos casos, se puede prescindir de ella."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | {+A while ago, the users of the word processor XyWrite got a downgrade in
-# | the mail. The downgrade removed a feature which allowed you to predefine
-# | abbreviations: when you typed an abbreviation followed by a punctuation
-# | character, it would immediately replace itself by some expansion.+} So
-# | that way you could define the abbreviation for some long phrase, type the
-# | [-abbreviation-] {+abbreviation, and+} then the long phrase [-will-]
-# | {+would+} be in your document. They wrote to me about this because they
-# | knew {+that+} the <a href=\"/software/emacs/\">Emacs</a> editor has a
-# | similar feature. In fact, it had it since the 70's. This was interesting
-# | because it showed me that [-I-] {+I've+} had at least one patentable idea
-# | in my life. {+<i class=\"aside\">[laughs]</i> +} I knew it was
-# | patentable because somebody else patented it afterward! Actually, they had
-# | tried these various approaches.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "So that way you could define the abbreviation for some long phrase, type "
-#| "the abbreviation then the long phrase will be in your document. They "
-#| "wrote to me about this because they knew the <a href=\"/software/emacs/"
-#| "\">Emacs</a> editor has a similar feature. In fact, it had it since the "
-#| "70's. This was interesting because it showed me that I had at least one "
-#| "patentable idea in my life. I knew it was patentable because somebody "
-#| "else patented it afterward! Actually, they had tried these various "
-#| "approaches."
msgid ""
"A while ago, the users of the word processor XyWrite got a downgrade in the "
"mail. The downgrade removed a feature which allowed you to predefine "
@@ -1090,34 +639,21 @@
"was patentable because somebody else patented it afterward! Actually, they "
"had tried these various approaches."
msgstr ""
-"De ese modo se podÃa asignar una abreviatura para alguna frase larga, "
-"escribir la abreviatura y entonces en el documento aparecÃa la frase entera.
"
-"Ellos me escribieron sobre esto porque sabÃan que el editor <a href=\"/"
-"software/emacs/\">Emacs</a> tiene una funcionalidad similar. De hecho, la "
-"tiene desde los años setenta. Fue interesante, porque me hizo ver que habÃa
"
-"tenido al menos una idea patentable en mi vida. ¡Supe que era patentable "
-"porque otra persona la patentó después! De hecho, habÃan probado los tres "
-"enfoques."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | [-First-]{+At first+} they tried negotiating with the patent holder, who
-# | turned out not to negotiate in good faith. Then they looked at whether
-# | they could have a chance of overturning the patent. What they decided to
-# | do was take out the feature. You can live without this feature. If the
-# | word processor lacks only this feature, maybe people will still use it.
-# | But as various features start getting hit, eventually you end up with a
-# | program {+that+} people think is not very good{+,+} and they are likely to
-# | reject it. [-That is a rather narrow patent on a very specific feature.-]
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "First they tried negotiating with the patent holder, who turned out not "
-#| "to negotiate in good faith. Then they looked at whether they could have "
-#| "a chance of overturning the patent. What they decided to do was take out "
-#| "the feature. You can live without this feature. If the word processor "
-#| "lacks only this feature, maybe people will still use it. But as various "
-#| "features start getting hit, eventually you end up with a program people "
-#| "think is not very good and they are likely to reject it. That is a "
-#| "rather narrow patent on a very specific feature."
+"Hace algún tiempo, los usuarios del procesador de textos XyWrite recibieron "
+"una actualización regresiva por correo. La actualización eliminaba una "
+"funcionalidad que permitÃa predefinir abreviaturas. Es decir, cuando se "
+"escribÃa una abreviatura seguida de un signo de puntuación, se reemplazaba "
+"inmediatamente por la secuencia de caracteres completa. De ese modo se podÃa
"
+"asignar una abreviatura para alguna frase larga, escribir la abreviatura y "
+"entonces en el documento aparecÃa la frase entera. Ellos me escribieron "
+"sobre esto porque sabÃan que el editor <a href=\"/software/emacs/\">Emacs</"
+"a> tiene una funcionalidad similar. De hecho, la tiene desde los años "
+"setenta. Fue interesante, porque me hizo ver que habÃa tenido al menos una "
+"idea patentable en mi vida. <i class=\"aside\">[risas]</i> Descubrà "
+"que era patentable porque ¡otra persona la patentó después! De hecho,
habÃan "
+"probado los tres enfoques."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"At first they tried negotiating with the patent holder, who turned out not "
"to negotiate in good faith. Then they looked at whether they could have a "
@@ -1127,38 +663,15 @@
"start getting hit, eventually you end up with a program that people think is "
"not very good, and they are likely to reject it."
msgstr ""
-"Primero intentaron negociar con el titular de la patente, pero resultó que "
+"Primero intentaron negociar con el dueño de la patente, pero resultó que "
"este no negociaba de buena fe. Luego se plantearon si podrÃan tener alguna "
-"oportunidad de invalidar la patente. Y finalmente decidieron eliminar esa "
+"oportunidad de invalidar la patente. Finalmente decidieron eliminar esa "
"funcionalidad del programa. Se puede vivir sin ella. Si el procesador de "
"texto solo carece de esta funcionalidad, quizá la gente lo use igualmente, "
"pero si se empiezan a eliminar varias funcionalidades, al final la gente "
-"pensará que el programa no es muy bueno y probablemente lo rechace. En este "
-"caso se trataba de una patente bastante limitada sobre una funcionalidad muy "
-"especÃfica."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | [-What-]{+That's a rather narrow patent on a very specific feature. But
-# | what+} do you do with the <a
-# | href=\"https://patents.justia.com/patent/4873662\">British Telecom
-# | patent</a> on traversing hyper[- -]links together with dial-up access?
-# | Traversing hyper[- -]links is absolutely essential to a major use of
-# | computers these days. [-Dial-up-] {+And dial-up+} access is also
-# | essential. How do you do without this feature, which, by the way, isn't
-# | even one feature, it is really {+just+} a combination of two{+,+} just
-# | arbitrarily juxtaposed. It is rather like [-having-] a patent on
-# | {+having+} a sofa and television in the same room. {+<i
-# | class=\"aside\">[laughs]</i>+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "What do you do with the <a href=\"https://patents.justia.com/"
-#| "patent/4873662\">British Telecom patent</a> on traversing hyper links "
-#| "together with dial-up access? Traversing hyper links is absolutely "
-#| "essential to a major use of computers these days. Dial-up access is also "
-#| "essential. How do you do without this feature, which, by the way, isn't "
-#| "even one feature, it is really a combination of two just arbitrarily "
-#| "juxtaposed. It is rather like having a patent on a sofa and television "
-#| "in the same room."
+"pensará que el programa no es muy bueno y probablemente lo rechace. "
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"That's a rather narrow patent on a very specific feature. But what do you do "
"with the <a href=\"https://patents.justia.com/patent/4873662\">British "
@@ -1167,36 +680,22 @@
"these days. And dial-up access is also essential. How do you do without "
"this feature, which, by the way, isn't even one feature, it is really just a "
"combination of two, just arbitrarily juxtaposed. It is rather like a patent "
-"on having a sofa and television in the same room. <i class=\"aside\">[laughs]"
-"</i>"
+"on having a sofa and television in the same room. <i class=\"aside"
+"\">[laughs]</i>"
msgstr ""
-"Pero, ¿qué se puede hacer con relación a la <a
href=\"https://patents.justia."
-"com/patent/4873662\">patente de British Telecom</a> sobre la navegación por "
-"hipervÃnculos mediante acceso telefónico? Hoy en dÃa, la navegación por "
-"hipervÃnculos es absolutamente esencial en el uso corriente de los "
-"ordenadores. El acceso telefónico también es esencial. ¿Cómo
arreglárselas "
-"sin esta funcionalidad que, por cierto, ni siquiera es una funcionalidad "
-"sino en realidad una combinación de dos funcionalidades yuxtapuestas de "
-"forma arbitraria? Es como tener una patente sobre un sofá y un televisor que
"
-"estén en la misma habitación."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | Sometimes the idea that's patented will be so broad and basic that {+it's
-# | very hard, that+} it basically rules out an entire field. For instance,
-# | the idea of Public Key Encryption{+,+} which was patented in the US. The
-# | patent expired in 1997. Until then, it largely blocked the use of Public
-# | Key Encryption in the US. A number of programs that people started to
-# | develop got [-crushed. They-] {+crushed, and+} were never really
-# | available because the patent holders threatened them.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Sometimes the idea that's patented will be so broad and basic that it "
-#| "basically rules out an entire field. For instance, the idea of Public "
-#| "Key Encryption which was patented in the US. The patent expired in "
-#| "1997. Until then, it largely blocked the use of Public Key Encryption in "
-#| "the US. A number of programs that people started to develop got "
-#| "crushed. They were never really available because the patent holders "
-#| "threatened them."
+"En ese caso se trataba de una patente bastante limitada sobre una "
+"funcionalidad muy especÃfica. Pero, ¿qué se puede hacer con relación a la
<a "
+"href=\"https://patents.justia.com/patent/4873662\">patente de British "
+"Telecom</a> sobre la navegación por hipervÃnculos mediante acceso "
+"telefónico? Hoy en dÃa, la navegación por hipervÃnculos es absolutamente "
+"esencial en el uso corriente de los ordenadores. El acceso telefónico "
+"también es esencial. ¿Cómo arreglárselas sin esta funcionalidad que, por "
+"cierto, ni siquiera es una funcionalidad sino en realidad una combinación de
"
+"dos funcionalidades yuxtapuestas de forma arbitraria? Es como tener una "
+"patente sobre un sofá y un televisor que estén en la misma habitación. <i "
+"class=\"aside\">[risas]</i>"
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"Sometimes the idea that's patented will be so broad and basic that it's very "
"hard, that it basically rules out an entire field. For instance, the idea "
@@ -1209,30 +708,11 @@
"todo un campo. Por ejemplo, la idea de cifrado mediante clave pública, que "
"fue patentada en EE. UU. La patente caducó en 1997. Hasta entonces, "
"obstruyó enormemente el uso de ese tipo de cifrado en EE. UU. Un buen "
-"número de programas que la gente empezaba a desarrollar se vieron "
-"frustrados. Nunca llegaron a estar verdaderamente disponibles debido a las "
-"amenazas de los propietarios de las patentes."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | Then, one program got [-away. The-] {+away: the+} program <a
-# | href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20170315023711/http://www.pgpi.org/\">
-# | PGP</a>, which initially was released as free software. Apparently, the
-# | patent holders{+,+} by the time they got around to attacking, realized
-# | they might get too much bad publicity. So they imposed restrictions{+,+}
-# | making it for non[---]commercial use only, which meant it couldn't catch
-# | on too much. So they greatly limited the use of Public Key Encryption for
-# | a decade or more. There was no way around that patent. There was nothing
-# | else you could do like that.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Then, one program got away. The program <a href=\"https://web.archive."
-#| "org/web/20170315023711/http://www.pgpi.org/\"> PGP</a>, which initially "
-#| "was released as free software. Apparently, the patent holders by the "
-#| "time they got around to attacking, realized they might get too much bad "
-#| "publicity. So they imposed restrictions making it for non-commercial use "
-#| "only, which meant it couldn't catch on too much. So they greatly limited "
-#| "the use of Public Key Encryption for a decade or more. There was no way "
-#| "around that patent. There was nothing else you could do like that."
+"número de programas que la gente empezaba a desarrollar se vieron frustrados
"
+"y nunca llegaron a estar verdaderamente disponibles debido a las amenazas de "
+"los propietarios de las patentes."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"Then, one program got away: the program <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/"
"web/20170315023711/http://www.pgpi.org/\"> PGP</a>, which initially was "
@@ -1243,35 +723,17 @@
"Key Encryption for a decade or more. There was no way around that patent. "
"There was nothing else you could do like that."
msgstr ""
-"Posteriormente apareció un programa, <a href=\"http://www.pgpi.org/\">PGP</"
-"a>, que inicialmente se publicó como software libre. Al parecer, los "
-"titulares de las patentes se proponÃan atacar, pero se dieron cuenta de que "
-"eso podrÃa crearles muy mala imagen. De modo que impusieron restricciones, "
-"limitándolo solo a usos no comerciales, lo que significaba que no podrÃa "
-"hacerse muy popular. De esta manera, limitaron fuertemente el uso del "
-"cifrado mediante clave pública durante una década o más. No habÃa "
-"alternativas a esa patente. No se podÃa hacer nada más."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | Sometimes a specific algorithm gets patented. For instance, there is a
-# | patent on an optimized version of the Fast Fourier Transform. It runs
-# | about twice as fast. You can avoid that by using the ordinary FFT in your
-# | program. That part of your program will take twice as long. Maybe that
-# | doesn't [-really matter, maybe that is-] {+matter. Maybe that's+} a small
-# | {+enough+} part of the program's running [-time. Maybe-] {+time that,+}
-# | if it is twice as slow, you won't really notice. Or maybe that means your
-# | program won't run at all{+,+} because it will take twice {+the+} real time
-# | to do its job. The effects vary.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Sometimes a specific algorithm gets patented. For instance, there is a "
-#| "patent on an optimized version of the Fast Fourier Transform. It runs "
-#| "about twice as fast. You can avoid that by using the ordinary FFT in "
-#| "your program. That part of your program will take twice as long. Maybe "
-#| "that doesn't really matter, maybe that is a small part of the program's "
-#| "running time. Maybe if it is twice as slow, you won't really notice. Or "
-#| "maybe that means your program won't run at all because it will take twice "
-#| "real time to do its job. The effects vary."
+"Posteriormente un programa escapó: <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/"
+"web/20170315023711/http://www.pgpi.org/\">PGP</a>, que inicialmente se "
+"publicó como software libre. Al parecer, los dueños de las patentes se "
+"proponÃan atacar, pero se dieron cuenta de que eso podrÃa crearles muy mala
"
+"imagen. De modo que impusieron restricciones, limitándolo solo a usos no "
+"comerciales, lo que significaba que no podrÃa hacerse muy popular. De esta "
+"manera, limitaron fuertemente el uso del cifrado mediante clave pública "
+"durante una década o más. No habÃa manera de evitar esa patente. No se
podÃa "
+"hacer nada más."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"Sometimes a specific algorithm gets patented. For instance, there is a "
"patent on an optimized version of the Fast Fourier Transform. It runs about "
@@ -1284,37 +746,15 @@
msgstr ""
"A veces se patenta un algoritmo determinado. Por ejemplo, existe una patente "
"sobre una versión optimizada de la transformada rápida de Fourier (<abbr "
-"title=\"Fast Fourier Transform\">FFT</abbr>), que funciona el doble de "
-"rápido. Es posible evitarla utilizando en el programa la FFT ordinaria. Esa "
-"parte del programa tardará el doble de tiempo en ejecutarse. Quizás eso no "
-"tenga gran importancia, quizá represente una pequeña parte del tiempo de "
-"ejecución del programa, quizá ni siquiera se note que es el doble de lento.
"
-"O quizás el programa no funcione en absoluto si le lleva el doble de tiempo "
-"hacer su tarea. Los efectos varÃan."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | In some cases, you can find a better algorithm. [-This-] {+That+} may or
-# | may not do you any good. Because we couldn't use [-c-]{+C+}ompress, in
-# | the GNU [-p-]{+P+}roject we started looking for some other algorithm for
-# | data compression. Somebody wrote to us saying he had one. He had written
-# | a program and he decided to contribute it to us. We were going to release
-# | [-it. Just-] {+it, and just+} by chance[-,-] I happened to see a copy of
-# | the [-New-] {+<cite>New+} York [-Times. It-] {+Times</cite> that+}
-# | happened to have the weekly patent column in it. I didn't see a copy of
-# | the [-Times-] {+<cite>Times</cite>+} more than once every few months. So
-# | I looked at it{+,+} and it said that somebody had got a patent for
-# | “[-I-]{+i+}nventing a new method of compressing data.”
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "In some cases, you can find a better algorithm. This may or may not do "
-#| "you any good. Because we couldn't use compress, in the GNU project we "
-#| "started looking for some other algorithm for data compression. Somebody "
-#| "wrote to us saying he had one. He had written a program and he decided to "
-#| "contribute it to us. We were going to release it. Just by chance, I "
-#| "happened to see a copy of the New York Times. It happened to have the "
-#| "weekly patent column in it. I didn't see a copy of the Times more than "
-#| "once every few months. So I looked at it and it said that somebody had "
-#| "got a patent for “Inventing a new method of compressing data.”"
+"title=\"Fast Fourier Transform\">FFT</abbr>), que funciona aproximadamente "
+"el doble de rápido. Es posible evitarla utilizando en el programa la FFT "
+"ordinaria. Esa parte del programa tardará el doble de tiempo en ejecutarse. "
+"Quizás eso no tenga gran importancia, quizá represente una pequeña parte
del "
+"tiempo de ejecución del programa, quizá ni siquiera se note que es el doble
"
+"de lento. O quizás el programa no funcione en absoluto si le lleva el doble "
+"de tiempo hacer su tarea. Los efectos varÃan."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"In some cases, you can find a better algorithm. That may or may not do you "
"any good. Because we couldn't use Compress, in the GNU Project we started "
@@ -1332,35 +772,12 @@
"buscar algún algoritmo alternativo para la compresión de datos. Alguien nos
"
"escribió diciendo que tenÃa uno. HabÃa escrito un programa y decidió "
"ofrecérnoslo. Ãbamos ya a publicarlo cuando por casualidad hojeé un
ejemplar "
-"del New York Times en el que aparecÃa la columna semanal sobre patentes (no "
-"solÃa hojear el Times más que una vez cada varios meses). Asà que le eché
un "
-"vistazo, y decÃa que alguien habÃa conseguido una patente por «inventar un
"
-"nuevo método de compresión de datos»."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | I figured I better take a look at this patent. I got a copy{+,+} and it
-# | turned out to cover the program that we were just a week away from
-# | releasing. [-That-] {+So that+} program died before it was born. Later
-# | on we did find another algorithm which was un[---]patented. That became
-# | the program <a href=\"/software/gzip/\"> [-g-]{+G+}zip</a>, which is now
-# | effectively the de-facto standard for data compression. As an algorithm
-# | to use in a program for data compression, it was fine. [-Anyone-]
-# | {+People+} who wanted to do data compression could use [-g-]{+G+}zip
-# | instead of [-c-]{+C+}ompress. But the same patented LZW compression
-# | algorithm was also used in image formats such as [-the-] <a
-# | href=\"/philosophy/gif.html\">GIF</a> format.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "I figured I better take a look at this patent. I got a copy and it "
-#| "turned out to cover the program that we were just a week away from "
-#| "releasing. That program died before it was born. Later on we did find "
-#| "another algorithm which was un-patented. That became the program <a href="
-#| "\"/software/gzip/\"> gzip</a>, which is now effectively the de-facto "
-#| "standard for data compression. As an algorithm to use in a program for "
-#| "data compression, it was fine. Anyone who wanted to do data compression "
-#| "could use gzip instead of compress. But the same patented LZW "
-#| "compression algorithm was also used in image formats such as the <a href="
-#| "\"/philosophy/gif.html\">GIF</a> format."
+"del <cite>New York Times</cite> en el que aparecÃa la columna semanal sobre "
+"patentes (no solÃa hojear el Times más que una vez cada varios meses). AsÃ
"
+"que le eché un vistazo, y decÃa que alguien habÃa conseguido una patente
por "
+"«inventar un nuevo método de compresión de datos»."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"I figured I better take a look at this patent. I got a copy, and it turned "
"out to cover the program that we were just a week away from releasing. So "
@@ -1376,42 +793,14 @@
"resultó que cubrÃa el programa que Ãbamos a publicar en tan solo una
semana. "
"Ese programa murió antes de nacer. Más adelante encontramos otro algoritmo "
"que no estaba patentado. Este se convirtió en el programa <a href=\"/"
-"software/gzip/\"> gzip</a>, que ahora es el estándar de facto para la "
+"software/gzip/\"> Gzip</a>, que ahora es el estándar de facto para la "
"compresión de datos. Como algoritmo para utilizar en un programa de "
-"compresión de datos estaba muy bien. Cualquiera que quisiera comprimir "
-"datos podÃa utilizar gzip en lugar de compress. Pero el mismo algoritmo "
-"patentado de compresión LZW se utilizaba también en formatos de imagen
tales "
-"como <a href=\"/philosophy/gif.html\">GIF</a>."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | [-But there-]{+And there,+} because the job {+that+} people wanted to do
-# | was not [-to-] simply [-compress data-] {+“Compress my
-# | data,”+} but [-to make-] {+“Make+} an image that people
-# | [-could-] {+can+} display with their [-software,-] {+software,”+} it
-# | turned out [-extremely-] {+to be very+} hard to switch over to a different
-# | algorithm. [-We-] {+In fact, we+} have not been able to do it in 10
-# | years! Yes, people use{+d+} the [-gzip-] {+new Gzip+} algorithm to define
-# | <a href=\"https://www.w3.org/Graphics/PNG/\">another image format</a>,
-# | once people started getting threatened with law[- -]suits for using GIF
-# | files. [-When-] {+But when+} we started saying to people {+“Hey,+}
-# | stop using GIF files, switch over to [-this,-] {+this!”+} people
-# | said{+,+} “We can't switch. The browsers don't support the new
-# | format yet.” [-The-] {+And the+} browser developers said
-# | “We're not in a hurry about this. After all, nobody is using this
-# | file format.” {+<i class=\"aside\">[laughs]</i>+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "But there because the job people wanted to do was not to simply compress "
-#| "data but to make an image that people could display with their software, "
-#| "it turned out extremely hard to switch over to a different algorithm. We "
-#| "have not been able to do it in 10 years! Yes, people use the gzip "
-#| "algorithm to define <a href=\"https://www.w3.org/Graphics/PNG/\">another "
-#| "image format</a>, once people started getting threatened with law suits "
-#| "for using GIF files. When we started saying to people stop using GIF "
-#| "files, switch over to this, people said “We can't switch. The "
-#| "browsers don't support the new format yet.” The browser developers "
-#| "said “We're not in a hurry about this. After all, nobody is using "
-#| "this file format.”"
+"compresión de datos estaba muy bien. Quien quisiera comprimir datos podÃa "
+"utilizar Gzip en lugar de Compress. Pero el mismo algoritmo patentado de "
+"compresión LZW se utilizaba también en formatos de imagen tales como <a
href="
+"\"/philosophy/gif.html\">GIF</a>."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"And there, because the job that people wanted to do was not simply “"
"Compress my data,” but “Make an image that people can display "
@@ -1429,27 +818,17 @@
"Y como en este caso lo que se querÃa hacer no era simplemente comprimir "
"datos, sino elaborar una imagen que cualquiera pudiera visualizar con su "
"software, resultaba extremadamente complicado cambiar a un algoritmo "
-"diferente. ¡Durante diez años no hemos podido hacerlo! Tan pronto como "
+"diferente. De hecho, ¡durante diez años no pudimos hacerlo! Tan pronto como
"
"empezaron a llegar amenazas judiciales por usar archivos GIF, se comenzó a "
-"utilizar el algoritmo de gzip para definir <a href=\"https://www.w3.org/"
+"utilizar el algoritmo de Gzip para definir <a href=\"https://www.w3.org/"
"Graphics/PNG/\">otro formato de imagen</a>. Cuando empezamos a pedir que se "
"abandonara el uso de archivos GIF en favor de este otro formato, nos "
"respondÃan: «No podemos cambiar, los navegadores no admiten todavÃa el
nuevo "
"formato». Y los desarrolladores de navegadores decÃan: «No tenemos ninguna
"
-"prisa. Después de todo, nadie utiliza este nuevo formato»."
+"prisa. Después de todo, nadie utiliza este nuevo formato».” <i class="
+"\"aside\">[risas]</i>"
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | In effect, society had so much inertia in the use of [-the GIF format,-]
-# | {+that particular format [GIF] that+} we have not been able to get people
-# | to switch. Essentially, the community's use of the GIF format is still
-# | pushing sites into using GIF format{+,+} with the result that they are
-# | vulnerable to these threats.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "In effect, society had so much inertia in the use of the GIF format, we "
-#| "have not been able to get people to switch. Essentially, the community's "
-#| "use of the GIF format is still pushing sites into using GIF format with "
-#| "the result that they are vulnerable to these threats."
msgid ""
"In effect, society had so much inertia in the use of that particular format "
"[GIF] that we have not been able to get people to switch. Essentially, the "
@@ -1457,25 +836,11 @@
"format, with the result that they are vulnerable to these threats."
msgstr ""
"De hecho, la inercia en el uso del formato GIF era tan grande que no pudimos "
-"lograr que se cambiara. En la práctica, el uso del formato GIF por parte de "
-"la comunidad todavÃa sigue llevando a que los sitios web utilicen ese "
-"formato, con el resultado de que son vulnerables a las amenazas."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | In fact, the situation is even more [-bizarre. There-] {+bizarre, because
-# | there+} are [-in fact-] {+actually+} two patents covering the LZW
-# | compression algorithm. The patent office couldn't even tell that they
-# | were issuing two patents on the same thing. They couldn't keep track.
-# | There is a reason for this. It takes a while of study of these two
-# | patents to see that they really cover the same thing.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "In fact, the situation is even more bizarre. There are in fact two "
-#| "patents covering the LZW compression algorithm. The patent office "
-#| "couldn't even tell that they were issuing two patents on the same thing. "
-#| "They couldn't keep track. There is a reason for this. It takes a while "
-#| "of study of these two patents to see that they really cover the same "
-#| "thing."
+"lograr que la gente cambiara. En la práctica, el uso del formato GIF por "
+"parte de la comunidad todavÃa sigue llevando a que los sitios web utilicen "
+"ese formato, con el resultado de que son vulnerables a las amenazas."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"In fact, the situation is even more bizarre, because there are actually two "
"patents covering the LZW compression algorithm. The patent office couldn't "
@@ -1483,26 +848,14 @@
"couldn't keep track. There is a reason for this. It takes a while of study "
"of these two patents to see that they really cover the same thing."
msgstr ""
-"En realidad la situación es todavÃa más grotesca. Hay de hecho dos
patentes "
-"que cubren el algoritmo de compresión LZW. La oficina de patentes ni "
-"siquiera se dio cuenta de que estaban concediendo dos patentes sobre la "
+"En realidad la situación es todavÃa más grotesca, porque de hecho hay dos "
+"patentes que cubren el algoritmo de compresión LZW. La oficina de patentes "
+"ni siquiera se dio cuenta de que estaban concediendo dos patentes sobre la "
"misma cosa. No estaba al tanto, y hay un motivo para ello: hay que dedicar "
"una buena cantidad de tiempo al estudio de estas dos patentes para darse "
"cuenta de que en realidad cubren lo mismo."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | If they were patents on some chemical process, it would be much easier.
-# | [-You-] {+Because you+} could see what substances were being used, what
-# | the inputs were, what the outputs were, which physical actions are being
-# | taken. No matter how they are described, you'd see what they were and
-# | then you would see that they are similar.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "If they were patents on some chemical process, it would be much easier. "
-#| "You could see what substances were being used, what the inputs were, what "
-#| "the outputs were, which physical actions are being taken. No matter how "
-#| "they are described, you'd see what they were and then you would see that "
-#| "they are similar."
msgid ""
"If they were patents on some chemical process, it would be much easier. "
"Because you could see what substances were being used, what the inputs were, "
@@ -1510,36 +863,13 @@
"how they are described, you'd see what they were and then you would see that "
"they are similar."
msgstr ""
-"Si fueran patentes sobre procesos quÃmicos, serÃa mucho más fácil. Se
podrÃa "
-"verificar qué sustancias se están empleando, qué se introduce, qué se "
-"obtiene y qué acciones fÃsicas se llevan a cabo. Sea cual sea su "
+"Si fueran patentes sobre procesos quÃmicos, serÃa mucho más fácil, porque
se "
+"podrÃa verificar qué sustancias se están empleando, qué se introduce,
qué se "
+"obtiene, y qué acciones fÃsicas se llevan a cabo. Sea cual sea su "
"descripción, se comprobarÃa en qué consisten esos procesos y se verÃa que
"
"son similares."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | [-If-]{+But when+} something is purely mathematical, [-there are many-]
-# | {+you could have various+} ways [-of describing-] {+to describe+} it,
-# | which are a lot more different. They are not superficially similar. You
-# | have to really understand them to see they are talking about the same
-# | thing. [-The-] {+In the+} patent [-office doesn't-] {+office, they
-# | don't+} have time. The US Patent Office{+,+} as of a few years ago, was
-# | spending [-on average-] 17 hours {+on the average+} per patent. This is
-# | not long enough to think carefully about [-them, so,-] {+them. So,+} of
-# | course they make mistakes like that. In fact, I told you about the
-# | program that died before it was born. [-That-] {+Well, that+} algorithm
-# | also {+has+} had two patents issued for it in the US. Apparently, it is
-# | not that unusual.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "If something is purely mathematical, there are many ways of describing "
-#| "it, which are a lot more different. They are not superficially similar. "
-#| "You have to really understand them to see they are talking about the same "
-#| "thing. The patent office doesn't have time. The US Patent Office as of "
-#| "a few years ago, was spending on average 17 hours per patent. This is "
-#| "not long enough to think carefully about them, so, of course they make "
-#| "mistakes like that. In fact, I told you about the program that died "
-#| "before it was born. That algorithm also had two patents issued for it in "
-#| "the US. Apparently, it is not that unusual."
msgid ""
"But when something is purely mathematical, you could have various ways to "
"describe it, which are a lot more different. They are not superficially "
@@ -1558,17 +888,10 @@
"Oficina de Patentes de EE. UU. empleaba una media de 17 horas por "
"patente. No es tiempo suficiente para examinarlas cuidadosamente, de modo "
"que comenten errores como este, por supuesto. Ya les he hablado del programa "
-"que murió antes de nacer. También sobre ese algoritmo se habÃan emitido en
"
-"EE. UU. dos patentes. Por lo que se ve, no es nada inusual."
+"que murió antes de nacer; pues bien, también sobre ese algoritmo se habÃan
"
+"emitido en EE. UU. dos patentes. Por lo que se ve, no es nada inusual."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | [-Avoiding-]{+So, avoiding+} the patents may be [-easy,-] {+easy {or it}+}
-# | may be [-impossible. It-] {+impossible; it+} may be easy but it makes
-# | your program useless. It varies depending on the situation.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Avoiding the patents may be easy, may be impossible. It may be easy but "
-#| "it makes your program useless. It varies depending on the situation."
msgid ""
"So, avoiding the patents may be easy {or it} may be impossible; it may be "
"easy but it makes your program useless. It varies depending on the "
@@ -1578,26 +901,6 @@
"programa puede acabar resultando inútil. Depende de la situación."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | Here is another point I should [-mention: Sometimes-] {+mention, that
-# | sometimes+} a company or consortium can make a format or protocol [-the-]
-# | {+a+} de-facto standard. Then, if that format or protocol is patented,
-# | [-that is-] {+that's+} a real disaster for you. There are even official
-# | standards that are restricted by patents. There was a big political
-# | uproar last September when the <a
-# | href=\"https://www.w3.org/TR/patent-practice/\">World Wide Web
-# | Consortium</a> was proposing to start adopting standards that were covered
-# | by patents. The community [-objected so-] {+objected, and+} they reversed
-# | themselves.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Here is another point I should mention: Sometimes a company or consortium "
-#| "can make a format or protocol the de-facto standard. Then, if that "
-#| "format or protocol is patented, that is a real disaster for you. There "
-#| "are even official standards that are restricted by patents. There was a "
-#| "big political uproar last September when the <a href=\"https://www.w3.org/"
-#| "TR/patent-practice/\">World Wide Web Consortium</a> was proposing to "
-#| "start adopting standards that were covered by patents. The community "
-#| "objected so they reversed themselves."
msgid ""
"Here is another point I should mention, that sometimes a company or "
"consortium can make a format or protocol a de-facto standard. Then, if that "
@@ -1609,8 +912,8 @@
"and they reversed themselves."
msgstr ""
"Hay otra cuestión que debo mencionar. A veces una empresa o un consorcio "
-"puede hacer que un formato o protocolo sea el estándar de facto. En tal "
-"caso, si ese formato o protocolo se patenta es un auténtico desastre. Hay "
+"puede hacer que un formato o protocolo sea un estándar de facto. En tal "
+"caso, si ese formato o protocolo se patenta, es un auténtico desastre. Hay "
"incluso estándares oficiales que están restringidos por patentes. El pasado
"
"mes de septiembre se produjo un gran revuelo polÃtico cuando el <a href="
"\"https://www.w3.org/TR/patent-practice\"><cite>World Wide Web Consortium</"
@@ -1618,24 +921,6 @@
"patentes. La comunidad protestó y se retractaron."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | They went back to insisting that [-any-] patents had to be freely
-# | implementable by anyone{+,+} and that [-the-] standards had to be free for
-# | anyone to implement. That is an interesting victory. I think [-that
-# | was-] {+it's+} the first time any standards body has made that decision.
-# | [-It is-] {+It's+} normal for standards bodies to be willing to put
-# | something in a standard which {+in fact+} is restricted by patents{+,+}
-# | and people are not allowed to go ahead and implement it freely. We need
-# | to go to other standards bodies and call on them to change their rules.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "They went back to insisting that any patents had to be freely "
-#| "implementable by anyone and that the standards had to be free for anyone "
-#| "to implement. That is an interesting victory. I think that was the "
-#| "first time any standards body has made that decision. It is normal for "
-#| "standards bodies to be willing to put something in a standard which is "
-#| "restricted by patents and people are not allowed to go ahead and "
-#| "implement it freely. We need to go to other standards bodies and call on "
-#| "them to change their rules."
msgid ""
"They went back to insisting that patents had to be freely implementable by "
"anyone, and that standards had to be free for anyone to implement. That is "
@@ -1645,43 +930,20 @@
"are not allowed to go ahead and implement it freely. We need to go to other "
"standards bodies and call on them to change their rules."
msgstr ""
-"Se echaron atrás e insistieron en que cualquiera deberÃa poder implementar "
-"libremente cualquier patente y en que los estándares tenÃan que ser libres "
-"para que cualquiera los implementara. Es una victoria interesante. Creo que "
-"ha sido la primera vez en que una organización de estándares ha tomado esta
"
-"decisión. Es habitual que los organismos de normalización estén dispuestos
a "
-"añadir a un estándar algo restringido por patentes, de modo que a la gente "
-"no se le permita implementarlo libremente. Tenemos que dirigirnos a otros "
-"organismos de normalización y reclamarles que cambien sus reglas."
+"Se echaron atrás y volvieron a insistir en que cualquiera deberÃa poder "
+"implementar libremente cualquier patente, y en que cualquiera deberÃa tener "
+"la libertad de implementar los estándares. Es una victoria interesante. Creo
"
+"que ha sido la primera vez en que una organización de estándares ha tomado "
+"esta decisión. Es habitual que los organismos de normalización estén "
+"dispuestos a añadir a un estándar algo restringido por patentes, de modo
que "
+"a la gente no se le permita implementarlo libremente. Tenemos que dirigirnos "
+"a otros organismos de normalización y reclamarles que cambien sus reglas."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dt>
-# | 2[-)-]{+.+} Licensing the patent
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid "2) Licensing the patent"
msgid "2. Licensing the patent"
-msgstr "2) Obtener la licencia de la patente"
+msgstr "2. Obtener la licencia de la patente"
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | The second possibility {+is,+} instead of avoiding the [-patent is-]
-# | {+patent,+} to get a license for the patent. This is not necessarily an
-# | option. The patent holder does not have to offer you a [-license, it is-]
-# | {+license. It's+} not required. [-10 Years-] {+Ten years+} ago, the
-# | [-l-]{+L+}eague for [-programming freedom-] {+Programming Freedom+} got a
-# | letter asking for help from somebody whose family business was making
-# | gambling machinery for casinos{+,+} and they used computers back then. He
-# | received a threat from another company that [-said we-] {+said,
-# | “We+} have the patents. You are not allowed to make these things.
-# | Shut [-down.-] {+down.”+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "The second possibility instead of avoiding the patent is to get a license "
-#| "for the patent. This is not necessarily an option. The patent holder "
-#| "does not have to offer you a license, it is not required. 10 Years ago, "
-#| "the league for programming freedom got a letter asking for help from "
-#| "somebody whose family business was making gambling machinery for casinos "
-#| "and they used computers back then. He received a threat from another "
-#| "company that said we have the patents. You are not allowed to make these "
-#| "things. Shut down."
msgid ""
"The second possibility is, instead of avoiding the patent, to get a license "
"for the patent. This is not necessarily an option. The patent holder does "
@@ -1693,25 +955,16 @@
"things. Shut down.”"
msgstr ""
"La segunda posibilidad consiste en conseguir una licencia para la patente, "
-"en lugar de evitarla. Esta no es necesariamente una opción. El titular de la
"
+"en lugar de evitarla. Esta no es necesariamente una opción. El dueño de la "
"patente no tiene por qué ofrecernos una licencia, no está obligado a "
"hacerlo. Hace diez años, alguien cuyo pequeño negocio familiar consistÃa
en "
"la fabricación de máquinas tragamonedas para los casinos (que ya entonces "
"usaban ordenadores) envió una carta a la Liga para la Libertad de "
"Programación en la que solicitaba ayuda porque habÃa recibido una amenaza
de "
-"otra empresa que decÃa que ellos tenÃan la patente: «Usted no está "
+"otra empresa que le decÃa: «Nosotros tenemos las patentes. Usted no está "
"autorizado a fabricar estas cosas. Cierre su negocio»."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | I looked at that patent. It covered having a number of computers on a
-# | network for playing games{+,+} such that each computer supported more than
-# | one game and allowed you to [-play-] {+be playing+} more than one game at
-# | a time.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "I looked at that patent. It covered having a number of computers on a "
-#| "network for playing games such that each computer supported more than one "
-#| "game and allowed you to play more than one game at a time."
msgid ""
"I looked at that patent. It covered having a number of computers on a "
"network for playing games, such that each computer supported more than one "
@@ -1722,81 +975,34 @@
"un juego y permitÃa jugar a más de un juego a la vez."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | You will find {+the+} patent office{+s+} really think that there is
-# | something brilliant about doing more than one of anything. {+<i
-# | class=\"aside\">[laughs]</i> +} They don't realize that{+,+} in
-# | computer science, that's the most obvious way to generalize anything. You
-# | did it [-once and now-] {+once. Now+} you can do it any number of times,
-# | [-you can-] make a subroutine. They think that if you do anything [-more
-# | than-] {+twice instead of+} once, [-that-] {+you made a new invention.
-# | That+} somehow means you are brilliant and [-that-] nobody can possibly
-# | argue with [-you and that you have the-] {+your+} right to boss them
-# | [-around.-] {+around and restrict them.+} Anyway, he [-was not-]
-# | {+wasn't+} offered a [-license. He-] {+license, and he+} had to shut
-# | down. He couldn't even afford really to go to court. I would say that
-# | particular patent was an obvious idea. [-It is-] {+It's+} possible that
-# | a judge might have [-agreed, but we-] {+agreed. We+} will never [-know-]
-# | {+know, though,+} because he could not afford to go to court.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "You will find patent office really think that there is something "
-#| "brilliant about doing more than one of anything. They don't realize that "
-#| "in computer science, that's the most obvious way to generalize anything. "
-#| "You did it once and now you can do it any number of times, you can make a "
-#| "subroutine. They think that if you do anything more than once, that "
-#| "somehow means you are brilliant and that nobody can possibly argue with "
-#| "you and that you have the right to boss them around. Anyway, he was not "
-#| "offered a license. He had to shut down. He couldn't even afford really "
-#| "to go to court. I would say that particular patent was an obvious idea. "
-#| "It is possible that a judge might have agreed, but we will never know "
-#| "because he could not afford to go to court."
msgid ""
"You will find the patent offices really think that there is something "
-"brilliant about doing more than one of anything. <i class=\"aside\">[laughs]"
-"</i> They don't realize that, in computer science, that's the most "
-"obvious way to generalize anything. You did it once. Now you can do it any "
-"number of times, make a subroutine. They think that if you do anything "
-"twice instead of once, you made a new invention. That somehow means you are "
-"brilliant and nobody can possibly argue with your right to boss them around "
-"and restrict them. Anyway, he wasn't offered a license, and he had to shut "
-"down. He couldn't even afford really to go to court. I would say that "
-"particular patent was an obvious idea. It's possible that a judge might "
-"have agreed. We will never know, though, because he could not afford to go "
-"to court."
+"brilliant about doing more than one of anything. <i class=\"aside"
+"\">[laughs]</i> They don't realize that, in computer science, that's "
+"the most obvious way to generalize anything. You did it once. Now you can "
+"do it any number of times, make a subroutine. They think that if you do "
+"anything twice instead of once, you made a new invention. That somehow means "
+"you are brilliant and nobody can possibly argue with your right to boss them "
+"around and restrict them. Anyway, he wasn't offered a license, and he had "
+"to shut down. He couldn't even afford really to go to court. I would say "
+"that particular patent was an obvious idea. It's possible that a judge "
+"might have agreed. We will never know, though, because he could not afford "
+"to go to court."
msgstr ""
"Ya ven que la oficina de patentes cree que es una idea brillante hacer "
-"cualquier cosa más de una vez. No se dan cuenta de que en informática esa
es "
-"la forma más obvia de generalizar algo. Se ha hecho una vez y ahora se puede
"
-"hacer cualquier número de veces, se puede escribir una subrutina. Creen que "
-"si alguien hace algo más de una vez, eso debe de significar que es un genio,
"
-"que nadie puede llevarle la contraria y que tiene derecho a dar órdenes a "
-"todo el mundo. En cualquier caso, a esa persona no le ofrecieron la "
-"licencia. Tuvo que cerrar. Ni siquiera pudo afrontar el costo de acudir a "
-"los tribunales. Yo dirÃa que esa patente concreta era una idea obvia. Es "
-"posible que un juez hubiera pensado lo mismo, pero nunca lo sabremos porque "
-"esa persona no se pudo permitir ir a juicio."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | However, a lot of patent holders do offer licenses. They often charge a
-# | lot of money for that{+,+} though. The company licensing the natural
-# | order recalculation patent was demanding 5% of the gross sales of every
-# | spreadsheet in the US. I am told that was the cheap pre-lawsuit price.
-# | If you actually made them sue you and they won, they'd demand more. You
-# | might be able to afford that 5% for licensing this one patent, but what if
-# | you need to license 20 different patents to make the program? Then all the
-# | money you take in [-goes on patents.-] {+has to go out to them.+} What if
-# | you need to license 21 patents?
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "However, a lot of patent holders do offer licenses. They often charge a "
-#| "lot of money for that though. The company licensing the natural order "
-#| "recalculation patent was demanding 5% of the gross sales of every "
-#| "spreadsheet in the US. I am told that was the cheap pre-lawsuit price. "
-#| "If you actually made them sue you and they won, they'd demand more. You "
-#| "might be able to afford that 5% for licensing this one patent, but what "
-#| "if you need to license 20 different patents to make the program? Then all "
-#| "the money you take in goes on patents. What if you need to license 21 "
-#| "patents?"
+"cualquier cosa más de una vez. <i class=\"aside\">[risas]</i> No se "
+"dan cuenta de que en informática esa es la forma más obvia de generalizar "
+"algo. Se ha hecho una vez y ahora se puede hacer cualquier número de veces, "
+"se puede escribir una subrutina. Creen que si alguien hace algo dos veces en "
+"vez de una sola vez, ha inventado algo. Eso debe de significar que se trata "
+"de un genio, que nadie puede llevarle la contraria y que tiene derecho a dar "
+"órdenes y restringir a todo el mundo. En cualquier caso, a esa persona no le
"
+"ofrecieron la licencia, tuvo que cerrar. Ni siquiera pudo afrontar el costo "
+"de acudir a los tribunales. Yo dirÃa que esa patente concreta era una idea "
+"obvia. Es posible que un juez hubiera pensado lo mismo, pero nunca lo "
+"sabremos porque esa persona no se pudo permitir ir a juicio."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"However, a lot of patent holders do offer licenses. They often charge a lot "
"of money for that, though. The company licensing the natural order "
@@ -1807,24 +1013,18 @@
"need to license 20 different patents to make the program? Then all the money "
"you take in has to go out to them. What if you need to license 21 patents?"
msgstr ""
-"No obstante, muchos titulares de patentes sà ofrecen licencias, pero a "
-"menudo piden mucho dinero por ellas. La compañÃa que concedÃa licencias
para "
-"la patente sobre el recálculo en orden natural pedÃa un cinco por ciento de
"
-"los ingresos brutos por cada hoja de cálculo vendida en EE. UU. Según "
-"me han dicho, ese era el precio reducido anterior al juicio. En caso de "
-"juicio, si el titular de la patente acaba ganando, exigirá más. Quizá uno "
-"pueda permitirse ese cinco por ciento por la licencia de una patente, pero "
-"¿y si para desarrollar el programa hiciera falta la licencia de veinte "
-"patentes? Pues en ese caso todo el dinero que se consiga se lo llevarán las "
-"patentes. ¿Y si hay que obtener la licencia de ventiuna patentes?"
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | People in business told me that{+,+} practically speaking, [-2-] {+two+}
-# | or [-3-] {+three+} of them would make any business unfeasible.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "People in business told me that practically speaking, 2 or 3 of them "
-#| "would make any business unfeasible."
+"No obstante, muchos dueños de patentes sà ofrecen licencias, pero a menudo "
+"piden mucho dinero por ellas. La compañÃa que concedÃa licencias para la "
+"patente sobre el recálculo en orden natural pedÃa un cinco por ciento de
los "
+"ingresos brutos por cada hoja de cálculo vendida en EE. UU. Según me "
+"han dicho, ese era el precio reducido anterior al juicio. En caso de juicio, "
+"si el dueño de la patente acababa ganando, exigirÃa más. Quizá uno pueda "
+"permitirse ese cinco por ciento por la licencia de una patente, pero ¿y si "
+"para desarrollar el programa hiciera falta la licencia de veinte patentes? "
+"Pues en ese caso todo el dinero que se consiga se lo llevarán ellos. ¿Y si "
+"hubiera que obtener la licencia de veintiuna patentes?"
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"People in business told me that, practically speaking, two or three of them "
"would make any business unfeasible."
@@ -1833,39 +1033,6 @@
"esas harÃan inviable cualquier negocio."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | [-There-]{+But there+} is a situation where licensing patents is a very
-# | good solution. That is if you are a multinational mega-corporation.
-# | Because these companies own a lot of patents, and they cross-license with
-# | each other. That way, they escape most of the harm that the patent system
-# | does and they only get the good. IBM published an <a
-# |
href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20150329104135/http://progfree.org/Links/prep.ai.mit.edu/ibm.think.article\">
-# | article</a> in Think [-magazine. I-] {+magazine—I+} believe it was
-# | issue No. 5 of [-1990 on-] {+1990—on+} IBM's patent portfolio, which
-# | said that IBM got two kinds of benefit{+s+} from its 9000 US patents. I
-# | believe the number is larger today. These were [-first,-] {+(1)+}
-# | collecting royalties{+,+} and [-second,-] {+(2)+} getting access to the
-# | patents of others. They said that the latter benefit [-is-] {+was+} an
-# | order of magnitude greater. So{+,+} the benefit that IBM got from being
-# | allowed to use the ideas that were patented by others was 10 times the
-# | direct benefit IBM could get from licensing patents. [-What does this
-# | really mean?-]
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "There is a situation where licensing patents is a very good solution. "
-#| "That is if you are a multinational mega-corporation. Because these "
-#| "companies own a lot of patents, and they cross-license with each other. "
-#| "That way, they escape most of the harm that the patent system does and "
-#| "they only get the good. IBM published an <a href=\"https://web.archive."
-#| "org/web/20150329104135/http://progfree.org/Links/prep.ai.mit.edu/ibm."
-#| "think.article\"> article</a> in Think magazine. I believe it was issue "
-#| "No. 5 of 1990 on IBM's patent portfolio, which said that IBM got two "
-#| "kinds of benefit from its 9000 US patents. I believe the number is "
-#| "larger today. These were first, collecting royalties and second, getting "
-#| "access to the patents of others. They said that the latter benefit is an "
-#| "order of magnitude greater. So the benefit that IBM got from being "
-#| "allowed to use the ideas that were patented by others was 10 times the "
-#| "direct benefit IBM could get from licensing patents. What does this "
-#| "really mean?"
msgid ""
"But there is a situation where licensing patents is a very good solution. "
"That is if you are a multinational mega-corporation. Because these "
@@ -1882,8 +1049,8 @@
"the ideas that were patented by others was 10 times the direct benefit IBM "
"could get from licensing patents."
msgstr ""
-"Hay una situación en la que obtener una licencia por el uso de la patente es
"
-"una muy buena solución. Es lo que les ocurre a las megacorporaciones "
+"Hay una situación en la que obtener una licencia por el uso de una patente "
+"es una muy buena solución. Es lo que les ocurre a las megacorporaciones "
"multinacionales. Como estas empresas poseen muchas patentes e intercambian "
"licencias entre ellas, se libran de la mayor parte del daño que provoca el "
"sistema de patentes y disfrutan de todas sus ventajas. IBM publicó un <a "
@@ -1891,32 +1058,14 @@
"prep.ai.mit.edu/ibm.think.article\">artÃculo</a> en la revista <cite>Think</"
"cite> (creo que era el número cinco de 1990) acerca de su cartera de "
"patentes, donde se decÃa que IBM obtenÃa dos tipos de beneficios de sus "
-"9.000 patentes estadounidenses (hoy en dÃa el número debe de ser aún
mayor). "
+"9.000 patentes estadounidenses (creo que hoy en dÃa el número es mayor). "
"Estos eran, en primer lugar, los ingresos por regalÃas, y en segundo lugar, "
-"el acceso a las patentes de otros. DecÃan que el segundo beneficio era mucho
"
-"mayor que el primero. De tal modo que el beneficio obtenido por IBM al "
-"permitÃrsele utilizar las ideas patentadas por otros multiplicaba por diez "
-"el beneficio directo que obtenÃa por ofrecer licencias. ¿Qué significa
esto "
-"en realidad?"
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | What {+does this really mean? What+} is the benefit that IBM gets from
-# | this access to the patents of others? [-It is-] {+It's+} basically the
-# | benefit of being excused from the trouble that the patent system can cause
-# | you. The patent system is like a lottery. What happens with any given
-# | patent could be nothing, could be a windfall for some patent holder [-or-]
-# | {+and+} a disaster for everyone else. But IBM being so big, for them[-,-]
-# | it averages out. They get to measure the average harm and good of the
-# | patent system.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "What is the benefit that IBM gets from this access to the patents of "
-#| "others? It is basically the benefit of being excused from the trouble "
-#| "that the patent system can cause you. The patent system is like a "
-#| "lottery. What happens with any given patent could be nothing, could be a "
-#| "windfall for some patent holder or a disaster for everyone else. But IBM "
-#| "being so big, for them, it averages out. They get to measure the average "
-#| "harm and good of the patent system."
+"el acceso a las patentes de otros. DecÃan que el segundo beneficio era un "
+"orden de magnitud mayor que el primero. De tal modo que el beneficio "
+"obtenido por IBM al permitÃrsele utilizar las ideas patentadas por otros "
+"multiplicaba por diez el beneficio directo que obtenÃa por ofrecer
licencias."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"What does this really mean? What is the benefit that IBM gets from this "
"access to the patents of others? It's basically the benefit of being excused "
@@ -1926,29 +1075,16 @@
"IBM being so big, for them it averages out. They get to measure the average "
"harm and good of the patent system."
msgstr ""
-"¿Cuál es el beneficio de IBM al tener acceso a las patentes de otros? "
-"Esencialmente es el beneficio de verse libre de los problemas que el sistema "
-"de patentes puede ocasionar. El sistema de patentes es como una loterÃa: con
"
-"una patente determinada puede no ocurrir nada, suponer una gran cantidad de "
-"dinero para su titular o un desastre para todos los demás. Pero IBM es una "
-"empresa tan grande que le compensa. Pueden hacer una estimación general de "
-"las ventajas y desventajas del sistema de patentes."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | For them, the trouble [-of the patent system-] would have been 10 times
-# | the good. I say would have been because IBM{+,+} through
-# | cross-licensing{+,+} avoids experiencing that trouble. That trouble is
-# | only potential. It doesn't really happen to them. But when they measure
-# | the benefits of avoiding that trouble, they estimate it as 10 times the
-# | value of the money they collect from their patents.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "For them, the trouble of the patent system would have been 10 times the "
-#| "good. I say would have been because IBM through cross-licensing avoids "
-#| "experiencing that trouble. That trouble is only potential. It doesn't "
-#| "really happen to them. But when they measure the benefits of avoiding "
-#| "that trouble, they estimate it as 10 times the value of the money they "
-#| "collect from their patents."
+"¿Qué significa esto en realidad? ¿Cuál es el beneficio de IBM al tener "
+"acceso a las patentes de otros? Esencialmente es el beneficio de verse libre "
+"de los problemas que el sistema de patentes puede ocasionar. El sistema de "
+"patentes es como una loterÃa. Con una patente determinada puede no ocurrir "
+"nada, o puede suponer un grande beneficio para su dueño y un desastre para "
+"todos los demás. Pero IBM es una empresa tan grande que le compensa. Pueden "
+"hacer una estimación general de las ventajas y desventajas del sistema de "
+"patentes."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"For them, the trouble would have been 10 times the good. I say would have "
"been because IBM, through cross-licensing, avoids experiencing that "
@@ -1957,35 +1093,14 @@
"estimate it as 10 times the value of the money they collect from their "
"patents."
msgstr ""
-"Para ellos, los problemas del sistema de patentes podrÃan haber sido diez "
-"veces mayores que las ventajas. Digo «podrÃan haber sido» porque mediante
el "
-"intercambio de licencias IBM evita esos problemas. Los problemas son solo "
-"potenciales, en realidad no les afectan. Pero cuando evalúan los beneficios "
-"de evitarlos, su estimación es que de esa manera multiplican por diez el "
-"valor del dinero que obtienen por sus patentes."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | This phenomenon of cross-licensing refutes a common myth, the myth of the
-# | starving genius. The myth that patents “protect” the
-# | “small inventor.” Those terms are propaganda terms. You
-# | shouldn't use them. The scenario is like this: Suppose there is a
-# | brilliant designer of [-whatever of whatever. Suppose he-] {+whatever,
-# | who+} has spent years {+by himself,+} starving in [-the attic-] {+an
-# | attic,+} designing a new wonderful kind of whatever{+,+} and now wants to
-# | manufacture [-it and isn't-] {+it. Isn't+} it a shame the big companies
-# | are going to go into competition with him, take away all the business and
-# | he'll [-“starve.”-] {+“starve”?+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "This phenomenon of cross-licensing refutes a common myth, the myth of the "
-#| "starving genius. The myth that patents “protect” the “"
-#| "small inventor.” Those terms are propaganda terms. You shouldn't "
-#| "use them. The scenario is like this: Suppose there is a brilliant "
-#| "designer of whatever of whatever. Suppose he has spent years starving in "
-#| "the attic designing a new wonderful kind of whatever and now wants to "
-#| "manufacture it and isn't it a shame the big companies are going to go "
-#| "into competition with him, take away all the business and he'll “"
-#| "starve.”"
+"Para ellos, los problemas podrÃan haber sido diez veces mayores que las "
+"ventajas. Digo «podrÃan haber sido» porque mediante el intercambio de "
+"licencias IBM evita esos problemas. Los problemas son solo potenciales, en "
+"realidad no les afectan. Pero cuando evalúan los beneficios de evitarlos, su
"
+"estimación es que de esa manera multiplican por diez el valor del dinero que
"
+"obtienen por sus patentes."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"This phenomenon of cross-licensing refutes a common myth, the myth of the "
"starving genius. The myth that patents “protect” the “"
@@ -2000,36 +1115,12 @@
"mito del «genio en la miseria», el mito de que las patentes «protegen» al
"
"«pequeño inventor». Estas son expresiones propagandÃsticas y no
deberÃamos "
"emplearlas. Nos presentan la siguiente historia: imaginemos un brillante "
-"diseñador de lo que sea. Imaginemos que ha pasado años de privaciones en su
"
-"ático diseñando algún nuevo y maravilloso prototipo y ahora quiere "
+"diseñador de cualquier cosa. Imaginemos que ha pasado años de privaciones
en "
+"su ático diseñando algún nuevo y maravilloso prototipo y ahora quiere "
"fabricarlo. ¿No es una vergüenza que las grandes empresas entren en "
"competición con él, se queden con todo su negocio y él «se muera de
hambre»?"
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | {+Well,+} I [-will-] have to point out that people in high tech fields are
-# | not generally working on their own{+,+} and that ideas don't come in a
-# | [-vacuum, they-] {+vacuum—they+} are based on [-ideas-] {+the work+}
-# | of [-others and-] {+others—and that+} these people have pretty good
-# | chances of getting a job if they need to these days. So this scenario,
-# | the idea that [-a-] {+this+} brilliant idea came from this [-brilliant-]
-# | {+one+} person working alone{+,+} is unrealistic{+,+} and the idea that he
-# | is in danger of starving is unrealistic. But it is conceivable that
-# | somebody could have an idea{+,+} and this [-idea along-] {+idea, maybe
-# | together+} with 100 or 200 other [-ideas can-] {+ideas, could+} be the
-# | basis of making some kind of product{+,+} and that big companies might
-# | want to compete with him.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "I will have to point out that people in high tech fields are not "
-#| "generally working on their own and that ideas don't come in a vacuum, "
-#| "they are based on ideas of others and these people have pretty good "
-#| "chances of getting a job if they need to these days. So this scenario, "
-#| "the idea that a brilliant idea came from this brilliant person working "
-#| "alone is unrealistic and the idea that he is in danger of starving is "
-#| "unrealistic. But it is conceivable that somebody could have an idea and "
-#| "this idea along with 100 or 200 other ideas can be the basis of making "
-#| "some kind of product and that big companies might want to compete with "
-#| "him."
msgid ""
"Well, I have to point out that people in high tech fields are not generally "
"working on their own, and that ideas don't come in a vacuum—they are "
@@ -2050,38 +1141,9 @@
"igual que la idea de que se encuentre en riesgo de pasar hambre. Pero sà es "
"concebible que alguien tenga una idea que junto con otras cien o doscientas "
"ideas pueda servir de base para la fabricación de algún tipo de producto, y
"
-"que las grandes compañÃas puedan querer competir con esta persona."
+"que las grandes compañÃas puedan querer competir con esa persona."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | So let's see what happens if he tries to use a patent to stop them. He
-# | says{+,+} “Oh [-N-]{+n+}o, IBM. You [-cannot-] {+can't+} compete
-# | with me. I've got this [-patent.-] {+patent.” And+} IBM [-says
-# | let's-] {+says, “Let's+} see. Let's look at your product. Hmmm.
-# | I've got this patent and this one and this one and this one and this one
-# | and this one, which parts of your product infringe. If you think you can
-# | fight against all of them in court, [-I will-] {+I'll+} just go back and
-# | [-find-] {+look for+} some more. So, why don't you cross[- -]{+-+}license
-# | with me?” And then this brilliant small {+<i
-# | class=\"aside\">[laughs]</i>+} inventor says{+,+} “Well, OK, I'll
-# | [-cross license.” So-] {+cross-license.” And now+} he can go
-# | back and make these wonderful whatever it is, [-but-] {+and+} so can IBM.
-# | IBM {+now+} gets access to his patent{+,+} and gets the right to compete
-# | with him, which means that this patent didn't “protect” him at
-# | all. The patent system doesn't really do that.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "So let's see what happens if he tries to use a patent to stop them. He "
-#| "says “Oh No, IBM. You cannot compete with me. I've got this "
-#| "patent. IBM says let's see. Let's look at your product. Hmmm. I've "
-#| "got this patent and this one and this one and this one and this one and "
-#| "this one, which parts of your product infringe. If you think you can "
-#| "fight against all of them in court, I will just go back and find some "
-#| "more. So, why don't you cross license with me?” And then this "
-#| "brilliant small inventor says “Well, OK, I'll cross license.” "
-#| "So he can go back and make these wonderful whatever it is, but so can "
-#| "IBM. IBM gets access to his patent and gets the right to compete with "
-#| "him, which means that this patent didn't “protect” him at "
-#| "all. The patent system doesn't really do that."
msgid ""
"So let's see what happens if he tries to use a patent to stop them. He "
"says, “Oh no, IBM. You can't compete with me. I've got this patent."
@@ -2097,45 +1159,20 @@
"protect” him at all. The patent system doesn't really do that."
msgstr ""
"Veamos pues qué sucederÃa si esa persona intentara usar una patente para "
-"impedirlo. Ãl dirá: «Ah, no, IBM, no puedes competir conmigo. Tengo esta "
+"impedirlo. Dirá: «Ah, no, IBM, no puedes competir conmigo. Tengo esta "
"patente». E IBM responderá: «Veamos. Echemos un vistazo a tu producto. "
-"Mmmm. .. Yo tengo esta patente, y esta otra, y esta otra, y esta otra, y "
-"esta otra, y esta otra, que son infringidas por algunas partes de tu "
-"producto. Si crees que puedes luchar contra todas ellas en los tribunales, "
-"volveré y encontraré unas cuantas más. Asà que, ¿por qué no
intercambias "
-"licencias conmigo?». Y entonces el brillante pequeño inventor dirá:
«Bueno, "
-"vale, intercambiemos licencias». Entonces podrá volver a su casa y fabricar
"
-"ese maravilloso lo que sea, pero también IBM podrá hacerlo. IBM obtiene "
-"acceso a su patente y el derecho a competir con él, lo que significa que esa
"
-"patente no lo «protegió» en absoluto. En realidad el sistema de patentes
no "
-"sirve para eso."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | The mega-corporations avoid, for the most part, the harm of the patent
-# | system. They see mainly the good side. [-That is-] {+That's+} why they
-# | want to have software patents. They are the ones who will benefit from
-# | it. But if you are {+really+} a small inventor{+,+} or work for a small
-# | company, the small company is not going to be able to do this. They try.
-# | The problem is that they cannot get enough patents to do this. [-Any-]
-# | {+You see, any+} given patent is pointing in a certain direction. So{+,+}
-# | if a small company has patents pointing there, there{+,+} and there {+<i
-# | class=\"aside\">[showing left side]</i>,+} and somebody over there {+<i
-# | class=\"aside\">[showing right side]</i>+} points a patent at them and
-# | says [-give-] {+“Give+} me your [-money,-] {+money,”+} they
-# | are [-helpless.-] {+helpless, because they've got patents pointing there
-# | or near <i class=\"aside\">[showing left side]</i>, but not there <i
-# | class=\"aside\">[showing right side]</i>.+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "The mega-corporations avoid, for the most part, the harm of the patent "
-#| "system. They see mainly the good side. That is why they want to have "
-#| "software patents. They are the ones who will benefit from it. But if "
-#| "you are a small inventor or work for a small company, the small company "
-#| "is not going to be able to do this. They try. The problem is that they "
-#| "cannot get enough patents to do this. Any given patent is pointing in a "
-#| "certain direction. So if a small company has patents pointing there, "
-#| "there and there and somebody over there points a patent at them and says "
-#| "give me your money, they are helpless."
+"Mmm. .. Yo tengo esta patente, y esta otra, y esta otra, y esta otra, y esta "
+"otra, y esta otra, que son infringidas por algunas partes de tu producto. Si "
+"crees que puedes luchar contra todas ellas en los tribunales, encontraré "
+"unas cuantas más. Asà que, ¿por qué no intercambias licencias conmigo?».
Y "
+"entonces el brillante pequeño inventor <i class=\"aside\">[risas]</i> dirá:
"
+"«Bueno, vale, intercambiemos licencias». Entonces podrá volver a su casa y
"
+"fabricar ese maravilloso lo que sea, pero también IBM podrá hacerlo. IBM "
+"obtiene acceso a su patente y el derecho a competir con él, lo que significa
"
+"que esa patente no lo «protegió» en absoluto. En realidad el sistema de "
+"patentes no sirve para eso."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"The mega-corporations avoid, for the most part, the harm of the patent "
"system. They see mainly the good side. That's why they want to have "
@@ -2151,33 +1188,21 @@
"side]</i>, but not there <i class=\"aside\">[showing right side]</i>."
msgstr ""
"Las megacorporaciones se ven libres de la mayor parte del daño que ocasiona "
-"el sistema de patentes. Fundamentalmente disfrutan de sus ventajas, por eso "
-"quieren que existan patentes de software: son las únicas que se
beneficiarán "
-"de ello. Pero si se es un pequeño inventor o se trabaja para una pequeña "
-"empresa, esa pequeña empresa no podrá hacerlo. Lo intentan, pero el
problema "
-"es que no pueden conseguir una cantidad suficiente de patentes como para "
-"hacerlo. Toda patente apunta en una dirección determinada. De modo que si "
-"una pequeña empresa tiene patentes que apuntan aquÃ, ahà y allá, y
alguien "
-"llega y le apunta con una patente diciendo: «Dame tu dinero», se ve "
-"indefensa.."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | IBM can do it{+,+} because with these 9000 patents, they are pointing
-# | [-everywhere, no-] {+everywhere. No+} matter where you are, there is
-# | [-probably-] an IBM patent pointing at [-you. So-] {+you, probably.
-# | So,+} IBM can [-almost-] always make you [-cross license. Small-]
-# | {+cross-license, almost always. But the small+} companies [-can-] only
-# | occasionally {+can+} make someone cross-license. They will say they want
-# | patents for defensive purposes{+,+} but they won't get enough to be able
-# | to defend themselves.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "IBM can do it because with these 9000 patents, they are pointing "
-#| "everywhere, no matter where you are, there is probably an IBM patent "
-#| "pointing at you. So IBM can almost always make you cross license. Small "
-#| "companies can only occasionally make someone cross-license. They will "
-#| "say they want patents for defensive purposes but they won't get enough to "
-#| "be able to defend themselves."
+"el sistema de patentes. Fundamentalmente disfrutan de sus ventajas, es por "
+"eso quieren que existan patentes de software, son las únicas que se "
+"beneficiarán con ellas. Pero si se es realmente un pequeño inventor o se "
+"trabaja para una pequeña empresa, esa pequeña empresa no podrá hacerlo. Lo
"
+"intentan, pero el problema es que no pueden obtener una cantidad suficiente "
+"de patentes como para hacerlo. Toda patente apunta en una dirección "
+"determinada. De modo que si una pequeña empresa tiene patentes que apuntan "
+"aquÃ, ahà y allà <i class=\"aside\">[señalando hacia la izquierda]</i>, y
"
+"alguien llega desde allá <i class=\"aside\">[señalando hacia la
derecha]</i> "
+"y le apunta con una patente diciendo: «Dame tu dinero», se ve indefensa "
+"porque posee patentes que apuntan allà o cerca de allà <i class=\"aside"
+"\">[señalando hacia la izquierda]</i>, pero no allá <i class=\"aside"
+"\">[señalando hacia la derecha]</i>."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"IBM can do it, because with these 9000 patents, they are pointing "
"everywhere. No matter where you are, there is an IBM patent pointing at you, "
@@ -2211,23 +1236,6 @@
"desarrollando algo."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | There are no patents on legal procedures. {+<i
-# | class=\"aside\">[laughs]</i> +} I guess the lawyers {+sort of+}
-# | understand what a pain it would be to have to deal with the patent system
-# | themselves. The result is that there is no way [-to-] {+you can+} get a
-# | patent to make that [-company cross license-] {+company, <a
-# |
href=\"https://www.nytimes.com/1990/01/14/business/a-white-knight-draws-cries-of-patent-blackmail.html\">
-# | Refac</a>, cross-license+} with you. So they go around squeezing everyone.
-# | But I guess {+the+} companies like IBM figure [-that is-] {+that's+} part
-# | of the price of doing business so they can live with it.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "There are no patents on legal procedures. I guess the lawyers understand "
-#| "what a pain it would be to have to deal with the patent system "
-#| "themselves. The result is that there is no way to get a patent to make "
-#| "that company cross license with you. So they go around squeezing "
-#| "everyone. But I guess companies like IBM figure that is part of the "
-#| "price of doing business so they can live with it."
msgid ""
"There are no patents on legal procedures. <i class=\"aside\">[laughs]</"
"i> I guess the lawyers sort of understand what a pain it would be to "
@@ -2238,22 +1246,17 @@
"squeezing everyone. But I guess the companies like IBM figure that's part "
"of the price of doing business so they can live with it."
msgstr ""
-"No hay patentes que cubran procedimientos legales. Supongo que los abogados "
-"comprenden lo penoso que serÃa tener que vérselas ellos mismos con el "
-"sistema de patentes. En consecuencia, no hay forma de obtener una patente "
-"para hacer que esa empresa intercambie licencias, lo que les permite ir por "
-"ahà exprimiendo a todo el mundo. Pero supongo que empresas como IBM calculan
"
-"que eso es parte del precio que hay que pagar por hacer negocios, de manera "
-"que pueden vivir con ello."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | So [-that is-] {+that's+} the possibility of licensing a patent{+,+} which
-# | may or may not be [-possible and-] {+possible. And+} you may or may not be
-# | able to afford it.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "So that is the possibility of licensing a patent which may or may not be "
-#| "possible and you may or may not be able to afford it."
+"No hay patentes que cubran procedimientos legales. <i class=\"aside"
+"\">[risas]</i> Supongo que los abogados comprenden lo penoso que serÃa "
+"tener que vérselas ellos mismos con el sistema de patentes. En consecuencia,
"
+"no hay forma de obtener una patente para hacer que esa empresa, <a href="
+"\"https://www.nytimes.com/1990/01/14/business/a-white-knight-draws-cries-of-"
+"patent-blackmail.html\"> Refac</a>, intercambie licencias, lo que les "
+"permite ir por ahà exprimiendo a todo el mundo. Pero supongo que empresas "
+"como IBM calculan que eso es parte del precio que hay que pagar por hacer "
+"negocios, de manera que pueden vivir con ello."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"So that's the possibility of licensing a patent, which may or may not be "
"possible. And you may or may not be able to afford it."
@@ -2262,32 +1265,10 @@
"será posible o no, dependiendo de si uno puede permitÃrselo."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dt>
-# | {+3.+} Overturning the patent in court[-.-]
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid "Overturning the patent in court."
msgid "3. Overturning the patent in court"
-msgstr "Revocar la patente en los tribunales"
+msgstr "3. Revocar la patente en los tribunales"
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | Supposedly, in order to be patented, something has to be new, useful and
-# | unobvious. [-That is-] {+That's+} the language used in the US. I think
-# | other countries have different language which is pretty much equivalent to
-# | it. Of course, when the patent office gets into the [-game,-] {+game
-# | and+} they start interpreting new and [-unobvious. New-] {+unobvious,
-# | “new”+} turns out to mean [-we-] {+“we+} don't have it
-# | in our [-files-] {+files,”+} and [-unobvious-]
-# | {+“unobvious”+} tends to mean [-unobvious-]
-# | {+“unobvious+} to [-someone-] {+somebody+} with an IQ of [-50.-]
-# | {+50.”+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Supposedly, in order to be patented, something has to be new, useful and "
-#| "unobvious. That is the language used in the US. I think other countries "
-#| "have different language which is pretty much equivalent to it. Of "
-#| "course, when the patent office gets into the game, they start "
-#| "interpreting new and unobvious. New turns out to mean we don't have it "
-#| "in our files and unobvious tends to mean unobvious to someone with an IQ "
-#| "of 50."
msgid ""
"Supposedly, in order to be patented, something has to be new, useful and "
"unobvious. That's the language used in the US. I think other countries "
@@ -2299,27 +1280,13 @@
msgstr ""
"Supuestamente, para que algo se patente tiene que ser nuevo, útil y no "
"obvio. Es el léxico usado en EE. UU. Creo que en otros paÃses emplean "
-"términos diferentes que son prácticamente equivalentes. Por supuesto,
cuando "
-"la oficina de patentes entra en juego, comienza por interpretar lo que es "
-"«nuevo» y «no obvio». «Nuevo» viene a significar «no lo tenemos en
nuestros "
-"archivos» y «no obvio» suele significar «no obvio para alguien con un "
-"cociente intelectual de 50»."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | Somebody who studies most of the software patents issued in the [-US, or-]
-# | {+US—or+} at least he used to[-,-]{+;+} I don't know if he can still
-# | keep up with [-them, said-] {+them—said+} that 90% of them wouldn't
-# | pass the [-crystal city-] {+Crystal City+} test, which meant{+,+} if the
-# | people in the patent office went outside to the news stand and got some
-# | computer magazines, they would see that these ideas [-are-] {+were+}
-# | already known.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Somebody who studies most of the software patents issued in the US, or at "
-#| "least he used to, I don't know if he can still keep up with them, said "
-#| "that 90% of them wouldn't pass the crystal city test, which meant if the "
-#| "people in the patent office went outside to the news stand and got some "
-#| "computer magazines, they would see that these ideas are already known."
+"términos diferentes que son prácticamente equivalentes. Claro que cuando la
"
+"oficina de patentes entra en juego y comienza a interpretar lo que es nuevo "
+"y no obvio, «nuevo» viene a significar «no lo tenemos en nuestros
archivos» "
+"y «no obvio» suele significar «no obvio para alguien con un cociente "
+"intelectual de 50»."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"Somebody who studies most of the software patents issued in the US—or "
"at least he used to; I don't know if he can still keep up with them—"
@@ -2332,31 +1299,10 @@
"cantidad que hay— decÃa que el 90% de ellas no pasarÃa el «test de "
"Cristal City» [Cristal City es la zona de Washington donde se encuentra la "
"oficina de patentes], con lo querÃa decir que si el personal de la oficina "
-"de patentes bajara al kiosco y adquiriera algunas revistas de informática, "
+"de patentes fuera al kiosco y adquiriera algunas revistas de informática, "
"comprobarÃa que esas ideas ya se conocÃan."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | The patent office does things that are so obviously foolish, you wouldn't
-# | even have to know the state of the art to see they are foolish. This is
-# | not limited to software. I once saw the famous Harvard mouse patent{+,+}
-# | which was obtained after Harvard genetically engineered a strain of mouse
-# | with a cancer causing gene. The cancer causing gene was already
-# | known{+,+} and was inserted using known techniques into an already
-# | existing strain of mouse. The patent they got covered inserting any
-# | cancer causing gene into any kind of mammal{+,+} using any method
-# | whatsoever. You don't have to know anything about genetic engineering to
-# | realize that is ridiculous.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "The patent office does things that are so obviously foolish, you wouldn't "
-#| "even have to know the state of the art to see they are foolish. This is "
-#| "not limited to software. I once saw the famous Harvard mouse patent "
-#| "which was obtained after Harvard genetically engineered a strain of mouse "
-#| "with a cancer causing gene. The cancer causing gene was already known "
-#| "and was inserted using known techniques into an already existing strain "
-#| "of mouse. The patent they got covered inserting any cancer causing gene "
-#| "into any kind of mammal using any method whatsoever. You don't have to "
-#| "know anything about genetic engineering to realize that is ridiculous."
msgid ""
"The patent office does things that are so obviously foolish, you wouldn't "
"even have to know the state of the art to see they are foolish. This is not "
@@ -2380,18 +1326,6 @@
"es ridÃculo."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | {+But+} I am told that this over[- -]claiming is normal practice{+,+} and
-# | that the US Patent Office sometimes invited patent applicants to make
-# | their claims broader. Basically{+,+} make the claims broader until you
-# | think they are running into something else that's unambiguous prior art.
-# | See how much land grab in mental space you can get away with.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "I am told that this over claiming is normal practice and that the US "
-#| "Patent Office sometimes invited patent applicants to make their claims "
-#| "broader. Basically make the claims broader until you think they are "
-#| "running into something else that's unambiguous prior art. See how much "
-#| "land grab in mental space you can get away with."
msgid ""
"But I am told that this overclaiming is normal practice, and that the US "
"Patent Office sometimes invited patent applicants to make their claims "
@@ -2409,34 +1343,6 @@
#
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | When programmers look at a lot of software patents, they [-say this-]
-# | {+say, “This+} is ridiculously <a
-# |
href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20040604051644/http://people.qualcomm.com/karn/patents/patent-comments.html\">
-# | [-obvious</a>!-] {+obvious</a>!”+} Patent bureaucrats have all sorts
-# | of excuses to justify ignoring what programmers think. They say
-# | “Oh! But you have to consider it in terms of the way things were 10
-# | or 20 years ago.” Then they discovered that if they talk something
-# | to death then you can eventually lose your bearings. Anything can look
-# | unobvious if you tear it apart enough, analyze it enough. You simply lose
-# | all standard of obviousness{+,+} or at least lose the ability to justify
-# | any standard of obvious or unobvious. Then, of course, they describe the
-# | patent holders as brilliant inventors, all of them. Therefore we can't
-# | question their entitlement to power over what we can do.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "When programmers look at a lot of software patents, they say this is "
-#| "ridiculously <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20040604051644/http://"
-#| "people.qualcomm.com/karn/patents/patent-comments.html\"> obvious</a>! "
-#| "Patent bureaucrats have all sorts of excuses to justify ignoring what "
-#| "programmers think. They say “Oh! But you have to consider it in "
-#| "terms of the way things were 10 or 20 years ago.” Then they "
-#| "discovered that if they talk something to death then you can eventually "
-#| "lose your bearings. Anything can look unobvious if you tear it apart "
-#| "enough, analyze it enough. You simply lose all standard of obviousness "
-#| "or at least lose the ability to justify any standard of obvious or "
-#| "unobvious. Then, of course, they describe the patent holders as "
-#| "brilliant inventors, all of them. Therefore we can't question their "
-#| "entitlement to power over what we can do."
msgid ""
"When programmers look at a lot of software patents, they say, “This is "
"ridiculously <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20040604051644/http://"
@@ -2462,27 +1368,11 @@
"obvia si se divide en partes cada vez más pequeñas y se analiza lo "
"suficiente. Uno acaba perdiendo toda noción de obviedad, o al menos la "
"capacidad de justificar cualquier criterio para discernir lo obvio de lo que "
-"no lo es. Luego, por supuesto, describen a todos los titulares de las "
-"patentes, sin excepción, como brillantes inventores. Por tanto, no podemos "
-"cuestionar su autoridad para decidir sobre lo que podemos o no podemos hacer."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | If you go to court, the judges are likely to be a little more stringent
-# | about the idea of what is obvious or not. But the problem is [-that-] it
-# | costs millions of dollars to do that. I heard of one patent case, the
-# | defendant I remember was Qualcomm, and I believe the ruling [-was-]
-# | ultimately {+was+} 13 million dollars{+,+} of which most went to pay the
-# | lawyers on both sides. There were a few million dollars left over for the
-# | plaintiff, because they lost.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "If you go to court, the judges are likely to be a little more stringent "
-#| "about the idea of what is obvious or not. But the problem is that it "
-#| "costs millions of dollars to do that. I heard of one patent case, the "
-#| "defendant I remember was Qualcomm, and I believe the ruling was "
-#| "ultimately 13 million dollars of which most went to pay the lawyers on "
-#| "both sides. There were a few million dollars left over for the "
-#| "plaintiff, because they lost."
+"no lo es. Luego, por supuesto, describen a todos los dueños de las patentes,
"
+"sin excepción, como brillantes inventores. Por tanto, no podemos cuestionar "
+"su autoridad para decidir sobre lo que podemos o no podemos hacer."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"If you go to court, the judges are likely to be a little more stringent "
"about the idea of what is obvious or not. But the problem is it costs "
@@ -2500,19 +1390,6 @@
"demandante, ya que Qualcomm perdió."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | To a large extent, the question of the validity of a patent will depend on
-# | historical accidents. Lots of historical accidents{+,+} such as precisely
-# | what was published when{+,+} and which of those things somebody manages to
-# | [-find. Which-] {+find, which+} of them didn't get lost, {+the+} precise
-# | dates{+,+} and [-so-on. Many-] {+so on. So it's many+} historical
-# | accidents {+that+} determine whether [-a-] {+the+} patent is valid.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "To a large extent, the question of the validity of a patent will depend "
-#| "on historical accidents. Lots of historical accidents such as precisely "
-#| "what was published when and which of those things somebody manages to "
-#| "find. Which of them didn't get lost, precise dates and so-on. Many "
-#| "historical accidents determine whether a patent is valid."
msgid ""
"To a large extent, the question of the validity of a patent will depend on "
"historical accidents. Lots of historical accidents, such as precisely what "
@@ -2528,34 +1405,6 @@
"una patente es válida o no."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | In fact, it is a weird thing [-that-] the <a
-# | href=\"https://patents.justia.com/patent/4873662\"> British Telecom
-# | following hyper[- -]links together with [-telephone access patent</a>, I
-# | think,-] {+phone access</a> patent,+} was applied [-for-] {+for, I
-# | think,+} in 1975. I think it was in 1974 that I developed the
-# | [-i-]{+I+}nfo package for the first time. The [-i-]{+I+}nfo package
-# | allows you to traverse [-hyper links-] {+hyperlinks,+} and people did use
-# | telephones to dial up and access the system. So in fact, I produced a
-# | piece of prior art for that patent. [-So that is-] {+That's+} the second
-# | patentable idea [-I have-] {+I've+} had in my life, but I don't think I
-# | have any proof of that. I didn't think this was interesting enough to
-# | publish it. After all, the idea of following [-hyper links-]
-# | {+hyperlinks,+} I got {+that+} from [-the-] {+a+} demo of Engelbart's
-# | editor. He is the one who had an idea [-which-] {+that+} was interesting
-# | to publish.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "In fact, it is a weird thing that the <a href=\"https://patents.justia."
-#| "com/patent/4873662\"> British Telecom following hyper links together with "
-#| "telephone access patent</a>, I think, was applied for in 1975. I think "
-#| "it was in 1974 that I developed the info package for the first time. The "
-#| "info package allows you to traverse hyper links and people did use "
-#| "telephones to dial up and access the system. So in fact, I produced a "
-#| "piece of prior art for that patent. So that is the second patentable "
-#| "idea I have had in my life, but I don't think I have any proof of that. "
-#| "I didn't think this was interesting enough to publish it. After all, the "
-#| "idea of following hyper links I got from the demo of Engelbart's editor. "
-#| "He is the one who had an idea which was interesting to publish."
msgid ""
"In fact, it is a weird thing the <a href=\"https://patents.justia.com/"
"patent/4873662\"> British Telecom following hyperlinks together with phone "
@@ -2573,7 +1422,7 @@
"patent/4873662\">patente de British Telecom sobre el seguimiento de "
"hipervÃnculos mediante acceso telefónico</a> se solicitara, según creo, en
"
"1975. Creo que fue en 1974 cuando por primera vez desarrollé el paquete "
-"info. Este paquete permite utilizar hipervÃnculos, y la gente usaba el "
+"Info. Este paquete permite utilizar hipervÃnculos, y la gente usaba el "
"teléfono para conectarse y acceder al sistema. Asà que lo cierto es que yo "
"produje con anterioridad una obra que utilizaba la técnica descrita en esa "
"patente. De modo que esa es la segunda idea patentable que he tenido en mi "
@@ -2583,39 +1432,6 @@
"quien tuvo una idea que merecÃa publicarse."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | [-What I'd done-]I called {+it+} “poor man's [-hypertext” as-]
-# | {+hypertext,” because+} I had to implement it in the context of
-# | TECO. It [-was not-] {+wasn't+} as powerful as his hypertext{+,+} but it
-# | was at least useful for browsing documentation, which [-it-] {+was+} all
-# | it was meant for, and as for there being dial-up access to the system,
-# | well, there was, but it didn't occur to me that the one had [-anything-]
-# | {+any+} particular {+thing+} to do with the other. I wasn't going to
-# | {+try to+} publish a paper saying “Oh! I implemented this poor man's
-# | hypertext, and guess what! There are dial-up lines on the computer
-# | too!” {+<i class=\"aside\">[laughs]</i> +} I suspect there is
-# | no way to tell precisely on what dates I implemented this. And was it
-# | published in any sense? Well, we invited guests to come in across the
-# | ARPAnet[-,-] and log in on our machine, so they could have browsed
-# | documentation using [-info-] {+Info,+} and seen the thing. [-If-] {+And
-# | if+} they had asked us, they would have found we have dial-up access. But
-# | as you can see, historical accident determines whether [-you have-]
-# | {+you've got+} prior art.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "What I'd done I called “poor man's hypertext” as I had to "
-#| "implement it in the context of TECO. It was not as powerful as his "
-#| "hypertext but it was at least useful for browsing documentation, which it "
-#| "all it was meant for, and as for there being dial-up access to the "
-#| "system, well, there was, but it didn't occur to me that the one had "
-#| "anything particular to do with the other. I wasn't going to publish a "
-#| "paper saying “Oh! I implemented this poor man's hypertext, and "
-#| "guess what! There are dial-up lines on the computer too!” I suspect "
-#| "there is no way to tell precisely on what dates I implemented this. And "
-#| "was it published in any sense? Well, we invited guests to come in across "
-#| "the ARPAnet, and log in on our machine, so they could have browsed "
-#| "documentation using info and seen the thing. If they had asked us, they "
-#| "would have found we have dial-up access. But as you can see, historical "
-#| "accident determines whether you have prior art."
msgid ""
"I called it “poor man's hypertext,” because I had to implement "
"it in the context of TECO. It wasn't as powerful as his hypertext, but it "
@@ -2632,34 +1448,22 @@
"they would have found we have dial-up access. But as you can see, "
"historical accident determines whether you've got prior art."
msgstr ""
-"A lo que habÃa hecho lo llamé «hipertexto del pobre», dado que tenÃa que
"
-"implementarlo en el contexto de TECO. No tenÃa tanta capacidad como el "
-"hipertexto de Englebart, pero al menos era útil para hojear documentación, "
-"que era todo lo que pretendÃa. Y en cuanto a que hubiera acceso telefónico "
-"al sistema, bueno, lo habÃa, pero no se me ocurrió que lo uno tuviera "
-"ninguna relación particular con lo otro. No iba a publicar un artÃculo para
"
-"decir: «¡Oh!, he implementado el hipertexto del pobre, y sabéis qué, "
-"¡también hay acceso telefónico en el ordenador!». Sospecho que no hay
manera "
-"de precisar en qué fecha implementé esto. Y ¿fue publicado en algún
sentido? "
-"Bueno, invitamos a la gente a que entrara en ARPAnet y se registrara en "
-"nuestra máquina, de modo que pudieran buscar documentación utilizando info
y "
-"ver cómo funcionaba todo. Si nos hubieran preguntado, habrÃan descubierto "
-"que tenÃamos acceso telefónico. Como pueden ver, una circunstancia
histórica "
-"determina si una técnica es original o no."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | Now of course, there is a publication made by Engelbart about hypertext,
-# | which they are going to show. I don't think it says anything about having
-# | dial-ups on the computer [-however, so-] {+however. So,+} whether it will
-# | suffice is not clear. [-So, this is an option, the possibility of going
-# | to court to overturn the patent.-]
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Now of course, there is a publication made by Engelbart about hypertext, "
-#| "which they are going to show. I don't think it says anything about "
-#| "having dial-ups on the computer however, so whether it will suffice is "
-#| "not clear. So, this is an option, the possibility of going to court to "
-#| "overturn the patent."
+"Lo llamé «hipertexto del pobre», dado que tenÃa que implementarlo en el "
+"contexto de TECO. No tenÃa tanta capacidad como el hipertexto de Englebart, "
+"pero al menos era útil para hojear documentación, que era todo lo que "
+"pretendÃa. Y en cuanto a que hubiera acceso telefónico al sistema, bueno,
lo "
+"habÃa, pero no se me ocurrió que lo uno tuviera alguna relación particular
"
+"con lo otro. No iba a publicar un artÃculo para decir: «¡Oh!, he "
+"implementado el hipertexto del pobre, y sabéis qué, ¡también hay acceso "
+"telefónico en el ordenador!». <i class=\"aside\">[risas]</i> Sospecho
"
+"que no hay manera de precisar en qué fecha implementé esto. Y ¿fue
publicado "
+"en algún sentido? Bueno, invitamos a la gente a que entrara en ARPAnet y se "
+"registrara en nuestra máquina, de modo que pudieran buscar documentación "
+"utilizando Info y ver cómo funcionaba todo. Si nos hubieran preguntado, "
+"habrÃan descubierto que tenÃamos acceso telefónico. Como pueden ver, una "
+"circunstancia histórica determina si una técnica es original o no."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
msgid ""
"Now of course, there is a publication made by Engelbart about hypertext, "
"which they are going to show. I don't think it says anything about having "
@@ -2668,34 +1472,9 @@
"Claro que ahora hay una publicación de Englebart sobre el hipertexto, que se
"
"presentará en los tribunales. De todos modos, no creo que diga nada sobre "
"disponer de acceso telefónico en el ordenador, de manera que no está claro "
-"si resultará suficiente. Asà pues, esta es una opción, la posibilidad de "
-"acudir a los tribunales para revocar una patente."
+"si resultará suficiente."
#. type: Content of: <div><dl><dd><p>
-# | [-Because-]{+So, this is an option, the possibility of going to court to
-# | overturn the patent. But, because+} of the expense, it is often out of
-# | the question even if you can find solid prior art that ought to be
-# | sufficient to overturn the patent. As a result, an invalid patent, a
-# | patent that nominally shouldn't have existed (but in fact lots and lots of
-# | them do) is a dangerous weapon. If somebody attacks you with an invalid
-# | patent, that can really cause a lot of trouble for you. You might be able
-# | to bluff them away by showing them the prior art. It depends [-upon-]
-# | whether they can get scared off that way or they might think
-# | “[-w-]{+W+}ell, you are just bluffing, we figure you can't really go
-# | to [-court, you-] {+court. You+} can't afford it{+,+} so we'll sue you
-# | anyway.”
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Because of the expense, it is often out of the question even if you can "
-#| "find solid prior art that ought to be sufficient to overturn the patent. "
-#| "As a result, an invalid patent, a patent that nominally shouldn't have "
-#| "existed (but in fact lots and lots of them do) is a dangerous weapon. If "
-#| "somebody attacks you with an invalid patent, that can really cause a lot "
-#| "of trouble for you. You might be able to bluff them away by showing them "
-#| "the prior art. It depends upon whether they can get scared off that way "
-#| "or they might think “well, you are just bluffing, we figure you "
-#| "can't really go to court, you can't afford it so we'll sue you anyway."
-#| "”"
msgid ""
"So, this is an option, the possibility of going to court to overturn the "
"patent. But, because of the expense, it is often out of the question even "
@@ -2708,40 +1487,19 @@
"might think “Well, you are just bluffing, we figure you can't really "
"go to court. You can't afford it, so we'll sue you anyway.”"
msgstr ""
-"Debido a los gastos que supone, normalmente ni se plantea, aun cuando se "
-"puedan encontrar pruebas sólidas de la existencia de una técnica anterior "
-"que deberÃan bastar para revocar la patente. En consecuencia, una patente "
-"inválida, que teóricamente no deberÃa existir (aunque en realidad existen "
-"muchas de ellas) es un arma peligrosa. Si alguien nos ataca con una patente "
-"inválida, puede causarnos serios problemas. Podemos tratar de disuadirlo "
-"mostrándole la técnica anterior. Quizá de ese modo se asuste, o puede que "
-"piense: «Estás fingiendo, sabemos que en realidad no puedes ir a juicio, no
"
-"te lo puedes permitir, asà que te demandaremos de todos modos»."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | All of these three possibilities are things that sometimes you can manage
-# | to use, but often you can't. So you have to face patent after patent
-# | after patent. Each time you may be able to find one of these three
-# | possibilities you can use, then there is another patent{+,+} then
-# | another{+,+} and another. It gets like crossing a minefield. Each step
-# | you take, each design decision, probably won't step on a [-patent, so-]
-# | {+patent. So+} you can take a few steps [-and probably-] {+and,
-# | probably,+} there won't be an explosion. But the chance {+that+} you will
-# | get all the way through the minefield and get to develop the program you
-# | [-want-] {+wanted+} to develop without ever stepping on a patent gets less
-# | and less as the program gets bigger.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "All of these three possibilities are things that sometimes you can manage "
-#| "to use, but often you can't. So you have to face patent after patent "
-#| "after patent. Each time you may be able to find one of these three "
-#| "possibilities you can use, then there is another patent then another and "
-#| "another. It gets like crossing a minefield. Each step you take, each "
-#| "design decision, probably won't step on a patent, so you can take a few "
-#| "steps and probably there won't be an explosion. But the chance you will "
-#| "get all the way through the minefield and get to develop the program you "
-#| "want to develop without ever stepping on a patent gets less and less as "
-#| "the program gets bigger."
+"Asà pues, esta es una opción, la posibilidad de acudir a los tribunales
para "
+"revocar una patente. Pero debido a los gastos que supone, normalmente ni se "
+"plantea, aun cuando se puedan encontrar pruebas sólidas de la existencia de "
+"una técnica anterior que deberÃan bastar para revocar la patente. En "
+"consecuencia, una patente inválida, que teóricamente no deberÃa existir "
+"(aunque en realidad existen muchÃsimas de ellas) es un arma peligrosa. Si "
+"alguien nos ataca con una patente inválida, puede causarnos serios "
+"problemas. Podemos tratar de disuadirlo mostrándole que la técnica ya "
+"existÃa. Quizá de ese modo se asuste, o puede que piense: «Estás
fingiendo, "
+"sabemos que en realidad no puedes ir a juicio, no te lo puedes permitir, asÃ
"
+"que te demandaremos de todos modos»."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
"All of these three possibilities are things that sometimes you can manage to "
"use, but often you can't. So you have to face patent after patent after "
@@ -2756,39 +1514,20 @@
msgstr ""
"Estas tres son opciones que a veces se pueden utilizar, pero a menudo no es "
"posible. De modo que hay que hacer frente a una patente tras otra. Cada vez "
-"que descubrimos que podemos utilizar una de esas opciones, enseguida aparece "
-"una nueva patente, y luego otra, y otra. Es como cruzar un campo de minas. A "
-"cada paso que se da, a cada decisión de diseño que se toma, es probable que
"
-"no nos topemos con una patente, de modo que es posible dar unos cuantos "
-"pasos sin que se produzca una explosión. Pero la probabilidad de cruzar todo
"
-"el campo de minas y llegar a desarrollar el programa que se quiere "
-"desarrollar sin toparse con ninguna patente es tanto menor cuanto mayor es "
-"el programa."
+"que descubrimos que podemos utilizar una de estas opciones, enseguida "
+"aparece una nueva patente, y luego otra, y otra. Es como cruzar un campo de "
+"minas. A cada paso que se da, a cada decisión de diseño que se toma, es "
+"probable que no nos topemos con una patente, de modo que es posible dar unos "
+"cuantos pasos sin que se produzca una explosión. Pero la probabilidad de "
+"cruzar todo el campo de minas y llegar a desarrollar el programa que se "
+"quiere desarrollar sin toparse con ninguna patente es tanto menor cuanto "
+"mayor es el programa."
#. type: Content of: <div><h3>
msgid "Specificities of the software field"
-msgstr ""
+msgstr "CaracterÃsticas del área de la programación"
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | Now, people used to say to me, “Well, there are patents in other
-# | fields, why should software be exempt?[-.-]” Note the bizarre
-# | assumption in there that somehow we are all supposed to suffer through the
-# | patent system. It is like saying “Some people get cancer. Why
-# | should you be exempt?” {+<i>[laughs]</i> +} As I see it, each
-# | person who doesn't get cancer is good. But there is, behind that, a less
-# | biased question, which is a good question{+,+} which is: Is software
-# | different from other fields? Should patent policy be different in
-# | different fields? [-If-] {+And if+} so, why?
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Now, people used to say to me, “Well, there are patents in other "
-#| "fields, why should software be exempt?.” Note the bizarre "
-#| "assumption in there that somehow we are all supposed to suffer through "
-#| "the patent system. It is like saying “Some people get cancer. Why "
-#| "should you be exempt?” As I see it, each person who doesn't get "
-#| "cancer is good. But there is, behind that, a less biased question, which "
-#| "is a good question which is: Is software different from other fields? "
-#| "Should patent policy be different in different fields? If so, why?"
msgid ""
"Now, people used to say to me, “Well, there are patents in other "
"fields, why should software be exempt?” Note the bizarre assumption in "
@@ -2800,13 +1539,14 @@
"patent policy be different in different fields? And if so, why?"
msgstr ""
"La gente solÃa decirme: «Bueno, hay patentes en otras áreas, ¿por qué
habrÃa "
-"que excluir el software?». Observen qué suposición más grotesca hay ahÃ,
la "
-"de que todos tenemos que someternos al sistema de patentes de alguna manera. "
-"Es como decir: «Algunos contraen cáncer, ¿por qué tú deberÃas verte
libre de "
-"él?». Tal como yo lo veo, que una persona no contraiga cáncer es algo
bueno. "
-"Pero tras esto hay una pregunta menos tendenciosa, una buena pregunta: ¿Es "
-"el área del software diferente de las demás? ¿DeberÃa la polÃtica de "
-"patentes ser diferente en las diferentes áreas y, en tal caso, por qué?"
+"que excluir el software?». Observen qué suposición más grotesca hay ahÃ,
que "
+"todos tenemos que someternos al sistema de patentes de alguna manera. Es "
+"como decir: «Algunos contraen cáncer, ¿por qué tú deberÃas verte libre
de "
+"él?». <i>[risas]</i> Tal como yo lo veo, que una persona no contraiga
cáncer "
+"es algo bueno. Pero tras esto hay una pregunta menos tendenciosa, una buena "
+"pregunta: ¿Es el área del software diferente de las demás? ¿DeberÃa la "
+"polÃtica de patentes ser diferente en las diferentes áreas y, en tal caso, "
+"por qué?"
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
@@ -2818,18 +1558,6 @@
"diferente según el área de especialización."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | On {+the+} one extreme we have pharmaceuticals{+,+} where a given chemical
-# | formula would be patented, so that patent covers one and only one product.
-# | Some other product wouldn't be covered by the existing patent. If there
-# | is to be a patent for this new product, the patent holder would be whoever
-# | developed the new product.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "On one extreme we have pharmaceuticals where a given chemical formula "
-#| "would be patented, so that patent covers one and only one product. Some "
-#| "other product wouldn't be covered by the existing patent. If there is to "
-#| "be a patent for this new product, the patent holder would be whoever "
-#| "developed the new product."
msgid ""
"On the one extreme we have pharmaceuticals, where a given chemical formula "
"would be patented, so that patent covers one and only one product. Some "
@@ -2840,35 +1568,10 @@
"En uno de los extremos tenemos a las empresas farmacéuticas, donde se "
"patenta una fórmula quÃmica, de modo que esa patente cubre un solo
producto. "
"Cualquier nuevo producto no estarÃa cubierto por la patente que ya existe. "
-"En caso de que el nuevo producto se patente, el titular de la patente será "
+"En caso de que el nuevo producto se patente, el dueño de la patente será "
"quien haya elaborado el nuevo producto."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | That fits in with the naive idea of the patent system that we have,
-# | that{+,+} if you are designing a new product, you are going to get
-# | “The [-Patent.” The-] {+Patent,” the+} idea that there
-# | is one patent per product and that it covers [-the-] {+<em>the</em>+} idea
-# | of that product. In some fields [-it is-] {+that's+} closer to being
-# | true. In other fields [-it is further-] {+it's farther+} from being true.
-# | {+Software is at the opposite extreme.+} This is because software
-# | packages are [-usually-] very [-big. They-] {+big, usually, and they+}
-# | use many different ideas in a new combination. If the program is [-new
-# | and-] {+new, it's+} not just copied, then [-it is-] {+it's+} probably
-# | using a different combination of ideas combined, of course, with newly
-# | written code, because you can't just magically say the names of these
-# | ideas and have them work. You have to implement them all.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "That fits in with the naive idea of the patent system that we have, that "
-#| "if you are designing a new product, you are going to get “The "
-#| "Patent.” The idea that there is one patent per product and that it "
-#| "covers the idea of that product. In some fields it is closer to being "
-#| "true. In other fields it is further from being true. This is because "
-#| "software packages are usually very big. They use many different ideas in "
-#| "a new combination. If the program is new and not just copied, then it is "
-#| "probably using a different combination of ideas combined, of course, with "
-#| "newly written code, because you can't just magically say the names of "
-#| "these ideas and have them work. You have to implement them all."
msgid ""
"That fits in with the naive idea of the patent system that we have, that, if "
"you are designing a new product, you are going to get “The Patent,"
@@ -2885,9 +1588,10 @@
"Eso se ajusta a la idea ingenua que tenemos del sistema de patentes, la idea "
"de que si alguien diseña un producto nuevo, va a conseguir «la patente»,
la "
"idea de que hay una patente por producto y que la patente cubre la idea de "
-"ese producto. En algunas áreas esto se aproxima a la verdad, en otras está "
-"muy lejos de ser cierto. En el área de la informática los paquetes de "
-"software suelen ser muy grandes. Utilizan muchas ideas diferentes en nuevas "
+"<em>ese</em> producto. En algunas áreas esto se aproxima a la verdad, en "
+"otras está muy lejos de ser cierto. El software se encuentra en el extremo "
+"opuesto. Esto se debe a que en el área de la informática los paquetes de "
+"software suelen ser muy grandes, utilizan muchas ideas diferentes en nuevas "
"combinaciones. Si el programa es nuevo, y no simplemente copiado, "
"probablemente utilice una combinación diferente de ideas, combinadas, por "
"supuesto, con código nuevo, porque no es posible hacer que esas ideas "
@@ -2895,27 +1599,6 @@
"implementarlas todas."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | You have to implement them all in that combination. The result is [-that
-# | even-] {+that,+} when you write a program, you are using lots of different
-# | ideas, any one of them might be patented by somebody. A pair of them
-# | [-may-] {+might+} be patented as a combination by somebody. There might
-# | be several different ways of describing one idea{+,+} which might be
-# | patented by various different people. So there are possibly thousands of
-# | things, thousands of points of vulnerability in your program, which might
-# | be patented by somebody else already. This is why software patents tend
-# | to obstruct the progress of software—the work of software
-# | development.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "You have to implement them all in that combination. The result is that "
-#| "even when you write a program, you are using lots of different ideas, any "
-#| "one of them might be patented by somebody. A pair of them may be "
-#| "patented as a combination by somebody. There might be several different "
-#| "ways of describing one idea which might be patented by various different "
-#| "people. So there are possibly thousands of things, thousands of points "
-#| "of vulnerability in your program, which might be patented by somebody "
-#| "else already. This is why software patents tend to obstruct the progress "
-#| "of software—the work of software development."
msgid ""
"You have to implement them all in that combination. The result is that, "
"when you write a program, you are using lots of different ideas, any one of "
@@ -2932,29 +1615,12 @@
"diferentes, cada una de las cuales puede estar patentada por alguien. Un par "
"de ellas podrÃa estar patentada como combinación por alguien. Puede haber "
"varias maneras diferentes de describir una idea, que puede estar patentada "
-"por distinta gente. Asà que posiblemente haya miles de cosas, miles de "
+"por distintas personas. Asà que posiblemente haya miles de cosas, miles de "
"aspectos vulnerables en el programa, que podrÃan estar ya patentados por "
"alguien. Por eso las patentes de software suelen obstaculizar el progreso "
"del software, la tarea de desarrollar software."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | If it were one patent-one product, then these patents wouldn't obstruct
-# | the development of products{+,+} because if you developed a new
-# | product[-,-] it wouldn't be patented by somebody else already. But when
-# | one product corresponds to many different ideas combined, it becomes very
-# | likely {+that+} your new product is going to be patented by somebody else
-# | already. In fact, there is economic research now showing just how
-# | imposing a patent system on a field where there is incremental
-# | innovation[-,-] can retard progress.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "If it were one patent-one product, then these patents wouldn't obstruct "
-#| "the development of products because if you developed a new product, it "
-#| "wouldn't be patented by somebody else already. But when one product "
-#| "corresponds to many different ideas combined, it becomes very likely your "
-#| "new product is going to be patented by somebody else already. In fact, "
-#| "there is economic research now showing just how imposing a patent system "
-#| "on a field where there is incremental innovation, can retard progress."
msgid ""
"If it were one patent-one product, then these patents wouldn't obstruct the "
"development of products, because if you developed a new product it wouldn't "
@@ -2974,29 +1640,6 @@
"progreso."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | You see, the advocates of software patents say “[-w-]{+W+}ell yes,
-# | there may be problems{+,+} but more important than any problems, the
-# | patents must promote innovation{+,+} and that is so important it doesn't
-# | matter what problems [-you-] {+they+} cause.” Of course, they don't
-# | say that out loud because it is ridiculous{+,+} but implicitly they want
-# | you to believe that{+,+} as long as it promotes progress, that outweighs
-# | any possible cost. But actually, there is no reason to believe it does
-# | promote progress. We now have a model showing precisely how patents
-# | [-can-] {+<em>can</em>+} retard progress. The case where that model can
-# | fit describes the software field pretty [-well; Incremental-] {+well:
-# | incremental+} innovation.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "You see, the advocates of software patents say “well yes, there may "
-#| "be problems but more important than any problems, the patents must "
-#| "promote innovation and that is so important it doesn't matter what "
-#| "problems you cause.” Of course, they don't say that out loud "
-#| "because it is ridiculous but implicitly they want you to believe that as "
-#| "long as it promotes progress, that outweighs any possible cost. But "
-#| "actually, there is no reason to believe it does promote progress. We now "
-#| "have a model showing precisely how patents can retard progress. The case "
-#| "where that model can fit describes the software field pretty well; "
-#| "Incremental innovation."
msgid ""
"You see, the advocates of software patents say “Well yes, there may be "
"problems, but more important than any problems, the patents must promote "
@@ -3013,33 +1656,14 @@
"problemas, pero más importante que cualquier problema es el hecho de que las
"
"patentes deben promover la innovación, y esto es tan importante que los "
"problemas que causen son irrelevantes». Claro que esto no lo dicen en voz "
-"alta porque es ridÃculo, pero implÃcitamente quieren haceros creer que el "
+"alta porque es ridÃculo, pero implÃcitamente quieren hacernos creer que el "
"sistema de patentes promueve el progreso y que eso compensa cualquier coste "
"posible. En realidad no hay razones para creer que promueva el progreso. "
"Ahora tenemos un modelo que demuestra claramente el modo en que las patentes "
-"pueden ralentizar el progreso. El caso en el que se aplica ese modelo, la "
-"innovación incremental, describe muy bien el área del software."
+"<em>pueden</em> ralentizar el progreso. El caso en el que se aplica ese "
+"modelo, la innovación incremental, describe muy bien el área del software."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | Why is software on that extreme of the spectrum? The reason is that in
-# | software we are developing idealized mathematical objects. You can build
-# | a complicated castle and have it rest on a thin line{+,+} and it will stay
-# | up because it doesn't weigh anything. In other fields, people have to
-# | cope with the perversity of matter—of physical objects. Matter does
-# | what it is going to do. You can try to model it{+,+} and if the actual
-# | behavior doesn't fit the [-model then-] {+model,+} tough on [-you,
-# | because-] {+you. Because+} the challenge is to make physical objects that
-# | really work.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Why is software on that extreme of the spectrum? The reason is that in "
-#| "software we are developing idealized mathematical objects. You can build "
-#| "a complicated castle and have it rest on a thin line and it will stay up "
-#| "because it doesn't weigh anything. In other fields, people have to cope "
-#| "with the perversity of matter—of physical objects. Matter does "
-#| "what it is going to do. You can try to model it and if the actual "
-#| "behavior doesn't fit the model then tough on you, because the challenge "
-#| "is to make physical objects that really work."
msgid ""
"Why is software on that extreme of the spectrum? The reason is that in "
"software we are developing idealized mathematical objects. You can build a "
@@ -3061,30 +1685,6 @@
"que funcionen en la realidad."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | If I wanted to put an <code>if</code> statement [-in-] {+inside+} a
-# | <code>while</code> statement, I don't have to worry about whether the
-# | <code>if</code> statement will oscillate at a certain frequency and rub
-# | against the <code>while</code> statement and eventually they will
-# | fracture. {+<i class=\"aside\">[laughs]</i> +} I don't have to worry
-# | whether it will oscillate at a certain higher frequency and induce a
-# | signal in the value of some other variable. I don't have to worry about
-# | how much current that <code>if</code> statement will [-draw and-]
-# | {+draw,+} whether it can dissipate the heat there inside that
-# | <code>while</code> statement. Whether there will be a voltage drop across
-# | the <code>while</code> statement that will make the <code>if</code>
-# | statement not function.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "If I wanted to put an <code>if</code> statement in a <code>while</code> "
-#| "statement, I don't have to worry about whether the <code>if</code> "
-#| "statement will oscillate at a certain frequency and rub against the "
-#| "<code>while</code> statement and eventually they will fracture. I don't "
-#| "have to worry whether it will oscillate at a certain higher frequency and "
-#| "induce a signal in the value of some other variable. I don't have to "
-#| "worry about how much current that <code>if</code> statement will draw and "
-#| "whether it can dissipate the heat there inside that <code>while</code> "
-#| "statement. Whether there will be a voltage drop across the <code>while</"
-#| "code> statement that will make the <code>if</code> statement not function."
msgid ""
"If I wanted to put an <code>if</code> statement inside a <code>while</code> "
"statement, I don't have to worry about whether the <code>if</code> statement "
@@ -3100,45 +1700,16 @@
"Si quiero poner una declaración <code>if</code> dentro de una declaración "
"<code>while</code>, no tengo que preocuparme de que la declaración
<code>if</"
"code> pueda oscilar a una determinada frecuencia, friccionar con la "
-"declaración <code>while</code> y llegar a romperse. No tengo que preocuparme
"
-"de que oscile a una frecuencia demasiado alta y genere una señal que "
-"modifique el valor de alguna otra variable. No tengo que preocuparme de "
-"cuánta corriente puede requerir la declaración <code>if</code> y si podrá "
-"disipar el calor dentro de la declaración <code>while</code>. O de si habrá
"
-"una caÃda de tensión en la declaración <code>while</code> que impida que
la "
-"declaración <code>if</code> funcione."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | I don't have to worry that if [-i-] {+I+} run this program in a [-salt
-# | water environment-] {+salt-water environment,+} that the salt water
-# | [-may-] {+might+} get in between the <code>if</code> statement and the
-# | <code>while</code> statement and cause corrosion. I don't have to
-# | worry{+,+} when I refer to the value of a variable{+,+} whether I am
-# | exceeding the fan-out limit by referring to it [-20-] {+too many+} times.
-# | I don't have to worry, when I refer to the variable, how much capacitance
-# | it has and whether there has been sufficient time to charge up the value.
-# | I don't have to worry{+,+} when I write the program, about how [-I am-]
-# | {+I'm+} going to physically assemble each copy{+,+} and whether I can
-# | manage to get access to put that <code>if</code> statement inside the
-# | <code>while</code> statement. {+And+} I don't have to worry about how [-I
-# | am-] {+I'm+} going to gain access in case [-that-] {+the+} <code>if</code>
-# | statement breaks, to remove it and replace it with a new one. {+<i
-# | class=\"aside\">[laughs]</i>+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "I don't have to worry that if i run this program in a salt water "
-#| "environment that the salt water may get in between the <code>if</code> "
-#| "statement and the <code>while</code> statement and cause corrosion. I "
-#| "don't have to worry when I refer to the value of a variable whether I am "
-#| "exceeding the fan-out limit by referring to it 20 times. I don't have to "
-#| "worry, when I refer to the variable, how much capacitance it has and "
-#| "whether there has been sufficient time to charge up the value. I don't "
-#| "have to worry when I write the program, about how I am going to "
-#| "physically assemble each copy and whether I can manage to get access to "
-#| "put that <code>if</code> statement inside the <code>while</code> "
-#| "statement. I don't have to worry about how I am going to gain access in "
-#| "case that <code>if</code> statement breaks, to remove it and replace it "
-#| "with a new one."
+"declaración <code>while</code> y llegar a romperse. <i class=\"aside"
+"\">[risas]</i> No tengo que preocuparme de que oscile a una frecuencia "
+"demasiado alta y genere una señal que modifique el valor de alguna otra "
+"variable. No tengo que preocuparme de cuánta corriente puede requerir la "
+"declaración <code>if</code> y si podrá disipar el calor dentro de la "
+"declaración <code>while</code>. O de si habrá una caÃda de tensión en la "
+"declaración <code>while</code> que impida que la declaración
<code>if</code> "
+"funcione."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
"I don't have to worry that if I run this program in a salt-water "
"environment, that the salt water might get in between the <code>if</code> "
@@ -3158,42 +1729,16 @@
"salada, el agua pueda introducirse entre las declaraciones <code>if</code> y "
"<code>while</code> y provocar corrosión. Cuando hago referencia al valor de "
"una variable, no tengo que preocuparme de que se exceda ningún lÃmite si
eso "
-"sucede veinte veces. Cuando hago referencia a la variable tampoco tengo que "
-"preocuparme de su capacitancia, ni de si habrá tiempo suficiente para que se
"
-"cargue su valor. Cuando escribo el programa no tengo que preocuparme de cómo
"
-"ensamblaré fÃsicamente cada copia ni de si podré arreglármelas para
insertar "
-"la declaración <code>if</code> dentro de la declaración <code>while</code>.
"
-"No tengo que preocuparme de cómo acceder a la declaración <code>if</code>, "
-"en caso de que se rompa, para retirarla y sustituirla por una nueva."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | So many problems that we don't have to worry about in software. That
-# | makes it fundamentally easier. [-It is-] {+It's+} fundamentally easier
-# | to write a program than to design a physical object that's going to work.
-# | This [-may-] {+might+} seem strange because you have probably heard people
-# | talking about how hard software is to design{+,+} and how this is a big
-# | problem and how we are going to solve it. They are not really talking
-# | about the same question [-as-] I am. [-I am-] {+See, I'm+} comparing
-# | physical and software systems of the same complexity, the same number of
-# | parts. [-I am-] {+I'm+} saying the software system is much easier to
-# | design than the physical system. But the intelligence of people in these
-# | various fields is the same, so what do we do when we are confronted with
-# | an easy field? We just push it f[-u-]{+a+}rther! We push our abilities to
-# | the limit.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "So many problems that we don't have to worry about in software. That "
-#| "makes it fundamentally easier. It is fundamentally easier to write a "
-#| "program than to design a physical object that's going to work. This may "
-#| "seem strange because you have probably heard people talking about how "
-#| "hard software is to design and how this is a big problem and how we are "
-#| "going to solve it. They are not really talking about the same question "
-#| "as I am. I am comparing physical and software systems of the same "
-#| "complexity, the same number of parts. I am saying the software system is "
-#| "much easier to design than the physical system. But the intelligence of "
-#| "people in these various fields is the same, so what do we do when we are "
-#| "confronted with an easy field? We just push it further! We push our "
-#| "abilities to the limit."
+"sucede demasiadas veces. Cuando hago referencia a la variable tampoco tengo "
+"que preocuparme de su capacitancia, ni de si habrá tiempo suficiente para "
+"que se cargue su valor. Cuando escribo el programa no tengo que preocuparme "
+"de cómo ensamblaré fÃsicamente cada copia ni de si podré arreglármelas
para "
+"insertar la declaración <code>if</code> dentro de la declaración "
+"<code>while</code>. No tengo que preocuparme de cómo acceder a la "
+"declaración <code>if</code>, en caso de que se rompa, para retirarla y "
+"sustituirla por una nueva.<i class=\"aside\">[risas]</i>"
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
"So many problems that we don't have to worry about in software. That makes "
"it fundamentally easier. It's fundamentally easier to write a program than "
@@ -3221,30 +1766,6 @@
"Llevamos nuestras capacidades al lÃmite."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | If systems of the same size are easy, let's make systems which are ten
-# | times as big, then it will be hard! {+<i
-# | class=\"aside\">[laughs]</i> +} That's what we do! We make software
-# | systems [-which are-] far bigger in terms of number of parts than physical
-# | systems. A physical system whose design has a million different pieces in
-# | it is a mega project. A computer program whose design has a million
-# | pieces in it, [-is-] {+that's+} maybe 300,000 lines, a few people will
-# | write that in a couple of years. [-That is-] {+That's+} not [-a-]
-# | particularly {+a+} giant program. GNU Emacs now has several million
-# | pieces in its design I [-think. It-] {+think, because it+} has a million
-# | lines of code. This [-is-] {+was+} a project done with essentially no
-# | funding whatsoever. Mostly done by people in their spare time.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "If systems of the same size are easy, let's make systems which are ten "
-#| "times as big, then it will be hard! That's what we do! We make software "
-#| "systems which are far bigger in terms of number of parts than physical "
-#| "systems. A physical system whose design has a million different pieces "
-#| "in it is a mega project. A computer program whose design has a million "
-#| "pieces in it, is maybe 300,000 lines, a few people will write that in a "
-#| "couple of years. That is not a particularly giant program. GNU Emacs "
-#| "now has several million pieces in its design I think. It has a million "
-#| "lines of code. This is a project done with essentially no funding "
-#| "whatsoever. Mostly done by people in their spare time."
msgid ""
"If systems of the same size are easy, let's make systems which are ten times "
"as big, then it will be hard! <i class=\"aside\">[laughs]</i> That's "
@@ -3258,39 +1779,18 @@
"funding whatsoever. Mostly done by people in their spare time."
msgstr ""
"Si los sistemas del mismo tamaño son sencillos, hagamos sistemas diez veces "
-"más grandes, ¡asà será complicado! Y es lo que hacemos. Hacemos sistemas
de "
-"software que son mucho mayores que los sistemas fÃsicos con respecto al "
-"número de partes que los componen. Un sistema fÃsico cuyo diseño contiene
un "
-"millón de piezas diferentes es un megaproyecto. Un programa informático
cuyo "
-"diseño contiene un millón de piezas puede tener unas 300.000 lÃneas, unas "
-"pocas personas pueden escribirlo en un par de años. No serÃa un programa "
-"gigantesco. GNU Emacs contiene ya varios millones de piezas, creo. Tiene un "
-"millón de lÃneas de código. Es un proyecto realizado prácticamente sin "
-"financiación, realizado en su mayor parte por gente en su tiempo libre."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | There is another big saving. If you [-have-] designed a physical product,
-# | the next thing you have to do is design the factory to make it. To build
-# | this factory may cost millions or tens of millions{+,+} whereas to make
-# | copies of the program, you just have to type [-<kbd>copy</kbd>.-]
-# | {+<code>copy</code>.+} The same [-copy-] {+<code>copy</code>+} command
-# | will copy any program. You want copies on [-CD then-] {+CD,+} fine. You
-# | burn a master CD and send it off to a CD plant. They will use the same
-# | equipment [-which-] {+that+} will copy any contents on a CD. You don't
-# | have to build a factory to [-make-] {+<em>make</em>+} this product. There
-# | is tremendous simplification and tremendous reduction in costs of
-# | designing things.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "There is another big saving. If you have designed a physical product, "
-#| "the next thing you have to do is design the factory to make it. To build "
-#| "this factory may cost millions or tens of millions whereas to make copies "
-#| "of the program, you just have to type <kbd>copy</kbd>. The same copy "
-#| "command will copy any program. You want copies on CD then fine. You "
-#| "burn a master CD and send it off to a CD plant. They will use the same "
-#| "equipment which will copy any contents on a CD. You don't have to build "
-#| "a factory to make this product. There is tremendous simplification and "
-#| "tremendous reduction in costs of designing things."
+"más grandes, ¡asà será complicado! <i class=\"aside\">[risas]</i> Y
es "
+"lo que hacemos. Hacemos sistemas de software que son mucho mayores que los "
+"sistemas fÃsicos con respecto al número de partes que los componen. Un "
+"sistema fÃsico cuyo diseño contiene un millón de piezas diferentes es un "
+"megaproyecto. Un programa informático cuyo diseño contiene un millón de "
+"piezas puede tener unas 300.000 lÃneas, unas pocas personas pueden "
+"escribirlo en un par de años. No serÃa un programa gigantesco. GNU Emacs "
+"contiene ya varios millones de piezas, creo, porque tiene un millón de "
+"lÃneas de código. Fue un proyecto realizado prácticamente sin
financiación, "
+"realizado en su mayor parte por gente en su tiempo libre."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
"There is another big saving. If you designed a physical product, the next "
"thing you have to do is design the factory to make it. To build this "
@@ -3305,43 +1805,14 @@
"Hay otra gran ventaja. Si usted ha diseñado un producto fÃsico, el
siguiente "
"paso será diseñar la fábrica para construirlo. Edificar esa fábrica puede
"
"costar millones o decenas de millones, mientras que para hacer copias del "
-"programa no hay más que escribir <kbd>copy</kbd>. La misma orden de copiar "
-"copiará cualquier programa. ¿Queremos copias en CD? De acuerdo, entonces "
-"grabamos un CD maestro y lo enviamos a una planta de CD. Utilizarán el mismo
"
-"equipamiento para copiar cualquier contenido en un CD, no tenemos que "
-"levantar una fábrica para hacer este producto. Hay una tremenda "
-"simplificación y una tremenda reducción de costes en el diseño."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | The result is, say for an automobile company, [-who will-] {+if they are
-# | going to+} spend 50 million dollars to build a factory, to build a new
-# | model of auto, they can hire some lawyers to cope with {+some+} patent
-# | license negotiations. They [-can-] {+could+} even cope with a law[-
-# | -]suit if they wanted to. [-To design-] {+Designing+} a program of the
-# | same complexity [-may-] {+might+} cost 50 thousand {+dollars,+} or 100
-# | thousand dollars. By comparison, the cost of dealing with the patent
-# | system is crushing. [-Or actually-] {+Actually+} designing a program
-# | with the same complexity as the mechanical design of an [-auto is-]
-# | {+auto, that's+} probably a [-month's-] {+month+} work. How many parts
-# | does an auto have… that is if it is an auto [-which-] {+that+}
-# | doesn't have computers in it[-.-]{+?+}[<a href=\"#f1\">1</a>] There are
-# | not that many [-parts. That-] {+parts, you see. Which+} is not to say
-# | designing a good one is easy{+,+} but just that there are not that many
-# | different things in it.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "The result is, say for an automobile company, who will spend 50 million "
-#| "dollars to build a factory, to build a new model of auto, they can hire "
-#| "some lawyers to cope with patent license negotiations. They can even "
-#| "cope with a law suit if they wanted to. To design a program of the same "
-#| "complexity may cost 50 thousand or 100 thousand dollars. By comparison, "
-#| "the cost of dealing with the patent system is crushing. Or actually "
-#| "designing a program with the same complexity as the mechanical design of "
-#| "an auto is probably a month's work. How many parts does an auto "
-#| "have… that is if it is an auto which doesn't have computers in it."
-#| "[<a href=\"#f1\">1</a>] There are not that many parts. That is not to "
-#| "say designing a good one is easy but just that there are not that many "
-#| "different things in it."
+"programa no hay más que escribir <code>copy</code>. La misma orden "
+"<code>copy</code> copiará cualquier programa. ¿Queremos copias en CD? De "
+"acuerdo, entonces grabamos un CD maestro y lo enviamos a una planta de CD. "
+"Utilizarán el mismo equipamiento para copiar cualquier contenido en un CD, "
+"no tenemos que levantar una fábrica para <em>hacer</em> este producto. Hay "
+"una tremenda simplificación y una tremenda reducción de costes en el
diseño."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
"The result is, say for an automobile company, if they are going to spend 50 "
"million dollars to build a factory, to build a new model of auto, they can "
@@ -3361,33 +1832,15 @@
"que puede contratar a unos cuantos abogados para que se ocupen de las "
"negociaciones relativas a las patentes. PodrÃan incluso afrontar un proceso "
"judicial si quisieran. Diseñar un programa de la misma complejidad puede "
-"costar 50.000 o 100.00 dólares. En comparación, el coste de lidiar con el "
-"sistema de patentes es devastador. De hecho, concebir un programa de la "
-"misma complejidad que el diseño mecánico de un coche llevarÃa
probablemente "
-"un mes de trabajo. ¿Cuántas partes tiene un coche (uno que no contenga "
-"ningún ordenador)?[<a href=\"#f1\">1</a>] No son muchas. Esto no quiere "
-"decir que diseñar un buen coche sea sencillo, sino solo que no contiene "
-"muchas piezas diferentes."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | The result is{+,+} software really is different from other fields because
-# | we are working with mathematical [-stuff designing-] {+stuff. Designing+}
-# | something is far, far [-easier and-] {+easier. And+} the result is
-# | [-that-] we regularly make systems [-which-] {+that+} are much, much
-# | larger{+,+} and do so with just a few people. The result is that the
-# | patent system then{+,+} instead of being close to [-one-] {+“one+}
-# | product, one [-patent,-] {+patent,”+} we are in a system where one
-# | product involves many, many ideas [-which-] {+that+} could be patented
-# | already.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "The result is software really is different from other fields because we "
-#| "are working with mathematical stuff designing something is far, far "
-#| "easier and the result is that we regularly make systems which are much, "
-#| "much larger and do so with just a few people. The result is that the "
-#| "patent system then instead of being close to one product, one patent, we "
-#| "are in a system where one product involves many, many ideas which could "
-#| "be patented already."
+"costar 50.000 o 100.000 dólares. En comparación, el coste de lidiar con el "
+"sistema de patentes es devastador. Concebir un programa de la misma "
+"complejidad que el diseño mecánico de un coche llevarÃa probablemente un
mes "
+"de trabajo. ¿Cuántas partes tiene un coche... uno que no contenga ningún "
+"ordenador?[<a href=\"#f1\">1</a>] No son muchas. Esto no quiere decir que "
+"diseñar un buen coche sea sencillo, sino solo que no contiene muchas piezas "
+"diferentes."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
"The result is, software really is different from other fields because we are "
"working with mathematical stuff. Designing something is far, far easier. And "
@@ -3398,35 +1851,14 @@
"already."
msgstr ""
"La programación es muy diferente de otros campos porque trabajamos con "
-"objetos matemáticos, cuyo diseño es muchÃsimo más sencillo, y debido a
ello "
+"objetos matemáticos. El diseño es muchÃsimo más sencillo, y debido a ello
"
"habitualmente hacemos sistemas que son muchÃsimo más grandes, y eso con tan
"
-"solo un puñado de personas. El resultado es que entonces el sistema de "
-"patentes con el que nos encontramos, en lugar de ser del tipo «un producto, "
-"una patente», es un sistema en el que un producto comprende multitud de "
-"ideas que podrÃan estar ya patentadas."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | The best way to explain it by analogy is with symphonies. A symphony is
-# | also long and has many notes in it, and probably uses many musical ideas.
-# | Imagine if the governments of Europe in the 1700's had decided they wanted
-# | to promote the progress of symphonic music by establishing a European
-# | Musical Patent Office that would give patents for any kind of musical
-# | [-ideas which-] {+idea that+} you could state in words. Then imagine it
-# | is around 1800 and you are Beethoven and you want to write a symphony. You
-# | [-will-] {+are going to+} find that getting your symphony {+to be legal,+}
-# | so that it doesn't infringe any patents{+,+} is going to be harder than
-# | writing a good symphony.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "The best way to explain it by analogy is with symphonies. A symphony is "
-#| "also long and has many notes in it, and probably uses many musical "
-#| "ideas. Imagine if the governments of Europe in the 1700's had decided "
-#| "they wanted to promote the progress of symphonic music by establishing a "
-#| "European Musical Patent Office that would give patents for any kind of "
-#| "musical ideas which you could state in words. Then imagine it is around "
-#| "1800 and you are Beethoven and you want to write a symphony. You will "
-#| "find that getting your symphony so that it doesn't infringe any patents "
-#| "is going to be harder than writing a good symphony."
+"solo un puñado de personas. Entonces el resultado es que el sistema de "
+"patentes, en lugar de ser del tipo «un producto, una patente», es un
sistema "
+"en el que un producto comprende multitud de ideas que podrÃan estar ya "
+"patentadas."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
"The best way to explain it by analogy is with symphonies. A symphony is "
"also long and has many notes in it, and probably uses many musical ideas. "
@@ -3445,34 +1877,11 @@
"estableciendo una Oficina Europea de Patentes Musicales que concediera "
"patentes para todo tipo de ideas musicales que pudieran expresarse en "
"palabras. Imaginen ahora que se encuentran en 1800, ustedes son Beethoven y "
-"quieren componer una sinfonÃa. DescubrirÃan que conseguir que su sinfonÃa
no "
+"quieren componer una sinfonÃa. DescubrirÃan que lograr que su sinfonÃa no "
"infringiera ninguna patente serÃa más complicado que escribir una buena "
"sinfonÃa."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | When you complain about this, the patent holders would say “Ah
-# | Beethoven, you are just bitching because you have no ideas of your own.
-# | All you want to do is rip off our inventions.” Beethoven, as it
-# | happens, had a lot of new musical ideas{+,+} but he had to use a lot of
-# | existing musical ideas in order to make recognizable [-music. In-]
-# | {+music, in+} order to make music that listeners could possibly like, that
-# | they could recognize as music. Nobody is so brilliant that he can
-# | re-invent music and make something that people [-would-] want to listen
-# | to. <a href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierre_Boulez\">Pierre
-# | Boulez</a> said he would try to do that, [-but-] {+and…+} who
-# | listens to Pierre Boulez? {+<i class=\"aside\">[laughs]</i>+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "When you complain about this, the patent holders would say “Ah "
-#| "Beethoven, you are just bitching because you have no ideas of your own. "
-#| "All you want to do is rip off our inventions.” Beethoven, as it "
-#| "happens, had a lot of new musical ideas but he had to use a lot of "
-#| "existing musical ideas in order to make recognizable music. In order to "
-#| "make music that listeners could possibly like, that they could recognize "
-#| "as music. Nobody is so brilliant that he can re-invent music and make "
-#| "something that people would want to listen to. <a href=\"https://en."
-#| "wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierre_Boulez\">Pierre Boulez</a> said he would try to "
-#| "do that, but who listens to Pierre Boulez?"
msgid ""
"When you complain about this, the patent holders would say “Ah "
"Beethoven, you are just bitching because you have no ideas of your own. All "
@@ -3485,36 +1894,18 @@
"\">Pierre Boulez</a> said he would try to do that, and… who listens "
"to Pierre Boulez? <i class=\"aside\">[laughs]</i>"
msgstr ""
-"Si protestaran por ello, los titulares de las patentes dirÃan, «Ah, "
-"Beethoven, reniegas solo porque no tienes ideas propias. Lo único que "
-"pretendes es apropiarte de nuestras invenciones». Lo cierto es que Beethoven
"
-"concibió multitud de ideas musicales nuevas, pero tenÃa que utilizar muchas
"
-"ideas musicales ya existentes a fin de componer música reconocible, a fin de
"
+"Si protestaran por ello, los dueños de las patentes dirÃan, «Ah,
Beethoven, "
+"reniegas solo porque no tienes ideas propias. Lo único que pretendes es "
+"apropiarte de nuestras invenciones». Lo cierto es que Beethoven concibió "
+"multitud de ideas musicales nuevas, pero tuvo que utilizar muchas ideas "
+"musicales ya existentes a fin de componer música reconocible, a fin de "
"componer música que pudiera gustar a los oyentes, música que estos pudieran
"
"reconocer como tal. Nadie es tan brillante como para reinventar la música y "
"componer algo que la gente quiera escuchar. <a href=\"https://en.wikipedia."
"org/wiki/Pierre_Boulez\">Pierre Boulez</a> dijo que intentarÃa hacerlo, "
-"¿pero quién escucha a Pierre Boulez?"
+"¿pero quién escucha a Pierre Boulez? <i class=\"aside\">[risas]</i>"
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | Nobody is so brilliant he can re-invent all [-of-] computer science,
-# | completely new. If he did, [-he would-] {+he'd+} make something that the
-# | users would find so strange that they wouldn't want to use it. If you
-# | look at a word processor today, [-you would-] {+you'll+} find, I think,
-# | hundreds of different features. If you develop a nice new innovative word
-# | processor, that means there are some new ideas in it, but there must be
-# | hundreds of old ideas in it. If you are not allowed to use them, you
-# | cannot make an innovative word processor.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Nobody is so brilliant he can re-invent all of computer science, "
-#| "completely new. If he did, he would make something that the users would "
-#| "find so strange that they wouldn't want to use it. If you look at a word "
-#| "processor today, you would find, I think, hundreds of different "
-#| "features. If you develop a nice new innovative word processor, that "
-#| "means there are some new ideas in it, but there must be hundreds of old "
-#| "ideas in it. If you are not allowed to use them, you cannot make an "
-#| "innovative word processor."
msgid ""
"Nobody is so brilliant he can re-invent all computer science, completely "
"new. If he did, he'd make something that the users would find so strange "
@@ -3526,34 +1917,14 @@
msgstr ""
"Nadie es tan brillante como para reinventar la informática desde cero. Si lo
"
"hiciera, lo que escribiera les resultarÃa a los usuarios tan extraño que no
"
-"querrÃan utilizarlo. Si miran hoy un procesador de textos encontrarán,
creo, "
-"cientos de funcionalidades diferentes. Si se desarrolla un nuevo procesador "
-"de textos de calidad e innovador, eso quiere decir que contendrá algunas "
-"ideas nuevas, pero ha de contener también cientos de viejas ideas. Si no se "
-"nos permite utilizarlas, no podremos hacer un procesador de textos innovador."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | Because the work of software development is so big, the result is that we
-# | don't need any artificial scheme to incentivize new ideas. You just have
-# | people writing software and they will have some new ideas. If you want to
-# | write a [-program and-] {+program,+} you want to make it [-good, so some-]
-# | {+good. Some+} ideas will come to you{+,+} and some {+of them+} you will
-# | see a way to use. What used to [-happen, because-]
-# | {+happen—because+} I was in the software field before there were
-# | software [-patents, was-] {+patents—was+} most of the developers
-# | would publish any new ideas that they thought were noteworthy, that they
-# | thought [-that-] they might get any credit or respect for.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Because the work of software development is so big, the result is that we "
-#| "don't need any artificial scheme to incentivize new ideas. You just have "
-#| "people writing software and they will have some new ideas. If you want "
-#| "to write a program and you want to make it good, so some ideas will come "
-#| "to you and some you will see a way to use. What used to happen, because "
-#| "I was in the software field before there were software patents, was most "
-#| "of the developers would publish any new ideas that they thought were "
-#| "noteworthy, that they thought that they might get any credit or respect "
-#| "for."
+"querrÃan utilizarlo. Si miran hoy un procesador de textos creo que "
+"encontrarán cientos de funcionalidades diferentes. Si se desarrolla un nuevo
"
+"procesador de textos de calidad e innovador, eso quiere decir que contendrá "
+"algunas ideas nuevas, pero ha de contener también cientos de viejas ideas. "
+"Si no se nos permite utilizarlas, no podremos hacer un procesador de textos "
+"innovador."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
"Because the work of software development is so big, the result is that we "
"don't need any artificial scheme to incentivize new ideas. You just have "
@@ -3567,7 +1938,7 @@
"Dado que la tarea de desarrollar software es tan grande, no necesitamos "
"ningún plan artificial para incentivar ideas nuevas. Solo se necesita gente "
"que escriba software, y ellos concebirán algunas ideas nuevas. Si queremos "
-"escribir un programa y hacer que sea bueno, tendremos algunas ideas y "
+"escribir un programa, queremos que sea bueno. Tendremos algunas ideas y "
"encontraremos la manera de utilizar algunas de ellas. Lo que solÃa suceder, "
"puesto que yo trabajé en el campo del software antes de que hubiera patentes
"
"de software, es que la mayorÃa de los desarrolladores publicaban cualquier "
@@ -3575,34 +1946,6 @@
"reconocimiento o consideración."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | The ideas that were too small or not impressive enough, they would not
-# | publish because that would be silly. Now the patent system is supposed to
-# | encourage disclosure of ideas. In fact, in the old days, nobody kept the
-# | ideas secret. They kept the code secret, it's true. The code, after all,
-# | represented the bulk of the work. They would {+typically+} keep the code
-# | secret and publish the [-ideas so that way-] {+ideas. That way,+} the
-# | employees [-w-]{+c+}ould get some credit and feel [-good.-] {+good; you
-# | know, they were allowed to publish papers.+} After software patents, they
-# | still kept the code secret and they patented the [-ideas, so-] {+ideas.
-# | So,+} in fact, disclosure has not been encouraged in any meaningful sense.
-# | The same things are kept secret now as [-what-] were kept secret before,
-# | but the ideas{+,+} which used to be published so [-that-] we could use
-# | [-them are-] {+them,+} now {+are+} likely to be patented and off-limits
-# | for 20 years.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "The ideas that were too small or not impressive enough, they would not "
-#| "publish because that would be silly. Now the patent system is supposed "
-#| "to encourage disclosure of ideas. In fact, in the old days, nobody kept "
-#| "the ideas secret. They kept the code secret, it's true. The code, after "
-#| "all, represented the bulk of the work. They would keep the code secret "
-#| "and publish the ideas so that way the employees would get some credit and "
-#| "feel good. After software patents, they still kept the code secret and "
-#| "they patented the ideas, so in fact, disclosure has not been encouraged "
-#| "in any meaningful sense. The same things are kept secret now as what "
-#| "were kept secret before, but the ideas which used to be published so that "
-#| "we could use them are now likely to be patented and off-limits for 20 "
-#| "years."
msgid ""
"The ideas that were too small or not impressive enough, they would not "
"publish because that would be silly. Now the patent system is supposed to "
@@ -3621,9 +1964,10 @@
"hacerlo. Ahora se supone que el sistema de patentes estimula la divulgación "
"de ideas. De hecho en los viejos tiempos nadie mantenÃa las ideas en "
"secreto. MantenÃan en secreto el código, es cierto. Al fin y al cabo, el "
-"código representaba el grueso del trabajo. MantenÃan en secreto el código
y "
-"publicaban las ideas, de manera que los empleados obtenÃan reconocimiento y "
-"se sentÃan bien. Tras la aparición de las patentes de software, seguÃan "
+"código representaba el grueso del trabajo. Generalmente mantenÃan en
secreto "
+"el código y publicaban las ideas. De manera que los empleados obtenÃan "
+"reconocimiento y se sentÃan bien, porque se sabe, se les permitÃa publicar "
+"artÃculos. Tras la aparición de las patentes de software, seguÃan "
"manteniendo el código en secreto y patentaban las ideas, asà que lo cierto "
"es que no se ha fomentado la divulgación de ninguna manera. Las mismas cosas
"
"que se mantenÃan en secreto antes se siguen manteniendo en secreto ahora, "
@@ -3633,20 +1977,10 @@
#. type: Content of: <div><h3>
msgid "Addressing the problem of software patents in public policies"
msgstr ""
+"Cómo abordar el problema de las patentes de software en las polÃticas "
+"públicas"
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | What can a country do to change this? How should we change the policy to
-# | solve this problem? There are two places you can attack it. One is the
-# | place where patents are being applied for and issued, in the patent
-# | office. [-The-] {+And the+} other is when patents are being
-# | applied—that is, the question of what does a patent cover.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "What can a country do to change this? How should we change the policy to "
-#| "solve this problem? There are two places you can attack it. One is the "
-#| "place where patents are being applied for and issued, in the patent "
-#| "office. The other is when patents are being applied—that is, the "
-#| "question of what does a patent cover."
msgid ""
"What can a country do to change this? How should we change the policy to "
"solve this problem? There are two places you can attack it. One is the "
@@ -3661,32 +1995,6 @@
"cuestión de qué es lo que cubre una patente."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | Changing the criteria for issuing patents{+,+} or simply keeping a good
-# | criteria for issuing patents, can work in a country which has not
-# | authorized software patents before[-,-]{+;+} for instance, for the most
-# | part, in Europe. Simply to clearly re-enforce the European Patent
-# | Office's rules which say that software is not patentable. This is a good
-# | solution for Europe. Europe is now considering a directive on software
-# | patents. The directive I suppose may be broader than that but one of its
-# | important implications is for software patents. Simply by modifying this
-# | to say software ideas cannot be patented will keep the problem out of
-# | Europe for the most part, except for some countries that may have admitted
-# | the problem on their [-own. Unfortunately-] {+own—unfortunately,+}
-# | one of them being the [-UK. Unfortunately-] {+UK, unfortunately+} for you.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Changing the criteria for issuing patents or simply keeping a good "
-#| "criteria for issuing patents, can work in a country which has not "
-#| "authorized software patents before, for instance, for the most part, in "
-#| "Europe. Simply to clearly re-enforce the European Patent Office's rules "
-#| "which say that software is not patentable. This is a good solution for "
-#| "Europe. Europe is now considering a directive on software patents. The "
-#| "directive I suppose may be broader than that but one of its important "
-#| "implications is for software patents. Simply by modifying this to say "
-#| "software ideas cannot be patented will keep the problem out of Europe for "
-#| "the most part, except for some countries that may have admitted the "
-#| "problem on their own. Unfortunately one of them being the UK. "
-#| "Unfortunately for you."
msgid ""
"Changing the criteria for issuing patents, or simply keeping a good criteria "
"for issuing patents, can work in a country which has not authorized software "
@@ -3714,23 +2022,6 @@
"uno de ellos es el Reino Unido. Por desgracia para ustedes."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | That approach won't work in the US. The reason is that the US already has
-# | large numbers of software patents{+,+} and any change in the criteria for
-# | issuing patents won't get rid of the existing [-ones.[<a
-# | href=\"#f2\">2</a>] In-] {+ones. However in+} fact, these patents are not
-# | officially labeled as software patents. I say software patents{+,+} but
-# | what do I really mean? [-Patents which-] {+I mean patents that+} might
-# | potentially apply to [-software. Patents which-] {+software, that+} might
-# | potentially get you sued for writing software.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "That approach won't work in the US. The reason is that the US already "
-#| "has large numbers of software patents and any change in the criteria for "
-#| "issuing patents won't get rid of the existing ones.[<a href=\"#f2\">2</"
-#| "a>] In fact, these patents are not officially labeled as software "
-#| "patents. I say software patents but what do I really mean? Patents which "
-#| "might potentially apply to software. Patents which might potentially get "
-#| "you sued for writing software."
msgid ""
"That approach won't work in the US. The reason is that the US already has "
"large numbers of software patents, and any change in the criteria for "
@@ -3741,32 +2032,13 @@
msgstr ""
"Esta estrategia no sirve en EE. UU. La razón es que EE. UU. tiene "
"ya gran cantidad de patentes de software y ningún cambio en los criterios "
-"para emitir patentes nos librarÃa de las ya existentes.[<a href=\"#f2\">2</"
-"a>] En realidad estas patentes no están oficialmente identificadas como "
-"patentes de software. Yo hablo de patentes de software, pero ¿qué quiero "
-"decir en realidad? Me refiero a patentes que podrÃan aplicarse al software, "
-"patentes que podrÃan hacer que nos demandaran por escribir software."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | The patent office doesn't divide patents into software patents and other
-# | patents. So, in fact, any patent might conceivably get you sued for
-# | writing software if it could apply to some software. So{+,+} in the [-US
-# | the-] {+US, a+} solution would have to be done through changing the
-# | applicability, the scope of patents{+,+} saying that a pure software
-# | implementation{+,+} running on general purpose computer hardware which
-# | does not in itself infringe the patent, is not covered by any patent and
-# | you [-cannot get-] {+can't be+} sued for it. [-That is-] {+That's+} the
-# | other kind of solution.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "The patent office doesn't divide patents into software patents and other "
-#| "patents. So, in fact, any patent might conceivably get you sued for "
-#| "writing software if it could apply to some software. So in the US the "
-#| "solution would have to be done through changing the applicability, the "
-#| "scope of patents saying that a pure software implementation running on "
-#| "general purpose computer hardware which does not in itself infringe the "
-#| "patent, is not covered by any patent and you cannot get sued for it. "
-#| "That is the other kind of solution."
+"para emitir patentes nos librarÃa de las ya existentes. En realidad estas "
+"patentes no están oficialmente identificadas como patentes de software. Yo "
+"hablo de patentes de software, pero ¿qué quiero decir en realidad? Me "
+"refiero a patentes que podrÃan aplicarse al software, patentes que podrÃan "
+"hacer que nos demandaran por escribir software."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
"The patent office doesn't divide patents into software patents and other "
"patents. So, in fact, any patent might conceivably get you sued for writing "
@@ -3779,21 +2051,14 @@
msgstr ""
"La oficina de patentes no distingue entre patentes de software y otro tipo "
"de patentes. De manera que, de hecho, cabe la posibilidad de que cualquier "
-"patente podrÃa hacer que nos demandaran por escribir software. Asà que, en "
-"EE. UU., la solución consistirÃa en modificar la aplicabilidad, el "
-"alcance de las patentes, diciendo que una simple implementación de software "
-"que se ejecute en un ordenador genérico y que en sà misma no infrinja la "
-"patente no está cubierta por ninguna patente y no puede ser objeto de "
-"denuncia. Este es otro tipo de solución."
+"patente podrÃa hacer que nos demandaran por escribir software si se pudiera "
+"aplicar al mismo. Asà que, en EE. UU., la solución consistirÃa en "
+"modificar la aplicabilidad, el alcance de las patentes, diciendo que una "
+"simple implementación de software que se ejecuta en un ordenador genérico y
"
+"que en sà misma no infringe la patente no está cubierta por ninguna patente
"
+"y no puede ser objeto de denuncia. Este es el otro tipo de solución."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | [-The-]{+But the+} first kind of solution, the solution that operates on
-# | what [-types-] {+kinds+} of patents can be valid is a good solution for
-# | Europe to use.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "The first kind of solution, the solution that operates on what types of "
-#| "patents can be valid is a good solution for Europe to use."
msgid ""
"But the first kind of solution, the solution that operates on what kinds of "
"patents can be valid is a good solution for Europe to use."
@@ -3802,21 +2067,6 @@
"ser válidas, es una buena solución para utilizar en Europa."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | When the US started having software patents, there was no political
-# | debate. In fact, nobody noticed. The software field, for the most part,
-# | didn't even notice. There was a [-supreme court-] {+Supreme Court+}
-# | decision in 1981 which considered a patent on a process for curing rubber.
-# | The ruling was that the fact that the apparatus included a computer and a
-# | program as part of the process to cure the rubber did not make it
-# | un[---]patentable.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "When the US started having software patents, there was no political "
-#| "debate. In fact, nobody noticed. The software field, for the most part, "
-#| "didn't even notice. There was a supreme court decision in 1981 which "
-#| "considered a patent on a process for curing rubber. The ruling was that "
-#| "the fact that the apparatus included a computer and a program as part of "
-#| "the process to cure the rubber did not make it un-patentable."
msgid ""
"When the US started having software patents, there was no political debate. "
"In fact, nobody noticed. The software field, for the most part, didn't even "
@@ -3826,34 +2076,14 @@
"cure the rubber did not make it unpatentable."
msgstr ""
"Cuando en EE. UU. se empezaron a introducir las patentes de software, "
-"no hubo debate. De hecho, nadie lo advirtió. El mundo del software, en su "
-"mayor parte, ni siquiera se dio cuenta. En 1981 hubo una decisión del "
+"no hubo debate polÃtico. De hecho, nadie lo advirtió. El mundo del
software, "
+"en su mayor parte, ni siquiera se dio cuenta. En 1981 hubo una decisión del "
"Tribunal Supremo relativa a una patente sobre un proceso de curado del "
"caucho. La sentencia decÃa que el hecho de que el aparato incluyera un "
"ordenador y un programa como parte del proceso para curar el caucho no lo "
"inhabilitaba para ser patentado."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | The appeals court the next year{+,+} which considers all patent cases,
-# | reversed the qualifiers. They said the fact that there is a computer and
-# | a program in this makes it patentable. The fact that there is a computer
-# | and program in anything makes it patentable. This is why the US started
-# | having business procedure patents. [-This is because-] {+Because+} the
-# | business procedures were carried out on a computer and that made them
-# | patentable. So this ruling was made{+,+} and I think the natural order
-# | recalculation patent was one of the first or might have been even the
-# | first. [-Throughout the 80's we didn't know about this.-]
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "The appeals court the next year which considers all patent cases, "
-#| "reversed the qualifiers. They said the fact that there is a computer and "
-#| "a program in this makes it patentable. The fact that there is a computer "
-#| "and program in anything makes it patentable. This is why the US started "
-#| "having business procedure patents. This is because the business "
-#| "procedures were carried out on a computer and that made them patentable. "
-#| "So this ruling was made and I think the natural order recalculation "
-#| "patent was one of the first or might have been even the first. "
-#| "Throughout the 80's we didn't know about this."
msgid ""
"The appeals court the next year, which considers all patent cases, reversed "
"the qualifiers. They said the fact that there is a computer and a program "
@@ -3865,43 +2095,16 @@
"have been even the first."
msgstr ""
"Al año siguiente, un tribunal de apelación especializado en los casos de "
-"patentes invirtió los términos. Dijeron que el hecho de que algo contenga
un "
-"ordenador y un programa lo hace patentable. Asà es cómo EE. UU.
comenzó "
-"a introducir patentes sobre procedimientos industriales. Esto se debe a que "
-"los procedimientos industriales se realizan en un ordenador, y eso los hacÃa
"
-"patentables. El caso es que se tomó esa decisión, y creo que la patente "
-"sobre el cálculo en orden natural fue una de las primeras, o incluso puede "
-"que fuera la primera. En los años ochenta no lo sabÃamos."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | {+But throughout the 80's we mostly didn't know about this.+} It was
-# | around 1990 that programmers in the US started to become aware that they
-# | were faced with a danger from software patents. [-So i-] {+So, I+} saw
-# | how the field worked before {+then+} and how [-the field-] {+it+} worked
-# | after. I saw no particular speed up in progress after 1990. There was no
-# | political debate in the US, but in Europe there has been a big political
-# | debate. Several years ago there was a push to amend the Munich treaty
-# | that established the <a href=\"https://www.epo.org/\"> European Patent
-# | Office</a>. It has a <a
-# |
href=\"https://www.epo.org/law-practice/legal-texts/html/epc/1973/e/ar52.html\">
-# | clause saying that software is not patentable</a>. The push was to amend
-# | that to start allowing software patents. But the community took notice of
-# | this. It was actually free software developers and free software users
-# | who took the lead.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "It was around 1990 that programmers in the US started to become aware "
-#| "that they were faced with a danger from software patents. So i saw how "
-#| "the field worked before and how the field worked after. I saw no "
-#| "particular speed up in progress after 1990. There was no political "
-#| "debate in the US, but in Europe there has been a big political debate. "
-#| "Several years ago there was a push to amend the Munich treaty that "
-#| "established the <a href=\"https://www.epo.org/\"> European Patent Office</"
-#| "a>. It has a <a href=\"https://www.epo.org/law-practice/legal-texts/html/"
-#| "epc/1973/e/ar52.html\"> clause saying that software is not patentable</"
-#| "a>. The push was to amend that to start allowing software patents. But "
-#| "the community took notice of this. It was actually free software "
-#| "developers and free software users who took the lead."
+"patentes invirtió los términos. Dijeron que el hecho de que contenga un "
+"ordenador y un programa lo hace patentable. Cualquier cosa contenga un "
+"ordenador y un programa es patentable. Asà es cómo EE. UU. comenzó a "
+"introducir patentes sobre procedimientos industriales, porque los "
+"procedimientos industriales se realizan en un ordenador, y eso los hacÃa "
+"patentables. Fue asà que se tomó esa decisión, y creo que la patente sobre
"
+"el cálculo en orden natural fue una de las primeras, o incluso puede que "
+"fuera la primera."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
"But throughout the 80's we mostly didn't know about this. It was around "
"1990 that programmers in the US started to become aware that they were faced "
@@ -3916,41 +2119,21 @@
"allowing software patents. But the community took notice of this. It was "
"actually free software developers and free software users who took the lead."
msgstr ""
-"Fue alrededor de los noventa cuando los programadores de EE. UU. "
-"empezaron a darse cuenta del peligro que representaban las patentes de "
-"software. De modo que yo conocÃa cómo funcionaba la informática antes y "
-"después, y no he visto ningún aumento del progreso a partir de 1990. En EE."
-" UU. no hubo debate, pero en Europa ha habido un amplio debate "
-"polÃtico. Hace unos años hubo presiones para enmendar el tratado de Munich "
-"que estableció la <a href=\"https://www.epo.org/\">Oficina Europea de "
-"Patentes</a>. Hay una <a href=\"https://www.epo.org/law-practice/legal-texts/"
-"html/epc/1973/e/ar52.html\">cláusula que dice que el software no es "
-"patentable</a>. La ofensiva pretendÃa enmendarla para que se permitieran las
"
-"patentes de software. Pero la comunidad se dio cuenta de esto, y fueron los "
-"desarrolladores y usuarios de software libre quienes lideraron la oposición."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | We are not the only ones threatened by software patents. All software
-# | developers are threatened by software patents and even software users are
-# | [-threatened by software patents.-] {+threatened.+} For instance, Paul
-# | Heckel, when Apple wasn't very scared of his threats, he threatened to
-# | start suing [-Apple's-] {+Apple+} customers. {+That,+} Apple found
-# | [-that-] very scary. They figured they couldn't afford to have their
-# | customers being sued like that, even if they would ultimately win. So
-# | [-the-] users can get sued too, either as a way of attacking a
-# | developer{+,+} or just as a way to squeeze money out of them on their own
-# | or [-to-] cause [-mayhem.-] {+mayhem to them on their own.+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "We are not the only ones threatened by software patents. All software "
-#| "developers are threatened by software patents and even software users are "
-#| "threatened by software patents. For instance, Paul Heckel, when Apple "
-#| "wasn't very scared of his threats, he threatened to start suing Apple's "
-#| "customers. Apple found that very scary. They figured they couldn't "
-#| "afford to have their customers being sued like that, even if they would "
-#| "ultimately win. So the users can get sued too, either as a way of "
-#| "attacking a developer or just as a way to squeeze money out of them on "
-#| "their own or to cause mayhem."
+"Pero durante los años ochenta no sabÃamos prácticamente nada de esto. Fue "
+"alrededor de los noventa cuando los programadores de EE. UU. empezaron "
+"a darse cuenta del peligro que representaban las patentes de software. De "
+"modo que yo conocÃa cómo funcionaba la informática antes y después, y no
he "
+"visto ningún aumento del progreso a partir de 1990. En EE. UU. no hubo "
+"debate, pero en Europa ha habido un amplio debate polÃtico. Hace unos años "
+"hubo presiones para enmendar el tratado de Munich que estableció la <a href="
+"\"https://www.epo.org/\">Oficina Europea de Patentes</a>. Hay una <a href="
+"\"https://www.epo.org/law-practice/legal-texts/html/epc/1973/e/ar52.html"
+"\">cláusula que dice que el software no es patentable</a>. La ofensiva "
+"pretendÃa enmendarla para que se permitieran las patentes de software. Pero "
+"la comunidad se dio cuenta de esto, y fueron los desarrolladores y usuarios "
+"de software libre quienes lideraron la oposición."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
"We are not the only ones threatened by software patents. All software "
"developers are threatened by software patents and even software users are "
@@ -3966,24 +2149,12 @@
"ejemplo, cuando Paul Heckel vio que sus amenazas no intimidaban demasiado a "
"Apple, amenazó con empezar a demandar a los clientes de Apple. Eso sÃ
asustó "
"a Apple. Calcularon que no podÃan permitirse que sus clientes fueran "
-"demandados de esa manera, aun cuando al final ganaran. De modo que también "
-"los usuarios pueden ser denunciados, bien como forma de atacar a un "
+"demandados de esa manera, aun si al final ganaran. De modo que también los "
+"usuarios pueden ser denunciados, bien como forma de atacar a un "
"desarrollador, o simplemente como un medio para sacarles dinero o provocar "
"confusión."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | All software developers and users are [-vulnerable. But-] {+vulnerable,
-# | but+} it was the free software community in Europe that took the lead in
-# | organizing opposition. In fact, twice now the countries that govern the
-# | European Patent Office voted not to amend that treaty. Then the EU took a
-# | hand{+,+} and the directorates of the EU were divided on the issue.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "All software developers and users are vulnerable. But it was the free "
-#| "software community in Europe that took the lead in organizing "
-#| "opposition. In fact, twice now the countries that govern the European "
-#| "Patent Office voted not to amend that treaty. Then the EU took a hand "
-#| "and the directorates of the EU were divided on the issue."
msgid ""
"All software developers and users are vulnerable, but it was the free "
"software community in Europe that took the lead in organizing opposition. "
@@ -3999,28 +2170,6 @@
"diferente."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | The one whose job is to promote software is against software patents{+,+}
-# | it seems. [-They-] {+But they+} were not in charge [-with-] {+of+} this
-# | issue. [-It is-] {+It's+} the open market directorate [-who-] {+that+}
-# | is in charge{+,+} and [-is lead-] {+that's led+} by somebody who is in
-# | favor of software patents. They basically disregarded public opinion
-# | [-which has-] {+that had+} been expressed to [-them. They have-] {+them,
-# | and they+} proposed a directive to allow software patents.[<a
-# | [-href=\"#f3\">3</a>]-] {+href=\"#f2\">2</a>]+} The French government has
-# | already said they are against it. People [-who-] are working in various
-# | other governments in Europe to oppose software patents{+,+} and it is
-# | vital to start doing so here.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "The one whose job is to promote software is against software patents it "
-#| "seems. They were not in charge with this issue. It is the open market "
-#| "directorate who is in charge and is lead by somebody who is in favor of "
-#| "software patents. They basically disregarded public opinion which has "
-#| "been expressed to them. They have proposed a directive to allow software "
-#| "patents.[<a href=\"#f3\">3</a>] The French government has already said "
-#| "they are against it. People who are working in various other governments "
-#| "in Europe to oppose software patents and it is vital to start doing so "
-#| "here."
msgid ""
"The one whose job is to promote software is against software patents, it "
"seems. But they were not in charge of this issue. It's the open market "
@@ -4036,40 +2185,12 @@
"al cargo es la Dirección General del Mercado Interno, cuyo lÃder es "
"favorable a las patentes de software. Ignoraron por completo la opinión "
"pública y propusieron una directiva que permitÃa las patentes de software."
-"[<a href=\"#f3\">3</a>] El Gobierno francés ya ha dicho que se opone a esa "
+"[<a href=\"#f2\">2</a>] El Gobierno francés ya ha dicho que se opone a esa "
"directiva. En varios otros paÃses europeos ya se está trabajando para "
"oponerse a las patentes de software, y es vital que aquà se empiece a hacer "
"lo mismo."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | According to Hartmut Pilch, who is one of the leaders in the European
-# | struggle against software patents, the main impetus comes from the <a
-# | href=\"https://www.gov.uk/topic/intellectual-property/patents\">UK
-# | [-“Intellectual Property”-] {+Patent+} Office</a>. [-This
-# | office-] {+The UK Patent Office+} is simply biased in favor of software
-# | patents. It had a public consultation{+,+} and most of the responses were
-# | opposed to software patents. They then wrote a report saying that people
-# | seem to be content with them, {+<i class=\"aside\">[laughs]</i>+}
-# | completely disregarding the answers. You see, the free software community
-# | [-said please-] {+said, “Please+} send the answers to them{+,+} and
-# | please send your answers to us too and we'll publish [-them.-]
-# | {+them.”+} So they published these answers{+,+} which were
-# | [-generally opposed.-] {+opposed generally.+} You'd have never guessed
-# | that from the report that the UK Patent Office published.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "According to Hartmut Pilch, who is one of the leaders in the European "
-#| "struggle against software patents, the main impetus comes from the <a "
-#| "href=\"https://www.gov.uk/topic/intellectual-property/patents\">UK “"
-#| "Intellectual Property” Office</a>. This office is simply biased in "
-#| "favor of software patents. It had a public consultation and most of the "
-#| "responses were opposed to software patents. They then wrote a report "
-#| "saying that people seem to be content with them, completely disregarding "
-#| "the answers. You see, the free software community said please send the "
-#| "answers to them and please send your answers to us too and we'll publish "
-#| "them. So they published these answers which were generally opposed. "
-#| "You'd have never guessed that from the report that the UK Patent Office "
-#| "published."
msgid ""
"According to Hartmut Pilch, who is one of the leaders in the European "
"struggle against software patents, the main impetus comes from the <a href="
@@ -4091,44 +2212,14 @@
"favorable a las patentes de software. Llevó a cabo una encuesta pública y
la "
"mayorÃa de las respuestas fueron contrarias a las patentes de software. "
"Luego redactaron un informe diciendo que la gente parecÃa estar conforme con
"
-"ellas, ignorando por completo las respuestas. Resulta que la comunidad del "
-"software libre pidió que se enviaran las respuestas a la Oficina de "
-"Patentes, y también a ellos, para asà publicarlas. De modo que las "
-"publicaron, y la mayorÃa eran contrarias. A la vista del informe de la "
-"Oficina de Patentes del Reino Unido nadie habrÃa pensado que era asÃ."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | They [-(-]{+[+}the UK Patent and Trademark Office[-)-]{+]+} use a term
-# | that they call [-technical effect.-] {+“technical effect.”+}
-# | This is a term which can stretch tremendously. You are supposed to think
-# | it means a program idea would only be patentable if it relates closely to
-# | specific physical activities. If that is the interpretation, it would
-# | mostly solve the problem. If the only software ideas that [-can-]
-# | {+could+} be patented were those that really did relate to a particular
-# | technical, specific physical result that you might have patented if you
-# | didn't use a program, that would be OK. The problem is [-that-] you can
-# | stretch that term. You can describe the result you get by running any
-# | program as a physical result. How does this physical result [-different-]
-# | {+differ+} from every other? Well it is as a result of this computation.
-# | The result is that the UK Patent Office is proposing something that looks
-# | like it leads to mostly solving the problem{+,+} and really gives [-carte
-# | blanche-] {+<i>carte blanche</i>+} for patenting almost anything.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "They (the UK Patent and Trademark Office) use a term that they call "
-#| "technical effect. This is a term which can stretch tremendously. You "
-#| "are supposed to think it means a program idea would only be patentable if "
-#| "it relates closely to specific physical activities. If that is the "
-#| "interpretation, it would mostly solve the problem. If the only software "
-#| "ideas that can be patented were those that really did relate to a "
-#| "particular technical, specific physical result that you might have "
-#| "patented if you didn't use a program, that would be OK. The problem is "
-#| "that you can stretch that term. You can describe the result you get by "
-#| "running any program as a physical result. How does this physical result "
-#| "different from every other? Well it is as a result of this computation. "
-#| "The result is that the UK Patent Office is proposing something that looks "
-#| "like it leads to mostly solving the problem and really gives carte "
-#| "blanche for patenting almost anything."
+"ellas, <i class=\"aside\">[risas]</i> ignorando por completo las respuestas. "
+"Resulta que la comunidad del software libre pidió que se enviaran las "
+"respuestas a la Oficina de Patentes, y también a ellos, para asà "
+"publicarlas. De modo que las publicaron, y la mayorÃa eran contrarias. A la "
+"vista del informe de la Oficina de Patentes del Reino Unido nadie habrÃa "
+"pensado que era asÃ."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
"They [the UK Patent and Trademark Office] use a term that they call “"
"technical effect.” This is a term which can stretch tremendously. You "
@@ -4145,7 +2236,7 @@
"mostly solving the problem, and really gives <i>carte blanche</i> for "
"patenting almost anything."
msgstr ""
-"Ellos (la Oficina de Patentes y Marcas Comerciales del Reino Unido) utilizan "
+"Ellos [la Oficina de Patentes y Marcas Comerciales del Reino Unido] utilizan "
"un concepto que llaman «efecto técnico». Es un concepto que se puede
estirar "
"enormemente. Se supone que hay que pensar que significa que la idea de un "
"programa solo es patentable si está estrechamente relacionada con "
@@ -4154,46 +2245,14 @@
"patentarse fueran las que realmente están relacionadas con una técnica "
"particular, con un resultado fÃsico concreto que podrÃa haberse patentado "
"sin utilizar un programa, eso estarÃa bien. El problema es que se puede "
-"ampliar esa condición. Se puede describir como un resultado fÃsico el "
-"resultado que se obtiene ejecutando algún programa. ¿En qué se diferencia "
+"ampliar esa condición. El resultado que se obtiene ejecutando algún "
+"programa se puede describir como un resultado fÃsico. ¿En qué se
diferencia "
"este resultado fÃsico de cualquier otro? En que es el resultado de esa "
"computación. La consecuencia es que la Oficina de Patentes del Reino Unido "
"está planteando una propuesta que parece conducir a la resolución del "
"problema y que en realidad da carta blanca para patentar casi todo."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | The people in the same ministry are also involved in [-the-] {+a+}
-# | copyright issue which really has nothing to do with software patents
-# | except that [-it is-] {+it's+} being handled by the same people. [-It
-# | is-] {+It's+} a question of interpreting the recent EU copyright
-# | directive, a horrible law like the <a
-# | href=\"https://www.eff.org/issues/dmca\">Digital Millennium Copyright Act
-# | in the US</a>. But there is some latitude for countries to decide how to
-# | implement it. The UK is proposing the most draconian possible way of
-# | implementing this directive. You could greatly reduce the harm that it
-# | does by implementing it properly. The UK wants to maximize the tyrannical
-# | effect of this directive. It seems there is a certain group, the <a
-# |
href=\"https://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukgwa/20070603164510/http://www.dti.gov.uk/\">{+
-# | +}Department of Trade and Industry [archived]</a>, {+<i
-# | class=\"aside\">[laughs]</i>+} who need to be reined in. {+<i
-# | class=\"aside\">[laughs]</i> +} It is necessary to put a check on
-# | their activities. Stop their creating new forms of power.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "The people in the same ministry are also involved in the copyright issue "
-#| "which really has nothing to do with software patents except that it is "
-#| "being handled by the same people. It is a question of interpreting the "
-#| "recent EU copyright directive, a horrible law like the <a href=\"https://"
-#| "www.eff.org/issues/dmca\">Digital Millennium Copyright Act in the US</"
-#| "a>. But there is some latitude for countries to decide how to implement "
-#| "it. The UK is proposing the most draconian possible way of implementing "
-#| "this directive. You could greatly reduce the harm that it does by "
-#| "implementing it properly. The UK wants to maximize the tyrannical effect "
-#| "of this directive. It seems there is a certain group, the <a href="
-#| "\"https://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukgwa/20070603164510/http://"
-#| "www.dti.gov.uk/\">Department of Trade and Industry [archived]</a>, who "
-#| "need to be reined in. It is necessary to put a check on their "
-#| "activities. Stop their creating new forms of power."
msgid ""
"The people in the same ministry are also involved in a copyright issue which "
"really has nothing to do with software patents except that it's being "
@@ -4222,53 +2281,25 @@
"que produce, pero el Reino Unido quiere maximizar el efecto tiránico de la "
"directiva. Parece que hay cierto organismo, el <a href=\"https://webarchive."
"nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukgwa/20070603164510/http://www.dti.gov.uk/"
-"\">Departamento de Comercio e Industria</a>, al que hay que poner freno. Es "
-"necesario poner lÃmites a sus actividades e impedirle crear nuevas formas de
"
-"poder."
-
-#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | Software patents tie up every software developer and every computer user
-# | in a new [-in a new-] form of [-bureaucrat.-] {+bureaucracy.+} If the
-# | businesses that use computers realized how much trouble this can cause for
-# | them, they would be up in arms{+,+} and [-I am-] {+I'm+} sure they [-can-]
-# | {+could+} stop it. Business doesn't like being tied up in bureaucracy.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Software patents tie up every software developer and every computer user "
-#| "in a new in a new form of bureaucrat. If the businesses that use "
-#| "computers realized how much trouble this can cause for them, they would "
-#| "be up in arms and I am sure they can stop it. Business doesn't like "
-#| "being tied up in bureaucracy."
+"\">Departamento de Comercio e Industria</a>, <i class=\"aside\">[risas]</i> "
+"al que hay que poner freno. <i class=\"aside\">[risas]</i> Es necesario "
+"poner lÃmites a sus actividades e impedirle crear nuevas formas de poder."
+
+#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
"Software patents tie up every software developer and every computer user in "
"a new form of bureaucracy. If the businesses that use computers realized "
"how much trouble this can cause for them, they would be up in arms, and I'm "
"sure they could stop it. Business doesn't like being tied up in bureaucracy."
msgstr ""
-"Las patentes de software enredan a todos los desarrolladores de software y a "
+"Las patentes de software atrapan a todos los desarrolladores de software y a "
"todos los usuarios de ordenadores en una nueva forma de burocracia. Si las "
"empresas que utilizan ordenadores se dieran cuenta de la cantidad de "
"problemas que esto puede ocasionarles se pondrÃan en pie de guerra y estoy "
-"seguro de que podrÃan detenerlo. A las empresas no les gustan las trabas "
+"seguro de que podrÃan ponerle fin. A las empresas no les gustan las trabas "
"burocráticas."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | Sometimes, of course, it serves an important purpose. There are some
-# | areas where we wish the UK government did a more careful job [-in-] {+of+}
-# | tying certain businesses up in bureaucracy, like when it involves moving
-# | animals around.[<a [-href=\"#f4\">4</a>]-] {+href=\"#f3\">3</a>]+} But in
-# | some cases, when it doesn't serve any purpose except to create artificial
-# | monopolies{+,+} so that somebody can interfere with software development,
-# | squeeze money out of developers and users, then we should reject it.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "Sometimes, of course, it serves an important purpose. There are some "
-#| "areas where we wish the UK government did a more careful job in tying "
-#| "certain businesses up in bureaucracy, like when it involves moving "
-#| "animals around.[<a href=\"#f4\">4</a>] But in some cases, when it doesn't "
-#| "serve any purpose except to create artificial monopolies so that somebody "
-#| "can interfere with software development, squeeze money out of developers "
-#| "and users, then we should reject it."
msgid ""
"Sometimes, of course, it serves an important purpose. There are some areas "
"where we wish the UK government did a more careful job of tying certain "
@@ -4281,11 +2312,10 @@
"Claro que a veces cumple una función importante. Hay algunos terrenos en los
"
"que desearÃamos que el Gobierno del Reino Unido hiciera una labor más "
"cuidadosa imponiendo trámites burocráticos a ciertas empresas, como cuando "
-"se trata de trasladar animales de un lugar a otro.[<a href=\"#f4\">4</a>] "
+"se trata de trasladar animales de un lugar a otro.[<a href=\"#f3\">3</a>] "
"Pero en ciertos casos, cuando no sirve más que para crear monopolios "
-"artificiales que permiten que alguien interfiera en el desarrollo del "
-"software y exprima a los desarrolladores y usuarios, entonces hemos de "
-"rechazarla."
+"artificiales para que alguien interfiera en el desarrollo del software y "
+"exprima a los desarrolladores y usuarios, entonces hemos de rechazarla."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
msgid ""
@@ -4299,14 +2329,12 @@
"a>."
#. type: Content of: <div><p>
-# | The battle is not over. It still can be won. {+<i
-# | class=\"aside\">[applause]</i>+}
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid "The battle is not over. It still can be won."
msgid ""
"The battle is not over. It still can be won. <i class=\"aside\">[applause]</"
"i>"
-msgstr "La batalla no ha terminado. Aún se puede ganar."
+msgstr ""
+"La batalla no ha terminado. Aún se puede ganar. <i class=\"aside"
+"\">[aplausos]</i>"
# type: Content of: <h4>
#. type: Content of: <div><h3>
@@ -4355,21 +2383,12 @@
msgstr "Para evitar que se extienda la fiebre aftosa."
#. type: Content of: <div><div><p>
-# | This [-essay-] {+speech+} is published in <a
-# |
href=\"https://shop.fsf.org/product/free-software-free-society/\"><cite>Free
-# | Software, Free Society: The Selected Essays of Richard M.
-# | Stallman</cite></a>.
-#, fuzzy
-#| msgid ""
-#| "This essay is published in <a href=\"https://shop.fsf.org/product/free-"
-#| "software-free-society/\"><cite>Free Software, Free Society: The Selected "
-#| "Essays of Richard M. Stallman</cite></a>."
msgid ""
"This speech is published in <a href=\"https://shop.fsf.org/product/free-"
"software-free-society/\"><cite>Free Software, Free Society: The Selected "
"Essays of Richard M. Stallman</cite></a>."
msgstr ""
-"Este ensayo está publicado en el libro <a href=\"https://shop.fsf.org/"
+"Esta charla está publicada en el libro <a href=\"https://shop.fsf.org/"
"product/free-software-free-society/\"><cite>Software libre para una sociedad "
"libre: Selección de ensayos de Richard M. Stallman</cite></a>."
[Prev in Thread] |
Current Thread |
[Next in Thread] |
- www/philosophy/po software-patents.es.po,
Dora Scilipoti <=