sipwitch-devel
[Top][All Lists]
Advanced

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: [Sipwitch-devel] My testing setup


From: Gernot Super
Subject: Re: [Sipwitch-devel] My testing setup
Date: Tue, 28 Feb 2012 10:20:27 +0100
User-agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; U; Linux i686; en-US; rv:1.9.2.24) Gecko/20111114 Icedove/3.1.16

@Steve Murphy: Tried another port, makes no difference.

@David Sugar:

Well, i don't know if that helps, but i had installed ejabberd and used the same dyndns address and i was able to connect two jitsi clients...there had been a problem with ICE though.. Since the ports on the router were forwarded and my router supports hairpinning (as i read on the mailing list, thanks Steve Murphy), i expected everything should work.

@ALL

I apologize for my rudeness before, i 'RTFM' and the mailing lists again (e.g. https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/sipwitch-devel/2011-09/msg00003.html) and i see this is a WIP with very few people actually working on it. Seems what i'm trying to archieve isn't possible at this stage of development.

One hint i have for you too:

Since some articles on the net (https://www.gnu.org/software/sipwitch/) and your homepage are quite misleading in that regard that SIP WITCH isn't ready for production use or as an skype alternative, you could easily change that on the front page of your website. Additionally adding some documentation before progressing with the actual code could not hurt too - the better documented, the more ppl are attracted imo.

Good luck with all your plans and wishes for 2012,

greets Gernot

Am 28.02.2012 09:39, schrieb David Sugar:
Since you are attempting to "connect" to the publicly appearing routing
address, sip.dyndns.org, from the external pc, where will it attempt to
connect to?  It sounds like it would try to connect to the public
appearing address of your nat/router box.  SIP Witch sits inside your
network.  The fact that sipwitch shows no activity I think indicates
indeed no sip packets were received by it, though this can be confirmed
with wireshark.  The question is what happened at the router, did they
even arrive there?  Does it indeed forward UDP ports successfully?

On 02/27/2012 09:35 AM, Gernot Super wrote:
System: Debian Squeeze with the latest sipwitch behind router(ports
5060,5061 forwarded), sip.dyndns.org, user1 running on local pc where
sipwitch server is installed, user2 external, Clients: Jitsi (latest
beta nightly)


/etc/sipwitch.conf:

<?xml version="1.0"?>
<sipwitch>
<provision>
<user id="user1">
<secret>user1</secret>  <extension>201</extension>  <display>USER1 - Jitsi
at local pc where sipwitch server is running</display>
</user>
<user id="user2">
<secret>user2</secret>  <extension>202</extension>  <display>USER2 - Jitsi
- external via usb-key</display>
</user>
</provision>
<access>
<local>192.168.0.0/24</local>
</access>
<stack>
<!--
<localnames>sip.dyndns.org</localnames>
-->
<!--
<restricted>local</restricted>
<trusted>local</trusted>
-->
<mapped>200</mapped>
<threading>2</threading>
<interface>*</interface>
<dumping>false</dumping>
<!--
<peering>sip.dyndns.org</peering>
-->
<system>system</system>
<anon>anonymous</anon>
</stack>
<timers>
<!-- ring every 4 seconds -->
<ring>4</ring>
<!-- call forward no answer after x rings -->
<cfna>4</cfna>
<!-- call reset to clear cid in stack, 6 seconds -->
<reset>6</reset>
</timers>
<registry>
<prefix>200</prefix>
<range>100</range>
<keysize>77</keysize>
<mapped>200</mapped>
<realm>output from 'sipwitch realm'</realm>
</registry>
<!--
<templates>
<user>
<secret>123</secret>
<forwarding>
<busy>voicemail</busy>
<na>voicemail</na>
</forwarding>
</user>
<admin>
<forwarding>
<busy>operator</busy>
<na>operator</na>
</forwarding>
</admin>
</templates>
-->
<routing>
</routing>
</sipwitch>

Since debian started sipwitch after installation i had to stop it first.
Afterwards i edited the configuration file and started sipwitch with
sipw -x9 -f.
Then executed jitsi on the same pc, added address@hidden and
password - user1 was recognised from the server with the external
dyndns-IP, registered and activated. Jitsi says user1 is online.

So far so good. Fired up another pc, internet-connection with usb-key,
started jisti, added address@hidden -->  Jitsi: Could  not connect.
-->  sipwitch: no sign of connection
Both logfiles not informative :-(

ANY help would be very appreciated.





reply via email to

[Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread]