Re: Discrepancy in documentation,

[Simon Bailey]

hi,

On Dec 15, 2008, at 8:48 PM, Trevor Daniels wrote:
> I've fixed the original error identified by David, added the
> default Dominant thirteenth, and replaced some TODOs with what
> I hope are correct chord descriptions.  On this latter point
> could you please check I've done this correctly, as my knowledge
> of interval naming conventions is not as reliable as I'd like.
> The changes should appear on the kainhofer server on Tuesday.


minor nitpick, which is probably my fault:

we have a half-diminished seventh with the modifier "dim5m7" and a  
minor-major seventh with the modifier "maj7m5". i think that may be a  
bit confusing.

but just while testing, i found out that the order of the modifier  
constructs is important. this is even more confusing – at least to me.  
(either that or i need more coffee). is there really a difference  
between a minor triad with added major 7th or a major 7th with a minor  
triad?

\chordmode {
c1:maj7m5 c:m5maj7 c:dim5m7 c:m7dim5
}

gives the attached png.

that's the only issue i have, everything else looks correct. otherwise  
thanks to trevor for the prompt change.

regards,
sb
--
Simon Bailey
Oompa Loompa of Science
+43 699 190 631 25