bug#43572: Feature request: make it possible to choose whether the first lines of the minibuffer should be displayed instead of the last ones

[Gregory Heytings]

> Really?  Despite the `-Q`?  Is it using a proportional font?
> Oh, wait, is it because you're running that Emacs session in a tty rather than 
> in a GUI?

Yes, yes, no, no ;-)

> How many columns wide is the frame?

167, Sir! ;-)

> > No, if you look at the patch its value is reset to nil whenever the 
> > minibuffer is entered.
>
> That still leaves the non-minibuffer uses of the mini window (i.e. the 
> echo area).
>
> And of course, that will also result in the use of an incorrect value 
> when you exit a *nested* minibuffer (unless both minibuffers were using 
> the same value).

Thank you very much for the pointers, indeed I completely forgot about 
these cases.  See the attached corrected patch, in which they are dealt 
with.  I believe start_display_at_beginning_of_minibuffer how has the 
value it should have whenever resize_mini_window() is called.

> > > I don't have a patch to suggest, but I think ideally, I'd want clients 
> > > like icomplete to tell the redisplay either something like "please 
> > > display as much as possible of *this* chunk of text" or maybe "feel 
> > > free not to display all of this overlay, it's not super important".
> >
> > Yes, that's the point.  The patch I proposed tells redisplay "please 
> > display as much as possible of the text between BOB and point", when 
> > the current behavior tells redisplay "please display as much as 
> > possible of the text between point and EOB".  Something more 
> > fine-grained would of course be possible, but I don't think it is a 
> > good idea to implement a feature when there is no clear need for it.
>
> I think what I was getting at is that this "request" should come from 
> the minibuffer's text rather than from a variable.

If this were possible, it would be even better indeed.  An "importance" 
text property, which would inform redisplay (?) of the relative importance 
of the parts of the buffer.  But implementing this is several orders of 
magnitude harder than implementing my proposal.

start-display-at-beginning-of-minibuffer.patch
Description: Text Data