Codeberg DOES pass that criteria I think. There are no
third-party requests, they actually care about this sort of thing.
I know that some extreme sticklers found some reason to complain
about Codeberg and cloudflare something related to
https://blog.codeberg.org/on-the-cloudflare-tor-takedown.html or
whatever, I don't know. Some few people got mad about something.
But when I go to Codeberg, the important thing is I see zero
requests to any other domains. Whatever offloading they do (if
any), it does not happen on the client side.
On Tue, 16 Apr 2024 15:14:29 -0400 bill-auger wrote:
savannah and notabug would meet that criteria, and gitlab would not
... also probably codeberg would not - most websites offload some work to
third-parties - i dont think the cloudfare thing is much different than relying
on third-parties to deliver scripts - regardless of what the third-party does
(as long sa it is libre), "relying on third-parties" is the essential problem;
and probably codeberg does that
if you are looking for a new criteria which would penalize gitlab but not
codeberg, i dont think there is any meaningful criteria which would distinguish
them, other than the one which got gitlab demoted a few years ago