Re: [Qemu-devel] [PATCH] [RESEND2] Qemu unmaintained?

[Amit Shah]

On (Thu) Sep 10 2009 [09:12:21], Anthony Liguori wrote:
>
> Yeah, I tried that without a lot of success.  Basically, my work flow is  
> the following:
>
> 1) Mail client filters things that look like patches into a folder
> 2) I do a once through to remove obvious dups or non-patches
> 3) I have some scripts that pull patches into an mbox format.  They are  
> smart about identifying threads and trying to find a sane sort order.
> 4) I have more scripts that let me split the mbox into smaller mboxes.   
> This is because git am is not very forgiving and having to do a git am  
> --abort can lead to a lot of wasted effort if the mbox has 100+ patches
> 5) I git am the smaller mboxes into staging
> 6) I push to staging
> 7) I do a build check, and fix errors, and push to staging
> 8) I start the testing cycle, removing patches based on testing results  
> and pushing to staging
> 9) I manually review each patch that's survived testing
> 10) I do final build/test, then push to master

Obviously there's a lot of manual intervention and can get you
overloaded. But if some developer knows that his patch is in some queue
or getting some consideration, he'll rest easier than to check if his
patch has made it either to master or to some staging queue somewhere.
If it can't be automated, it sadly has to drop back to manual acking.

> And commit mails are sent whenever something goes to master.  So someone  
> should get a mail when a patch goes to master or when I reject it.  To  
> me, the area to optimize is reducing the time things are spent in  
> staging.  I don't think people really need visibility into staging.

Absolutely. I think the trend has been anywhere from 2 to 4 weeks for
patches landing on the list to the master tree. Also, this results in
delays for important patches to get to the master tree because they're
delayed behind a huge pile of other patches. Avi has mentioned this
before but I don't know if there was any plan to address it.

                Amit