Re: transpose fails to transpose the pitchedTrill notehead

[David Kastrup]

David Kastrup <address@hidden> writes:

> Arnold <address@hidden> writes:
>
>>> I'm not top posting.
>>
>> Hello, the trill note head (resp. pitch) of a pitchedTrill is no longer 
>> transposed (as in 2.14.2).
>> Tested on a Win7/64 Computer.
>>
>> \version "2.15.36"
>> { \transpose c as' { \pitchedTrill e'4\startTrillSpan fis'
>> r\stopTrillSpan } }
>
> New issue 2484
> Patch: Let pitched trills in articulations be transposed as well
> http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=2484
>
> It turns out that the example file
> \version "2.15.34"
> \new Voice
> { \transpose c as' { \pitchedTrill e'4\startTrillSpan fis' r\stopTrillSpan }
>                    { \pitchedTrill e'4\startTrillSpan fis' r\stopTrillSpan }
> }
>
> still gives a strange result with the fix applied: the first trill pitch
> gets an explicit natural accidental even though this would be part of
> the surrounding key signature.  Removing \pitchedTrill, \startTrillSpan,
> and \stopTrillSpan does not result in similar spurious accidentals, so
> it would appear to be an artifact of the pitched trill code.
>
> This is a separate issue, however, and in contrast to your issue not
> likely a regression.

And not related to transposition:

\version "2.15.34"
\new Voice
{ \pitchedTrill c''4\startTrillSpan d'' r\stopTrillSpan }

is sufficient for getting an unneeded natural here.  Huh.

-- 
David Kastrup