Re: ugly: accidental reminders and ties

[Werner LEMBERG]

>> This code
>>
>>   \relative c' {
>>     <f! fis'>1 ~ | q |
>>     <f fis'>1 ~ | q |
>>   }
>>
>> produces the attached image.  Is this a known issue?
> 
> Well, you presumably complain about the tie positioning.

Yes.  I don't have an older lilypond binary at hand, but I have a gut
feeling that (much?) older versions don't show this.

> I find myself also annoyed with the repetition of the reminder
> accidental.

Indeed, especially since it is very easy to forget this behaviour.a

> Since it is merely a property on a note-event, the normal
> event-based configurable filtering mechanism for repeat chords is
> not enough for stripping this out: one would have to hardwire
> removing cautionary and forced accidentals into copy-repeat-chord.

I vote for fixing that, even if hard-wiring is needed.


    Werner