[Top][All Lists]
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?)
From: |
Reinhold Kainhofer |
Subject: |
Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?) |
Date: |
Thu, 25 Aug 2011 00:01:49 +0200 |
User-agent: |
KMail/1.13.6 (Linux/2.6.38-10-generic; KDE/4.7.0; i686; ; ) |
Am Wednesday, 24. August 2011, 23:33:02 schrieb Michael Ellis:
> On Wed, Aug 24, 2011 at 5:14 PM, Jan Nieuwenhuizen <address@hidden> wrote:
> > It's only about an hour of work (see below) to convert a simple and
> > prepared .ly score to musicxml, see below.
>
> That sounds encouraging. So how far away are we from being able to handle
> a more realistic score, say a string quartet or a 4-part choral score with
> with lyrics and piano reduction?
I don't think it's that easy, in particular if you want to get output that you
can send to a publisher without being thrown out of the office...
Jan, you can take a look at the ~100 MusicXML files in
input/regression/musicxml/ and at the corresponding output of musicxml2ly.
The current approach is to modify the source file to add a \convertToMusicXML
(or some similarly named function) to the music expression that you want to
convert.
However, I see several problems with this approach, which I might discuss
separately. In short, the only way to make it extendable for the future (so
that one day we can also export the layout) is to handle (MusicXML) export
similar to MIDI generation, namely via translators that collect all events and
all settings as they appear in the score.
Cheers,
Reinhold
--
------------------------------------------------------------------
Reinhold Kainhofer, address@hidden, http://reinhold.kainhofer.com/
* Financial & Actuarial Math., Vienna Univ. of Technology, Austria
* http://www.fam.tuwien.ac.at/, DVR: 0005886
* LilyPond, Music typesetting, http://www.lilypond.org
- Re: Lilypond lobbying?, (continued)
- Re: Lilypond lobbying?, Kieren MacMillan, 2011/08/18
- MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?), Pierre THIERRY, 2011/08/22
- Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?), Kieren MacMillan, 2011/08/23
- Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?), Michael Ellis, 2011/08/23
- Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?), Jonathan Kulp, 2011/08/23
- Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?), Christ van Willegen, 2011/08/24
- Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?), Federico Bruni, 2011/08/24
- Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?), Pierre THIERRY, 2011/08/24
- Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?), Jan Nieuwenhuizen, 2011/08/24
- Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?), Michael Ellis, 2011/08/24
- Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?),
Reinhold Kainhofer <=
- Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?), Kieren MacMillan, 2011/08/24
- Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?), Michael Ellis, 2011/08/24
- Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?), Carl Sorensen, 2011/08/24
- Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?), Urs Liska, 2011/08/24
- Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?), Kieren MacMillan, 2011/08/24
- Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?), Kieren MacMillan, 2011/08/24
- Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?), Carl Sorensen, 2011/08/24
- Message not available
- Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?), Kieren MacMillan, 2011/08/24
- Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?), Martin Tarenskeen, 2011/08/25
- Re: MusicXML exporter (was Re: Lilypond lobbying?), Martin Tarenskeen, 2011/08/25