Re: Parallel CueVoice with "too early" a clef change

[Menu Jacques]

Hello David,

Fine, you hit the point, and the following code avoids the non-appearing notes 
problem:

% Music to be used by CueDuring has to start at the same point in time
% as the music that incorporates it!

HautboisAvantChiffreSept = \relative gis' {
  \voiceOne
  %  \tweak staff-position #-1 r4
  R2 |
  \tweak staff-position #-1 r4
  gis8 \mf \< ( a |
  b [ cis d e ] |
  fis2 -> ) \! ~ |
  fis4 e8 ( d |
  d4 cis ) |
  r8 cis ( [ bis cis ]  |
  e [ d b fis ] |
  fis4 gis |
  gis4
  %a8 )
  %s |
}
\addQuote "HautboisAvantChiffreSept" { \HautboisAvantChiffreSept }

My original problem can be avoided for the time being by preventing Cue’d and 
Cue’ing musics to sound in parallel at any given point, since the effect of 
that is not clearly defined in the docs.

Thanks to all!

JM

> Le 9 nov. 2015 à 18:59, David Wright <address@hidden> a écrit :
> 
> On Mon 09 Nov 2015 at 17:00:51 (+0100), Menu Jacques wrote:
>> Hello David,
>> 
>> The docs say that the part that « receives » a Cue is usually made of rests, 
>> but not what happens if they contain actual notes.
>> Removing the last eight in the Cue avoids the problem, of course.
>> 
>> I tried with cueDuringWithClef, but then the four first eights at the 
>> beginning of the cue’d music don’t appear, even though the examples in the 
>> docs work fine. 
>> That beats me, see second part of the attached files.
> 
> OK, I've looked quickly at the notation manual and there's a lot to
> get one's head around. However, I'm hoping that there's a connection
> between QuoteDuring and CueDuring. I think your problem has to do with
> the R2 at the beginning of Basson. While that R2 is passing by, you're
> not quoting the Hautbois, but it's first two bars are still being
> consumed, because its "clock" runs from the same instant as the
> Basson clock. to understand this, look carefully at page 196 in
> Notation Manual (2.18.2) and see where the "a4 gis g gis" in the
> flute part have gone.
> 
> In other words, \quoteDuring #"flute" { s1 } parachutes in "s1-duration"
> of flute, but the section parachuted in is the *corresponding* time
> interval in the flute part, not the *first* bar of the flute part. The
> clocks of the two parts are running together the whole time.
> 
> I'm expecting Cue... to behave as Quote...
> 
> Cheers,
> David.