Re: Mandatory or a cautionary accidental?

[Urs Liska]

Hi David, Christ and Simon,

thanks for your opinion.
Obviously it boils down to the statement that leaving the reminder sharp for the gis' is impractical/impolite but not wrong.
See the actual situation in the attached image. The gis' is on the third beat in the lower voice of the right hand.
It is clear to me that there _has_ to be a sharp, the question is only if it will be a cautionary or a mandatory accidental.
And resulting from your opinions I will make it a cautionary one.

Best
Urs

Am 22.10.2013 08:42, schrieb Urs Liska:

In the following situation is the sharp in gis' a mandatory or a cautionary accidental:

{

  \key a \major

  g'1 ~ 

  \break

  g'2 gis'

}

?

Embarassingly I'm not sure about that right now but have to know.
The original edition I'm copying omits the reminder flat after the line break and the sharp at the gis,
and I've to know how to deal with the situation.

Thanks for opinions or knowledge
Urs

_______________________________________________
lilypond-user mailing list
address@hidden
https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user

04-1-missing-cautionary-accidental.png
Description: PNG image