[Gnash-commit] [bug #50393] `undefined` FSCommand parameter is not correctly passed to host container

[Nutchanon Wetchasit]

Follow-up Comment #7, bug #50393 (project gnash):

Well, in comment 5 <http://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?50393#comment5>, I ran two
kinds of tests on both players:

* Manual tests, a.k.a. `geturl-targettest.zip`.
* Automated tests, a.k.a. `hostcmd_testrunner_v*`, `hostcmd_htmltest_v*.html`
and `hostcmd-geturl_testrunner_v*`.

The first paragraph in comment 5 describes result from manual tests
(_...running all HTML files *in `geturl-targettest.zip`* with identical
result..._): which Gnash, of course, yield result identical to Flash Player.

Full manual test results (originally omitted from comment 5) are as
follows...

When testing Gnash with SWF version 5:

* getURL("loaded.html",undefined): The main page redirected to "loaded.html".
* getURL("loaded.html",null): File "loaded.html" got loaded into a frame named
"null".
* getURL("loaded.html",""): The main page redirected to "loaded.html".
* getURL("loaded.html"): The main page redirected to "loaded.html".
* MovieClip.getURL("loaded.html",undefined): The main page redirected to
"loaded.html".
* MovieClip.getURL("loaded.html",null): File "loaded.html" got loaded into a
frame named "null".
* MovieClip.getURL("loaded.html",""): The main page redirected to
"loaded.html".
* MovieClip.getURL("loaded.html"): The main page redirected to "loaded.html".

When testing Gnash with SWF version 6:

* getURL("loaded.html",undefined): The main page redirected to "loaded.html".
* getURL("loaded.html",null): File "loaded.html" got loaded into a frame named
"null".
* getURL("loaded.html",""): The main page redirected to "loaded.html".
* getURL("loaded.html"): The main page redirected to "loaded.html".
* MovieClip.getURL("loaded.html",undefined): The main page redirected to
"loaded.html".
* MovieClip.getURL("loaded.html",null): File "loaded.html" got loaded into a
frame named "null".
* MovieClip.getURL("loaded.html",""): The main page redirected to
"loaded.html".
* MovieClip.getURL("loaded.html"): The main page redirected to "loaded.html".

When testing Gnash with SWF version 7:

* getURL("loaded.html",undefined): File "loaded.html" got loaded into a frame
named "undefined".
* getURL("loaded.html",null): File "loaded.html" got loaded into a frame named
"null".
* getURL("loaded.html",""): The main page redirected to "loaded.html".
* getURL("loaded.html"): The main page redirected to "loaded.html".
* MovieClip.getURL("loaded.html",undefined): The main page redirected to
"loaded.html".
* MovieClip.getURL("loaded.html",null): File "loaded.html" got loaded into a
frame named "null".
* MovieClip.getURL("loaded.html",""): The main page redirected to
"loaded.html".
* MovieClip.getURL("loaded.html"): The main page redirected to "loaded.html".

When testing Gnash with SWF version 8:

* getURL("loaded.html",undefined): File "loaded.html" got loaded into a frame
named "undefined".
* getURL("loaded.html",null): File "loaded.html" got loaded into a frame named
"null".
* getURL("loaded.html",""): The main page redirected to "loaded.html".
* getURL("loaded.html"): The main page redirected to "loaded.html".
* MovieClip.getURL("loaded.html",undefined): The main page redirected to
"loaded.html".
* MovieClip.getURL("loaded.html",null): File "loaded.html" got loaded into a
frame named "null".
* MovieClip.getURL("loaded.html",""): The main page redirected to
"loaded.html".
* MovieClip.getURL("loaded.html"): The main page redirected to "loaded.html".

(You would see that result is the same as one from Flash Player
<http://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?50393#comment1>)

Note: The reason I used these manual tests, is to double-check
`hostcmd-geturl_testrunner_v*`'s behavior, as it does not have a
semi-automatic HTML counterpart
<http://savannah.gnu.org/patch/?9279#comment5>.

Hope this clear things up.

Gnash: 0.8.11dev (git 8a11e60 8-Mar-2017)
Flash Player: 11.2.202.491 (NPAPI binary)
Browser: Iceweasel 10.0.12 (debian) 
System: Debian GNU/Linux 7.0 Wheezy i386


    _______________________________________________________

Reply to this item at:

  <http://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?50393>

_______________________________________________
  Message sent via/by Savannah
  http://savannah.gnu.org/