Re: [Qemu-block] [PATCH v16 00/22] block: Image locking series

[Kevin Wolf]

Am 02.05.2017 um 10:18 hat Fam Zheng geschrieben:
> v16: Rebase to the latest block-next branch of Kevin.
>      Address Kevin's comments:
>      - on/off => on/off/auto for file.locking option
>      - Add file.locking to QAPI schema
>      - Fall back to POSIX file lock if OFD lock not available
>      - Print warning when falling back, if locking=on specified
>        (This means qemu-io/qemu-img need --image-opts to enable lock)
>      - Drop the BLK_PERM_MAX patch and use an alternative
>      - Use the 'TEST_IMG="$TEST_IMG.base" _make_test_img ...' idiom
>      - Drop reopen callback changes
>      - Don't open s->lock_fd if !s->use_lock
>      - Use the same open flags for the lock fd
>      - Don't leak the returned string for bdrv_perm_names
>      - Clear up comment on raw_apply_lock_bytes
>      - Improve error message text
>      - Pass "0, 0" to raw_handle_perm_lock in raw_abort_perm_update
>      - Filter out test dir in reference output
>      - Add locking to bdrv_host_device.

Looks like we're almost there! :-)

The actual locking code looks good to me now. I had a try at cleaning up
the BDRV_O_INACTIVE handling at the block layer level so that we don't
need the special code in file-posix (and we definitely want to do this),
but it's a bit harder than I thought. So let's merge your file-posix
code as it is and clean up things on top.

Kevin