[Axiom-developer] [#112 Returned type of compiled function]

[wyscc]

Changes 
http://page.axiom-developer.org/zope/mathaction/112ReturnedTypeOfCompiledFunction/diff
--

??changed:
-
This following shows that functions in Axiom have types and a domain for 
functions may be associated with an identifier.

\begin{axiom}
dom:=(INT->INT)
f:dom
f x == x-1
\end{axiom}

However, when the function is compiled, the returned type displayed may not 
agree with its declared type or even its apparent compiled type and depends on 
the input!

\begin{axiom}
f 3
f(-3)
\end{axiom}

This has nothing to do with the declaration of <code>f</code>.

\begin{axiom}
f(x:INT):INT==x-1
f(3)
f(-3)
\end{axiom}

Not even:

\begin{axiom}
f(x:INT):INT==(x-1)::INT
f(3)
f(-3)
\end{axiom}
Or even:

\begin{axiom}
g(x:INT):NNI == 2^(sign(x)*x)::NNI
g 3
\end{axiom}

The following deliberate "error" shows the Interpreter always assumes 
<code>3</code> is of type <code>PositiveInteger</code>.

\begin{axiom}
f 3
f -3
\end{axiom}


Compare the type returned below for <code>g 1</code>, the retraction to 
<code>PositiveInteger</code> is not done.

\begin{axiom}
g(x:INT): FRAC INT == 1/x
g 1
\end{axiom}

The difference may perhaps be due to the fact that the data structure of 
<code>FRAC INT</code> is very different from <code>INT</code>, whereas the data 
structure of <code>INT</code> is identical to that of <code>PI</code>. So the 
explanation that the reason <code>1/1</code> is not retracted because 
<code>retract</code> is not always possible is not the full story.

--
forwarded from http://page.axiom-developer.org/zope/mathaction/address@hidden