[Top][All Lists]

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Microsoft needs a help strategy

From: Rjack
Subject: Re: Microsoft needs a help strategy
Date: Mon, 26 Jan 2009 15:29:33 -0500
User-agent: Thunderbird (Windows/20081209)

amicus_curious wrote:

"Rjack" <> wrote in message">

THE GPL IS THE BEST FRIEND MICROSOFT EVER HAD. Open source advocates are ideologically blinded to these facts.

That is an interesting spin to the issue!

The reality is that the GPL has no practical effect on anything of any importance in terms of market development.

The GPL has a very intimidating effect on *small* proprietary developers... they actually believe bullshit propaganda like "getting ground up in the gears of the SFLC or FSF" because
of the alleged legal validity of the GPL.

One only need observe the voluntary dismissal WITH PREJUDICE
obtained by Verizon when they told SFLC to kiss their ass.
Many hardware developers have a vested financial interest in complying with SFLC demands. Business is the art of making money and if it is profitable to comply with silly GPL demands they will do so ... that doesn't make the GPL a valid business model.

One could, perhaps, take GPL code and attempt to create a new software product by extending the GPL source in some useful way, but, if you think about it more deeply, that is ever so unlikely to be successful.

For example, say you could safely, without getting ground up in the gears of the SFLC or FSF, hijack the source code for Open Office or Gimp or even Linux itself. If you try to sell it as a product by itself, with nothing added, you are going to fail, since the product is already available at essentially zero cost and you have nothing to differentiate yourself. If you add some useful improvement, you are still faced with a market that is mature and will only spur the incumbent suppliers to duplicate your improvement for their own products. The customers will classically wait for the incumbent to adopt the new feature.


Can you seriously believe that another office suite or graphics package or OS platform can make any headway against things like MS Office, Adobe Photoshop, or Windows itself? The marketing and business issues involved in such an endeavor totally swamp the technology issues.


For the first time ever, considering the present economic crisis at hand, it is possible that netbooks and lightweight applications can make serious inroads into the home market -- perhaps even small businesses since many must cut IT costs just to survive. A netbook or minimal desktop with a FreeBSD operating system could open a market for small developers. Small businesses often require little more than a good $39 GUI text editor. I have a feeling there is going to be a lot of unemployed software people in the next few
years who will be willing to try a shot at proprietary programming

Rjack :)

reply via email to

[Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread]