Re: engraving question

[Mark Knoop]

Mark Knoop wrote:
> Joe Neeman wrote:
>> I'm trying to tweak the spacing code, and I've come across a case where I'm 
>> not sure what to do. In the attached example, I have a note followed by a 
>> clef change followed by a bar line. Given that the clef fits in the space 
>> that would be there anyway, should it take up extra space? Any strong 
>> opinions (they will be regarded more highly if they come with references, of 
>> course)?
> 
> I would say that no extra space should be added - see ex0.png. I've also
> included a case where the engraver has actually moved a rest to the left
> to fit a clef change - ex1.png - perhaps in order to keep the quavers
> looking even. Both these are from the Henle edition of the Beethoven
> Sonatas for Piano and Cello.

One more from Brahms op 118 - Dover edition (reproduction of Breitkopf &
Härtel, 1927).

-- 
Mark Knoop