Re: [PATCH 0/1] pcie: Allow atomic completion on PCIE root port

[Robin Voetter]

On 4/21/23 10:22, Michael S. Tsirkin wrote:
> On Thu, Apr 20, 2023 at 05:38:39PM +0200, robin@streamhpc.com wrote:
>> From: Robin Voetter <robin@streamhpc.com>
>>
>> The ROCm driver for Linux uses PCIe atomics to schedule work and
>> generally communicate between the host and the device.  This does not
>> currently work in QEMU with regular vfio-pci passthrough, because the
>> pcie-root-port does not advertise the PCIe atomic completer
>> capabilities.  When initializing the GPU from the Linux driver, it
>> queries whether the PCIe connection from the CPU to GPU supports the
>> required capabilities[1] in the pci_enable_atomic_ops_to_root
>> function[2].  Currently the only part where this fails is checking the
>> atomic completer capabilities (32 and 64 bits) on the root port[3].  In
>> this case, the driver determines that PCIe atomics are not supported at
>> all, and this causes ROCm programs to misbehave.  (While AMD advertises
>> that there is some support for ROCm without PCIe atomics, I have never
>> actually gotten that working...)
>>
>> This patch allows ROCm to properly function by introducing an
>> additional experimental property to the pcie-root-port,
>> x-atomic-completion.
> 
> so what exactly makes it experimental? from this description
> it looks like it actually has to be enabled for things to work?

I was not sure which would be appropriate, but I'm fine with making it a
non-experimental option.