Re: [Qemu-devel] [PATCH] User mode: Handle x86_64 vsyscall

[Stefan Weil]

Laurent Desnogues schrieb:
> On Fri, Feb 5, 2010 at 11:57 PM, Stefan Weil <address@hidden> wrote:
>> Laurent Desnogues schrieb:
> [...]
>> I'm still struggling with bntest and other x86_64-linux-user software
>> calling any of the vsyscall functions.
>>
>> Laurent, your vsyscall patch only works on x86_64 hosts.
>>
>> A lot of software calls time() which uses vsyscall on x86_64 which
>> does not work with x86_64-linux-user mode.
>
> I'm not sure I understand what you mean. Did you try
> on some other host and it failed? Was your host
> 32-bit? If so, I'm afraid user-mode will fail for more
> reasons than vsyscall.
>
>> So the status of x86_64-linux-user is not more than experimental :-(
>>
>> I tried to modify x86_64-linux-user to set up a vsyscall page in high
>> memory,
>> but this seems to be difficult (at least with 32 bit host).
>>
>> Any hints how this should be done are welcome.
>
> My patch explicitly prevents the linking of the vsyscall
> page.
>
> Could you provide more info about your host?
>
>
> Laurent
>


I tested two different hosts with x86_64-linux-user:

* 32 bit Intel (i386) - does not work with your patch
* 64 bit AMD (x86_64)  - works with your patch

Your patch improves the emulation for 64 bit hosts.
Nevertheless, it has some open points:

* target-i386 code should not have to know about
  linux vsyscall

* there is no vsyscall page in memory,
  but very special programs might expect to see one
  (it is even worse: the target sees the memory page
  of the host)

* it is not possible to step into vsyscall code
  using a debugger

My favorite solution would be a vsyscall page mapped
to the correct fixed address and filled with QEMU
generated specific code, for example code which calls the
normal syscalls to do the work. This would only
need modifications for linux-user code.

Regards
Stefan