Re: [PATCH v3 kvm/queue 05/16] KVM: Maintain ofs_tree for fast memslot lookup by file offset

[Sean Christopherson]

On Thu, Dec 23, 2021, Chao Peng wrote:
> Similar to hva_tree for hva range, maintain interval tree ofs_tree for
> offset range of a fd-based memslot so the lookup by offset range can be
> faster when memslot count is high.

This won't work.  The hva_tree relies on there being exactly one virtual address
space, whereas with private memory, userspace can map multiple files into the
guest at different gfns, but with overlapping offsets.

I also dislike hijacking __kvm_handle_hva_range() in patch 07.

KVM also needs to disallow mapping the same file+offset into multiple gfns, 
which
I don't see anywhere in this series.

In other words, there needs to be a 1:1 gfn:file+offset mapping.  Since 
userspace
likely wants to allocate a single file for guest private memory and map it into
multiple discontiguous slots, e.g. to skip the PCI hole, the best idea off the 
top
of my head would be to register the notifier on a per-slot basis, not a per-VM
basis.  It would require a 'struct kvm *' in 'struct kvm_memory_slot', but 
that's
not a huge deal.

That way, KVM's notifier callback already knows the memslot and can compute 
overlap
between the memslot and the range by reversing the math done by 
kvm_memfd_get_pfn().
Then, armed with the gfn and slot, invalidation is just a matter of constructing
a struct kvm_gfn_range and invoking kvm_unmap_gfn_range().