gnokiid-0.5.4 problems - 5110 (Was: Re: Wrong cable for 5110?)

[Jon Wikne]

BORBELY Zoltan <address@hidden> wrote:

> On Thu, Sep 25, 2003 at 12:52:55PM +0200, Jon Wikne wrote:
> > *BUT*:
> > gnokiid 0.5.4 (for using the phone as a modem) _still_ does
> > not work. I have never gotten this to work beyond 0.3.3.
> > Previously, I have tried 0.4.3 and 0.5.0_pre, and at least
> > for one of these reported a similar error to the list.
> > What happens is given here:
> > 
> > Launching gnokiid... 
> > GNOKIID Version 0.5.4
> > Calling and starting pppd... 
> > AT
> > OK
> > ATDTmy-number
> > CARRIER
> > XID: N2 15 XID: Ver 0 IWF-MS 61 MS-IWF 61 T1 550ms N2 15 T2 0ms Connect 
> > script failed
> > 
> > On 0.3.3, the "CARRIER" is instead followed by "CONNECT", and
> > subsequently the PPP data link starts working. (Using the same
> > connect script.)
> > 
> > I can live with gnokiid-0.3.3. But just out of curiosity,
> > and maybe a bit of GNU spirit: Has anybody at all got gnokiid
> > to work on a 5110 past 0.3.3?
> 
> Please compile both the 0.3.3 and 0.5.4 with debug enabled and send
> me the debug outputs. I try to figure out what is the difference
> between these versions.

OK, thanks! Rather than sending two large log files with e-mail, and
also to cater for a possible interest from others than you, I have
put the logs on the Web here:

http://puma.uio.no/jon/gnokii/

Here is both the log from a successful session with gnokiid-0.3.3,
and that from the aborted session with gnokiid-0.5.4.

Just from a quick browse myself, I realize that also the debug
code has changed to a large extent after 0.3.3. This means that
there is some work associated with comparing the logs directly....

Note: I masked out the phone number, username and password sections
of the dialog, inserting the character 'x' in appropriate places.


Cheers,
-- Jon