Re: To many colliding ...

[Urs Liska]

Am 29. Oktober 2014 06:46:47 MEZ, schrieb Keith OHara <address@hidden>:
>> From: "Dr. Bernhard Kleine" <bernhard.kleine <at> gmx.net>
>> I have added a file which shows the warning. It compiles but I would
>like 
>> to know about the warning.
> 
>LilyPond complains when two voices have the same stem direction and no 
>indication of which note-head to shift horizontally (in the style of 
>Bach-era polyphony) to avoid the appearance of a chord.
>
>If you want the appearance of a chord, then ignore the warning.
>Be aware, though, that LilyPond is still interpreting your input as 
>two voices, which just happen to overlap in print.  If the two voices
>have eighth notes, there will be two flags, which look ugly in the
>same direction. (Maybe the warning could help to remind people to check
>
>for this?)
>
>If you want LilyPond to make a true chord, you can say <h g'>2 in one 
>of the two voices.
>
>Trevor Daniels <t.daniels <at> treda.co.uk> writes:
>> It's due to the use of \stemUp and \stemDown commands. 
>> Try to code your score without using them by assigning the notes to
>> correct voices. 
>
>Well, in the example the <<\\>> assigned default voices, but then 
>there was some reason for wanting the \stemUp or \stemDown overrides. 
>Using instead \voiceOne, bzw. \voiceTwo, is usually a good idea,
>but in the example given an explicit \voiceTwo would ask for two voices
>
>both in \voiceTwo and LilyPond gives a warning.
>
>It became clear that this warning did more harm than good.  Just one
>month ago, we restricted it.  Now when we explicitly ask for \stemDown
>or \voiceTwo on both voices, LilyPond sets the notes in the same column
>without complaint.
>
>Phil Holmes <mail <at> philholmes.net> writes:
>> GNU LilyPond 2.19.14
>> Success: compilation successfully completed
>
>Version 2.19.14 is the first 'development' (for testing) version where 
>this warning has been removed.
>

Ah, that's why ...
Thanks for the explanation.

Urs
>
>_______________________________________________
>lilypond-user mailing list
>address@hidden
>https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user