[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Introduce breakingRehearsalMarks for line-breaking RehearsalMarks (i
From: |
nine . fierce . ballads |
Subject: |
Re: Introduce breakingRehearsalMarks for line-breaking RehearsalMarks (issue 577180043 by address@hidden) |
Date: |
Wed, 11 Dec 2019 17:29:27 -0800 |
Harm,
With respect, I'm far from convinced that this is a good idea, but I
will continue to think about it. Thoughts so far:
* The user provides music for the appearance of the mark at the
beginning or end of a line, but can he control what happens in the
middle? They seem to stack vertically. What if the user would
prefer them to be side by side?
* The regression tests cover only line breaks. The unbroken
appearance is not covered.
* I am concerned about the complexity of this function as it deals
with mark sequence numbers. I'm skeptical that it's a fair trade
for what it offers.
* I struggle with the semantics of using one event and grob to do
double duty, e.g. as both a fermata and a rehearsal mark. One of my
stale experiments is a performer that inserts rehearsal marks into
MIDI files. I don't relish the thought of trying to extract a
MIDI-compatible rehearsal letter/number from such a mishmash.
https://codereview.appspot.com/577180043/
- Introduce breakingRehearsalMarks for line-breaking RehearsalMarks (issue 577180043 by address@hidden), thomasmorley65, 2019/12/07
- Re: Introduce breakingRehearsalMarks for line-breaking RehearsalMarks (issue 577180043 by address@hidden), nine . fierce . ballads, 2019/12/07
- Re: Introduce breakingRehearsalMarks for line-breaking RehearsalMarks (issue 577180043 by address@hidden), thomasmorley65, 2019/12/07
- Re: Introduce breakingRehearsalMarks for line-breaking RehearsalMarks (issue 577180043 by address@hidden), nine . fierce . ballads, 2019/12/11
- Re: Introduce breakingRehearsalMarks for line-breaking RehearsalMarks (issue 577180043 by address@hidden),
nine . fierce . ballads <=
- Re: Introduce breakingRehearsalMarks for line-breaking RehearsalMarks (issue 577180043 by address@hidden), thomasmorley65, 2019/12/12
- Re: Introduce breakingRehearsalMarks for line-breaking RehearsalMarks (issue 577180043 by address@hidden), thomasmorley65, 2019/12/17