Re: [Bug-XBoard] premove bug?

[Tim Mann]

On Wed, 21 Oct 2009 19:28:44 +0200, "h.g. muller" <address@hidden> wrote:
> There seems to be at least one real problem here:
> 
> The premove texts (as given by the command-line option -premoveBlackText,
> or through the Option->ICS menu dialog) is sent to the ICS prefixed with $.
> And the ICS seems to dislike that. (At least my version of the Lasker 2.2.3
> Chessd code rejects $d7d5 as illegal, while d7d5 was accepted.)
> I checked, and $ was aliased to @.
> 
> Is this a change in ICS behavior? This has not changed since 4.2.7!
> Normal moves are not prefixed with $. What is this prefixing with $
> supposed to do anyway?

IIRC:  chessclub.com and freechess.org both have features that let
you prefix a command with a special character to quote the command so
that the alias feature wouldn't look at it and possibly change it to a
different command.  Unfortunately they use different characters.
xboard tries to use that, at least on some commands, so that users
can't accidentally (or deliberately) goof things up by aliasing a
command that xboard wants to send directly to the ICS to something else.

Apparently that doesn't work with moves, at least on the ICS you're
looking at.  Glancing at the old change log, I noticed that we
generally try not to use it with moves: "Removed the leading
alias-suppression character when sending a move to ICS, because it
seemed to break accuclock on chess.net."  I guess premoves must go
through a different path and the character got left in for them.

By the way, I notice -premoveBlackText is not documented in the xboard
docs, but is in winboard.  (That was my error -- I notice it's that way
in 4.2.7.)

-- 
Tim Mann  address@hidden  http://tim-mann.org/