Re: broken slurs

[Werner LEMBERG]

> > Werner, can you please verify that this now has been fixed?

No, it isn't.

> I looked at a very nice edition of the Brahms intermezzi op110, and
> I could find very few examples where the trend of the melody was
> actually present in the in general, the slurs ending/begin points
> were determined by the last/first note of the line.

I think my description of the problem was bad.  With 2.3.20, the end
point of the first slur and the start point of the second slur is
fine, but the end point of the second slur isn't.  It is far too high.
Had I created a slur over the four notes in the second staff only, the
end point of the slur would be located directly above the note,
without the strange space:


  \score {
    \relative c'' {
      e2( e | g2 a | \break
      b2 a | e2 c) | \break
      b'2( a | e2 c) |
    }

    \paper {
      indent = 0.0\mm
      linewidth = 70.0\mm
    }
  }

BTW, it seems that the `linewidth' instruction is handled incorrectly:
In the image, the actual line width is much bigger than the requested
70mm.


    Werner


======================================================================


begin 644 xxx.png
MB5!.1PT*&@address@hidden"`(```!VBT[%````!&=!34$``+&/
M"_QA!0```#AT15AT4V]F='=A<address@hidden<VEO;address@hidden
M,B\R.2\Y-"`H4$Y'('!A=&-H(#$N,BG=%2Y)```,I4E$051XVNW=V:ZCNA8%
MT!#E_W\Y];"EB")`#+AC>8RGJU.GR74W68#-]'Z_'P!`LJ<F``#9"0"R$P!D
M)P#(3@"0G0"`[`0`V0D`LA,`9"<`R$X`D)address@hidden@.Q>address@hidden"<;V&U
M&?S:':042&C9"2+-$DE'`SC>N)*=6";D%G0QRVXT!60G,D^JP0TF>%?34'82
M+?P,:1AG#6DUWV4G':address@hidden<69&JK2$9LG.:address@hidden'Y`1\M:Z;7H:NQ5^Z%4
M3D0="MQ])2RWCF7+3JMMYZ&H=P"ZR,Z&]YI%H]8&:.7\F7P..BG:8G(1K!46
MA(#9^=VUTS1Y;address@hidden($T#(#TU%2IALW/,,address@hidden(2N+*DS-<094EWG76N/[9>
M$8K:P1WNS`4"7WQ;<(:H.Q<#(address@hidden;+O4D!&;(STLS9N6$"4O-[[GL.
MEVOQW-J,:`/]0'7G?1<%HQ..7E9Z#I>K>1?-:.M\Y.R\>X^6/G@"@@6GR=+V
M2H68=>?M;N`8E)`XJ;=N)YI$1==/S3M$=@(A[3R'(V,address@hidden:
M!=D)Q$E-"SVC3P=W8P!0RE^M.Q/_8XMWTV]T)V=KIYKK:.W<80.V;2YW:`?I
MZ!'6G^+9&7N"V:FFG>GGXAUNZE)V_BV"-[K'ZR):.P/T4G?>8J&T4TT[`V3Q
MO!B3`<Y#\&address@hidden,5([`[3,SGMM]EK\6CO5M#-`X[KS+FNB$R.U
M,T"&5<YS*0!"ZNMLA`K?CM]Z5_/TUD!O>-:L.+5SF,;4H1KYUJU:SK.W'_3X
M]3%J93$`;3VO_,/O][M<Q?G]US]_)address@hidden;address@hidden(R!)WYV4P`-'J
address@hidden(@;`-GYHR(4E@",S/Y.`&)JO[]S==_(3LI>V859XO^V'525KL6T<ZS&
MU*$:^=:M6L[S](_8_V7S+24`$,FQ=X4^5T:)address@hidden@].[<"]9.I)4Y+$,E`
M8'663=IGY_S9YSPUO\O3HSEG``$P1-U9.05/'P</`#UFY_5MH/LUJ[NU`#1G
M?R<`,?6ROW/QGNWWQS57"\<KOS[7>49V4%6Z%M/.&A.ZF3[E7#K/ML+I\.\9
MHP&`'EQ]WND&+P"R,[70_-2"XA,`V9D:GX^U7;V?O\'3&@!&S\ZM^%PE.`&0
MG<OXW$E0P0E`8*\3_TQ*?`I.`*)R-@(``14MX3*?#>MN+0#A/34!`!QR^'GG
address@hidden<address@hidden)@.P$`&0G`/26G:NO"WF'"`#9F1J<'G\"
M(#LWPW(K.!6=`,C.]?A<E)@address@hidden&<>9,OM6D5'$"(#M30U1J`B`[`8!-]G<"
address@hidden)`+(3`&0G`,A.`$!V`H#L!`#9"0"R$P!D)P#(address@hidden@*`[`0`V0D`
MLA,`9"<`(#L!0'8"@.P$`-D)`+(3`&0G`"`[`4!V`H#L!`#9"0"R$P!D)P`@
address@hidden,`D)T`<,U+$[!CFB:-<`OO]ULC0+VUT9038R"P078*
M/$L>-QN6QB2RTUIC^0"S!MEI8IN]8*I"X.R\,M-,+;`.6`<(FYV')H:9`%A/
M&"@[?XYIXQCH(5RM1;*SN]%I4`*WBU4+E^RL-.8,-2!JIEK?9&>V\60P`0-&
MJ:5/=AX;-T8,@"51=B:-$N,#P/(X4';^=>U.!U?N>T\1`&CKF7A-]!>?6TE6
MY_"M:9H\,P"@]^Q,#Z?2\?F=FI_?Y@,C`'24G=\%Z$Z>E<NP^;]YGIH`4%_2
MMZ]W[M96L/-"VM\?B=+*'3&address@hidden:09(
MS<[$N[+E5M+5RG*^E%O$*Y>;GC0#_-A>,G_,N?C?J\&9<;_*B759CK9J>8T/
address@hidden,G9T_4[!<3,X?H'Z>MDKE"A9W%W:>-.L.0';>8T&GH:U[
M]0"R4YZQEYJZ'I"=I9970J:FX`1X:0)2R$L`V8G4!#CIJ0D`H$UV>M@)I^>.
MZ0/WFE:3<V(!"*G<(Z?7Z?]8RA%]N<I9C]Q:7;AI_,';>?4M:V>'<9=I5<[S
M^H]3I\((JX_/`,!>address@hidden"D[S&K+5G:4_V`DT#\YYK3G_(VF*[%1T`DDS
MVK4R_#E_S]8!IQ"XZ%PM-TUVN)address@hidden/&B5*3'?Z;%V[+`!!27_L[:WY8PXL)
MS0L.C3]:address@hidden)."_F'O;.'F+9Z=;7\0$/Z:G9T[X>+S%C)\^UJ:`IP+3C%Y
M4\_37:address@hidden/;.CI*=7K<#R,)+FF/5G:L=+T0!KE2B\V)address@hidden"*[UWA25`
MWM3<+T;IM^_<address@hidden@I/;[.U=O*>RDK`NH,!?%NG*T=M;OU6I-C5RMIJ^1G8D_
M8O^7F7X`JHNHGN?Z.S'2W?X%()X,9\'/3TAP6H)+8P!UYUXU.=_;N[5K18X"
M(#N5+`#(SGR\0@:`[%13`L#_A:*S$0`(J9>S$;Y?`OK^#L#/OP?8GUQ^C^XF
M2SN7\^S\]P%`;U*S\WOCYF>address@hidden':FQN=C^_.M#[<F`)"=CR/'address@hidden&3G
M,CYW$E1P`A#8F?-L4^)3<`(0E?V=``14M(2;\O[;W:T%L$B&]]0$`'#(X>>=
M\P^0:3X`U)VIP?GP6!0`V7DH.,4G`+(3`)"=`%#`Z\H_O/JZD'>(``XMFPQ4
M=SI4`0#9>2`LMX+3)14`LG,]/A<EIHH3@'&<.9-O-2E5G`#(SM00E9H`R$X`
M8)/address@hidden@*`[`0`V0D`LA,`D)T`(#L!0'8"@.P$`-D)`+(3`)"=`"`[
M`4!V`H#L!`#9"0#(3@"address@hidden@*`[`0`V0D`R$X`D)T`(#L!0'8"@.P$
M`-D)`,A.`)"=`"`[`4!V`H#L!`!D)P#(3@"address@hidden@BI<FV#=-TQU_]OO]
MUG<`I:)AJ$7VID$HH0%D9Q?I:-WOZGI"=P"RL_'2;R$>*H]U-R`[CZW.UDT!
M+'0!V9FTJEKU:!*Z!A[P&.U=(:B9N"address@hidden:address@hidden)!:\*"[`2*I*QY
M#2VS<S&->YB0WRN+90(I*U^AIM?U:5;MK=?5U'14$,-*G'=;<R1E[LA7.%EW
M)A:FI>address@hidden<&A2PIIZJ#M_S*N+*9MK8INKT*2$7<W7_=`U6QFT[MQ/
MQSJ/'G=*6T4GW+=X-7,)7G=FF2?9KXL]Z6R^,EK[2!\/W^-'S4K8[$R_$_OW
MVD[V.[>KE:5;N#VDIFL76B6K6<^-Z\XF0[G#/3.C!>>\S1TL3)-DW8I5HY%Z
M"^//T;;ZN'&K\LNXF)XH:\R<5BVO\>EYK!J<address@hidden@
M[DPO1A\%7GSU)FWSB_J=M[3T"\%*54.:;'4GK*X[5AG"E*J?@:U"I49V&E+#
M7JWK>D8.5..?G'6G30LCI*:address@hidden"0<NS$&:BE+9"5(3KJ:IUP)D
M)U"<E\FCIJD<#3RM)N?$`C#(C8&"=6?Z!W533AIR2>["C?NV\]91QD9%EE;5
MC#6';O'LO/@KC08(N?HXRCA[,>3R]+Y>%Z>6[VE`^."TN)<.4<;*3D,!8@>G
M#\[#JN?%F%1TPCA5D?D.^>M.EZ(0INCTP7DHDIV.TH!QHM1,A_QUI^D$L2/3
M3*_6SAKY'AWGD08`(?5U-D+-"R4O]36_(M;XH[6S?J]?;MKQ6:&@+YZ=;7\0
MP#C+NIB\J0S?OI:F`$>#T][96WN>ZW7%*,#%PL,J.D3=Z55U@'*5J'4U;-VY
MVL$Z&^!<:@K.X'5GJPXVF(#8M::U[I8]Z+8[`"&address@hidden::PK
M1VMG_:YY0U;V>3U/_XC]7[:XCP\`81Q[5VAQ^$7SY*>H]_OMZAC@:G;^7&&M
address@hidden(SKUJ<I&:W^6ITA,`V7F@&-6X`,address@hidden
M=C+![PM8^SMU-V7:N9Q+Y]DZ'1Z``5U]WND&+P"R,[70_&Q0$9\`R,[4^'RL
M'8;P^1O<address@hidden@].S<address@hidden,`V;F,SYT$%9P`!&9_)P`!%:W?INO_=A]`!SBT
M8%HD[^Z5-]O5K`"$]]0$`%"address@hidden:#N3`W.A]NS`,C.0\$I/@&0G0!`
MDI<F`*C&FR+JSO5!8&0`(address@hidden/C3P!DYV98;@6GHA,`V;D>GXL24\4)P#C.
MG&>address@hidden(2DT`9"<`L,G9"address@hidden@*`[`0`V0D`LA,`D)T`(#L!
M0'8"@.P$`-D)`+(3`)"=`"`[`4!V`H#L!`#9"0#(3@"address@hidden@*`[`0`
MV0D`R$X`D)T`(#L!0'8"@.P$`-D)`,A.`"CG'VM-<W6YULVM````!W1)344'
6U`H(address@hidden)14Y$KD)@@@``
`
end