[Top][All Lists]
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
lilypond too noisy on the cmd line
From: |
Mark Veltzer |
Subject: |
lilypond too noisy on the cmd line |
Date: |
Sat, 1 Jan 2011 09:49:10 +0000 (UTC) |
User-agent: |
Loom/3.14 (http://gmane.org/) |
Hello all!
First is first: thanks for a great piece of software.
This is a long standing feature request for me which you probably got from
hundreds of other users but I sent it anyway since I see it as a major pain.
When I run lilypond it is too noisy. It prints out lots of stuff (version,
progress and more) to standard error. This has several problems:
- It does not allow me to differentiate between good messages and bad. The basic
idea of standard output and error was to enable such a distinction. Lilypond
does away with this.
- Since I build lots of lily files in a makefile then I do not wish to see any
of the progress, version and standard messages, as I only want to see real
errors if they occur. This forces me to wrap lilypond invocation in a script
which collects it's output, waits for the return code and in the case that the
return code indicates an error with the lilypond process (probably parsing
error) then I print out the output which is still too verbose because it
contains a lot more than the errors.
- Other translators or even huge compilers (gcc to name famous ones) manage to
remain silent even though they do quite a lot under the hood so this is not an
unreasonable request.
Suggestions:
- version, progress and general messages which are not error messages should go
to stdout and NOT stderr.
- a --quiet flag should be added to shut down all of the regular messages which
are not error messages (meaning those going to stdout).
- In the long run I suggest that --quiet become the default since that is how
most compilers/translators behave (do their work quietly unless errors occur or
verbose mode is requested).
Please reply to my email as I am not a subscriber.
Cheers,
Mark
- lilypond too noisy on the cmd line,
Mark Veltzer <=
- Re: lilypond too noisy on the cmd line, Graham Percival, 2011/01/01
- Re: lilypond too noisy on the cmd line, David Santamauro, 2011/01/01
- Re: lilypond too noisy on the cmd line, Graham Percival, 2011/01/01
- Re: lilypond too noisy on the cmd line, Bertalan Fodor (LilyPondTool), 2011/01/02
- Re: lilypond too noisy on the cmd line, David Santamauro, 2011/01/02
- lilypond logging (Re: lilypond too noisy on the cmd line), David Santamauro, 2011/01/03
- Re: lilypond logging (Re: lilypond too noisy on the cmd line), Matthias Kilian, 2011/01/03
Re: lilypond too noisy on the cmd line, David Kastrup, 2011/01/01