lilypond-user
[Top][All Lists]
Advanced

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: New slur/tie behaviour


From: Werner LEMBERG
Subject: Re: New slur/tie behaviour
Date: Mon, 05 Sep 2005 22:08:24 +0200 (CEST)

> Well, AFAIK engraving conventions are:
> 
>    * outer ties point outward
>    * double directions for seconds
>    * direction otherwise determined by vertical position.

This is correct, but doesn't work in cluster-like chords.

Here are my rules again for reference:

  sequentially from top to bottom:

    + The topmost tie is always `up'.

    + If there is a vertical gap to the last note above larger
      than or equal to a fifth (or sixth?), the tie is `up',
      otherwise it is `down'.

    + The bottommost tie is always `down'.

The current behaviour of lilypond (CVS version 2005-09-01) is
attached.


    Werner


======================================================================


begin 644 ties.png
MB5!.1PT*&@address@hidden&,```"/"`,```!INN;<````!&=!34$``+&/
M"_QA!0```4=03%1%`````0$!`@("`P,address@hidden&!P<'"`@("0D)"@H*
M"PL+#`P,address@hidden/$!`0$1$1$A(2$Q,3%!04%145%A86%Q<7&address@hidden&1D9
M&AH:&QL;'!P<'1T='AX>'Q\?("`@(B(B)B8F*"@H*2DI*BHJ+"PL+2TM+BXN
M,#`P,C(R,S,S-C8V-S<address@hidden/CX^/S\_0$!`04%!1$1$2DI*2TM+
M4%!04E)24U-355555SA`6%A865E97%Q<8&address@hidden:&AH;6UM;V]O<'!P
M<6IA<G)R='1T=W=W>'address@hidden&!B(B(BHJ*C8V-CX^/E)24F9F9GY^?
MI*2DIJ:FJJJJKZ^OL[.SM;6UN[N[P&!WP,#`PL+"Q\?'S,S,S<"PT[6UV=G9
MW=W=W]_?Y>address@hidden"YT15AT4V]F='=A<F4`
address@hidden<VEO;B`S+C$P82UJ=6UB;T9I>"!O9B`R,#`U,#0Q,address@hidden
M241!5'C:[9WM<]M&DL8[D;VB14JG1%&T2D3+UBH7![M4&.E(VT%%YE*U+-Y<
MM-#ZL"G<%BI;^`!7H8K__^<#0)#$@'@address@hidden@9#]/52)9E!K-`>;'>>GNH1D$
M05!U(address@hidden&address@hidden,9`$`3&address@hidden
M!($Q$`2!,1`$06`,address@hidden&`-!$`3&0!`$QD`0!,9`$`2!
M,address@hidden($Q4[05!$'5,:9+7306!$%5,:9+1!C)0!!4$6.F%`BM!4%0-8P)
M$8/address@hidden"F.V<,9DL0!%7"&%H([05]BG(O786V+'6._5FAK>O_W2)CHF',
M%`,9Z-.43;;"+L<::NN7+3)F,8:address@hidden@C'K&K#:5P!@(C`%CU#.FNUR)
M02`>!,:`,=4P9KKX#L];X^69GCIC3;5E.6#,1\28U882&/,89"KL$'9C;;$Z
MFQ2,J9XQTR5CL+/address@hidden;&K&9-6)`!8\`8,address@hidden@#QH`Q%3)F
M"L:`,6`,&%,#8SZ9O,CAM4);^V`,&`/&@#&\M!<*;=6]%P?&@#&/C3'=V+82
M&`/&@address@hidden&6,^73*.X`Q8`P8LP7&address@hidden(SW^+G0-,9LI4D_8L9\$&7,
M`T$0!&VLSX3',0])T6'P_Y\"*X</2G5PIL[6EU^JLW6FTA:IL/(#"3?5F,;*
MG&^NK?^2MO&:2+'KX[G^EO];"EROQM8/<G__!;5*SY5FB\(.ZJ=*+S2%ME3.
M;QHW5_J%M.W,23[>N=*#^..<address@hidden;9VYXK.18;:9KVQZ5;
M?_3_-4QU3':N=$Y[Y1D3+LATJZ@:#L:`,8^7,0X;address@hidden;8(QG
M,NT\9V)SI#'3;address@hidden;*JGG"\:`,8^3,9[YNC7OJQ<#QFQ?W`*RZ__`9..;
MT_GO'(^L>AGC&C]&S.N-F3]J"12\CU",C7L1"U_>address@hidden;P$S`&C'F$
MC''9RZ`[7/J=MW!KRK7-<4B:@>address@hidden(#.N]=)GQ&M1F$V&P53O..)RS&&
MMU4;8[K4K>98`C`&C'ETC/'N_*[P/;,VJ+CEFN,SOS>;U3!&YXX-\2:A>V)M
address@hidden>4O&Z.6/()%CS+2JXY7`&##FL3'F?8N>EZGHY[)]>F&K9XP56V/Q
M?V(=TG-K(_>L/K7>SQF3L%4_8RI((P!CP)C'Q1CG);TP2U[08_]!0T\Q8^)8
MH)DW\`&X>6N^H)[K,X:W5?=Z3$4AOF`,&/.X&#,Y,R4NZ;%36S%CN+VBF7-J
ME+)address@hidden&UQ2,Q/GI\/#P)^&X.<3@(0;OXXG!VT+<W-<<%^1L
M'<K9VB`&#[D$$`25T.=EYTI3\:'3LD[>M"LVU,)<:4MSI3!.PF1&^-5MWES)
MR7=K.W,address@hidden@366E]_'MVI)8CXFN*;#B&W=-##)@3*V,<7VL7&NIC]2)
M=L=L9[N,<2QVJVG),%EMPM9QLP7&Q/JB+LL82PX,>B86W(DKO#9D_%^^K?H8
M,X^,$3GJ.DXBP<J_8$Q=C''address@hidden'O>8LPW&.*QWGCL,?SDTG*TR
M)MX791DCMW\SHVPLN.V.8,-89_1/address@hidden@(,0)'77=C(32B?H(QM3#&OHLZ
M<"^,>\\8X8S[\\CWUNM5^$<MC+'>[LWCWOOC>address@hidden'CG;(TQOY)"
MQLAU9PX+?TGXY&KTW!*8B][0D9VT]97<^RO-F,address@hidden<>9)B(address@hidden/6,
ML89!#SX=FR*T<&W6#X<-4>![!8RQ^&!U:address@hidden@L(N#>RXXRQ=(DN
M+\08/;B"address@hidden;%OU)BC'address@hidden"/>73?HLXX%S,..UO&]L;57[-5
M"V.62S'3HKG/=(TQ73!F^XRQM9`O[D8P8-_3//2S`L;PBYUNZ)address@hidden
M6V_)&+F%4P'&U+"V:FU,*IXQ*<TT\JG='K&T17//-MB)_V=#.\76=G(B8^`H
M:MDNQC'-8XS[FFCLEKB<9Y[1F:V>,?S":address@hidden>,D5V$+69,QF)%
MJ:OII(A75,address@hidden;;UR^5<N`F,B;&B:++$94UB/:81
MC#'VRA%F_IP^I[YJQO`+I\X)Z9N[YU.FY_J,D5Z$+60,*40,J4(,9\G*7);R
MS,FKM.N=W\:KV7!MN!W&3&-3GJ+)$M]D7;'L)C"F4L9,1J[,-<V^JY8QB853
M<VB7],NQZ0U5S9A&CF(X4U9!7H)C,A;L'>Y3\/\),^SL^9M>:_V86'1Q/*:8
MZ#"OFF^I`&3D$GQ2N02<7FW;5D$NP3M^[WSQS;LRE^)M_:=<$\3_6C8O83'6
M>?6NUGJ^R"6`(*B>7(+N8C0WC1N:BLR51.<W!1,`-XQU-]A<X3^<1LV5[(6<
MILV5U`2^J[!EJ9MR*+55,%?B+R$W9119IRUGN$'G*Y5:CUD09<HW4;=XS5>:
M,8[-[K3C=%KN::address@hidden@@)O]BW3-MP"RG$8Q1%?BNP):>B05+?+G(F2_=
MZ`H1LPEC?O6;@6Y*<<9C'4-PG?9394S:FGA7C#$E]ZY=<WC"'2&A:3>address@hidden
MZ/&1[WL:'_9>$V,<IK63,?FGB7A\KA#]-ABC+/!=WE;.PJG=[C!/K)]2Q\VW
MI9XQ\;75`+7F7HE=,(\=T,3;9)WVTV+,-,))%%'7G?^7-5V:)AG3+1.#MXAZ
M/^V/F9F1>1L45A_,:=-ZNPI[KX,address@hidden>79O8,195HC]?A;address@hidden'J`M^E
M;address@hidden>N1J?%92L]<Y\&7M+6MZ6#V$3WE6)O.IPR>B.BT497<UB'+IV$
M+3`F,3*9SE:YCMUY3D'6E"CYPN8Q>$X8]7XF&I4:A;U?FI4Q)@K^7KAWNS>/
M>B]PS[&"6&TZGGAQQEB<K6H8,X^LMQ4&OLL&T?/K)_9:(]RWB-[D8<8SW_A#
M5FO=%I-L4('XF%6B0K2%[P2?;#?,$;'NFN,.4=M<LP7&)address@hidden&\Y$$3+3K(%,
MEW]ANFD,GG=+=+)AU+O/F9X_:+`K88S%?5(&,:F^>X+5F%WS33L,2(T88\F.
address@hidden"%5ED0O5ZT<address@hidden'DO)address@hidden>Y4[KBA=,RM3;MT-W.D!DY
MGS2VQ<+C3EJ#U,<%C$EES&*D$I]"I0YDNAL-8^*,F;1*+ZKMT[6KGC$Z7^Y]
M<_?,YV$X?L`872(_19`QELJH5&7A9R*;,];M8N5M$.P>&N$VXD";Q[WOW3KI
MMK9V+H%SOXB5N>BOMCL7VY]O%DN&Q[=6'5QX_(SISN*E8**Z4]VL#S0NT'>S
M.%_WA`:EMP<address@hidden;ZTW/[9B0YEG-`D8HV`)address@hidden&CSE9R<R;C!MKL
M^BCEM-0!=TH0;VNK9[A9[.UE=IC(F<9,IR8N//XUW^[JRVR5LI0Y:%[5VA0\
M*&7%F)%4`(+'5#-&YQDS,4OZ=>\S1J?J&=/(4<SZYDQ>6]G^,&`T+YPU8NMQ
M[PE;address@hidden&+J&[P4:address@hidden>`&/6?O+A:B&BW=B7JZMOHF_\%OWF*E7?
M[/JO[>YFOI[4;OM*F79WU=EJ/^5ZEYRM1/FY<E:^HD[>R_PHX$#J8A<*;5TM
MQR175]_1=W)WA;/UK?1-/A>_L=*N<V_CVX;:^DJR`])34<;\=K00T4[LR]'1
ML^B;':)G1UEZMK.SD_UJ0CM/PR^[(9KVCZ2TLZ/`UG[PU[3[]+-X-]N5LY68
M`)33+CW)>YF_QL&^3"/L*K0560M;\(`.Y.XP9^O9D:SVQ&^&O.OQ>_6LH;9V
M)address@hidden/M&<:5%"L[OXN:)C:<.YDB4=Z3!;[BM)VM+5[<QDV"K['O/G
M2E9R;;5TOK6K-HB^<,)1VM;VYTJ-F-\\]CC?6<22)5.(address@hidden/;)NMI
address@hidden"X%AIQ*93TF>H2P-QGDV"H=$+<!8_P.89?<H[-OR!%<
address@hidden:6N.L:D?\B[QNW+M#[:TIB5S1BY`4-\X/address@hidden(DY
MV$HZH'NURZ9":[[Q45<4^#YP-KV&,Z`]<Z-U6C`&C)%DS&Q5!"_:QI[&?ZJ"
M,7H:%Z)address@hidden($511^8C(address@hidden:2"O8A]0M->F:?SIRU
M4<S"address@hidden&6&N![W=$HTT"&EUSE"PDK>.\:S"F<L8LEV*FW>F2,2JF2E$@
M^(N7ZPL?[FB/J#,R[+39250W_\1(VB+]Q=<*ZZ2V9\F*]T$8<B<OSM<address@hidden
MK)=[C^)C=*GEIL+XF%5)^47@>]!0WS.AJUI!E7#J._$1G:Z>"V`,&),V6XJ/
M6<*PEZG\,&;YJ=O^8FTF814>W1"FL%PX:U.<ML+,FK18&R>H]TX]MDX_GWSA
M&.MHXJ0M[*AX`,K4VG2,\ZAPM&EGL-$+SE4*AX?GAE,Y%\`8,"8=,EV.,5.2
M7HW)*6[J#>A4(-S-8U$R4&9\JYQ37V3E74?UWCN:-M##0/+!0%O4>address@hidden
MMGGVB;NH4.^CIA>&address@hidden,address@hidden(address@hidden@#QE3.&"X]*>!+=8@)NFB'
M!#=PW!L:address@hidden>73_&address@hidden<X(:WM>4SW/RARD0[RHI[/](FF8,<
M,`:,J84Q44)address@hidden/D#CP6/B:]26F9B%/address@hidden/L\JK(,7+$&S<address@hidden
M,%-...1L->*\ZZ#B!&.3UUJDUQ,F$O<.QH`Q%3#F0UJ4\"KF53YDF=N+CL6'
MR]K:D;-U%`N:;TN^3<address@hidden"KPO;FVD$OP4>02)%,$=A;)!-+QX$L]
MG?][IURX^C[/&"E;4>S__"^?RN8EQ&U1\B=EU'KRAPT#W_=W)?(@FF_KF;2M
address@hidden/?GL:>FY4ORWY8/ON*G2UT6Y!&YTC&80(address@hidden@
MEV`AK<B6%_.K8`%)38VJC><D>6<)address@hidden;*OUR5GXY(G,E7>7.G;SK
MII#K,Y6N%]J*_#+2.]#Z7*F*)MTJ8_2<7(address@hidden)LN[_'9_QS]N2SB7@&9/M
MU]MD"/+%6\/.98Q\C:H-.T3660*.>:<EG#^^SLG1J.N,`\><:'N\7VUMDN<7
M4^:7K.O69J[/>-=)EC%9MES?K^/DB1Z3G,(V/F,LQ1$76V(,=ZNR<@G<R0HO
M\S7*5<&!RU@<'&=+-I>`9TRZ7RS;KY>&F\489<<$B':(U`MZJWWL\+2'\)#2
M1:\8.1O94NG7S!IF^Y5134[%>==*7+]-NKXZHR*K$!XQB]0Q)MV6/5I&B^TG
M_1J:68RQ:"N,F7;C%>U4)"K%(^M3<PF\>>A8;YRLSNU83`_[]%LK.9"QY',)
M>,:D^66^2O?+M2._KLU4QJBH4;address@hidden"^#=;73V^2E7.#JKG]3C">N7=%
M;:GTR[G;R_?K:)+JUQNJE3&IKD\"UT_Z:\6(_=E)_R3+=9\+I)`Q*;;<2;#G
MT.FO18OZ?H7G9K1NG53&T%88DSB&0$DR9-CENIFY!),P!#Y[2&<%]=Y/HKL:
MAM!WE>02K.R1KJ78,OQ/AK,<address@hidden(*VM6Y+37$'X99-/address@hidden(:S,I2/7
M^'Z9"!'94G(N09$MMT>address@hidden<M^A/*BJ'9-KR
address@hidden'A#X:;[]>EDWA0?5O/M\*8Q/6FBA*N<W()G',Z-8J"9*QQ.TK?FRG+)2BP
MY6IT4GCHA</:=.VE+4A7<>MR5\#Y"]X)G`SD&I=T9*_/:*L\X^"^Y8_<"];,
address@hidden<MZJMPW5+H5V#+%O'+&BWBY-7Z58(QT\09UXH8DY-+8-"^
M4%21J].QD]-"I/#.1<<2"`4@>RP:REA4^:T3<UX/!S$W0H4>S`.:Y-TAQ=6!
MO1[](!3;9CV/AC+*2V:4=GU`SX5<MPM<)[4=R!,M0F+?4,]5[5<9QG03I\]V
MU<V5TKN?2V]$`WWMLYN9RER"?%MT(^J7TS](V/J\CD%]WKD$HU/1YO`1:<_4
M%B#/L<7V#6&_.J9BOV1=%PZP#<Z[SK1%"OVB^5JX:#$U<W]2#V($&3-=_%LR
MD>#WAX>'5_&W<E@>"X&M=XIL?:C2UGG5O<&_X(.J[O>0O$,-L?6;0ELU7R['
M%GTLMA3,E98`E;QSV6?2;'SG?F^HK0^?9]NJ9J)TE.W]QA>\;*BM*X6V:K[<
ME<*'ZUU#;2E8\^TJ6HYY4/BF?F^HK4S&Z%4MQ1PIO.!E0VU=U=NH5W6X7N+A
M>M=06S*,F:=<3Q4-8\+Y#3<Z>_?P,/Y'25O_&/.V7OE#O]]+VOKPL&9K_-]E
M!VL_K_OUVZQ*)>9F]/#P]Y^]<J:\G__^D+#U\"`QATOZ-2QY8(+WR_^L^_6A
MNB;];<WUAY__7=*62M?3_/I725M__=M:9ZRF2:EH>:D;`X[J%=^`F'?E2NC;
M-S14&C^;M'4ON'&0D#NF7LUQO<D5WV#AF?99"<H$A_JZ,address@hidden
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MVKU+[XS;8,QJ`UO5>2<I5?K#$OK[NL#M<TT]R)?K+>-1=74-M&[+#9/address@hidden<
M/L\<address@hidden'S.C?Q:8=9&;;(0Q=D$K09%Z*LJ[S;W'`I2.4Y8Y8GX%?P
M8.Q-JO"KE.NFL.L.NPE<']73I%:0+G<V%OA(<8PPT>O6S>R,VV#,/"]R6NWM
M],P?Y\G,`V:DUC1Q;8,-YJD_/YI>;8^99[X-2_5=W/A^.:E^F2Q*2;HTW%FS
MY-R%>TZG_3&S4E%C6VS<#S-RC^Z<&OV:address@hidden&W&%GY9S6K2^Z7K
MZ760G:7KA[<address@hidden,_QZR;,W&V]M;Q:VXR:<_NL42>>*'\S&(R#NO^#
M>%YZ^[;address@hidden@/36_61+G&1:S^CM8;!.<IZ(-!3XOE:E[43T?7
M&"3\&H1^]6.%'>B".4ULTEB-#+IHCNN>.6S'_-)"O\:#P4W<KY.)77N#4;/N
MGVU.KE,/H:6700'][?EE3:[38R*/M3O3;B9?5F,M-DJ645H4+1HQV]V>7\8H
MX\0$[36SG48WJ7&7K`"U<MW:FNM>CE_7&8/93XTQBW&address@hidden
M7X*/W[SLXERF0)address@hidden/V/6P`RW\"NML;G,:3S,(@B`P!H(@,`:"
M(`B,@2`(C($@"(R!(`@"8R`(`F,@"`)C(`B"P!@(@L`8"(+`&`B"(#`&@B`P
M!H(@,`:"(`B,@2`(C($@"`)C(`@"8R`(`F,@"(+`&`B"P!@(@L`8"((@,`:"
M(#`&@B`P!H(@"(R!(`B,@2`(C($@"`)C(`@"8R`(@L`8"(+`&`B"/@;]/[+=
ER(4(M=IW````!W1)344'U0D%%`8N)address@hidden)14Y$KD)@@@``
`
end




reply via email to

[Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread]