|
From: | Phil Holmes |
Subject: | Re: Odd output |
Date: | Fri, 10 Dec 2010 17:36:26 -0000 |
As I replied in my direct reply - because it's not
right. I asked a friend who teaches music about the Mikado problem I had
and he said:
"Key- C
major Bass note pedals - C-G C-G etc. Chord in Bar 1 G7 (G B D Fnat = dominant 7th); Chord in Bar 2 C major (CEG) Each bar has a melody which uses AGF# G with the F# as a chromatical altered note (lower auxiliary between the 2 Gs) and therefore clashes (to create interest) with both chords. Each sounds fine on their own but looks illogical as a whole. If you can convince LilyPond that the accidentals are in different voices in the piano part then I would hope it would work. You could but shouldn't use a Gb not a F# as the first chordsis a G chord." Note his final comment - could use a Gb but shouldn't. -- Phil Holmes
|
[Prev in Thread] | Current Thread | [Next in Thread] |