Re: [Lilypond-auto] Issue 2589 in lilypond: cyclic dependency when tempo, slur, and script present

[lilypond]

Comment #8 on issue 2589 by address@hidden: cyclic dependency when  
tempo, slur, and script present
http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=2589

I get the error message consistently with either version of the crazy  
stuff, or simply  { b( b)->-- }.  I see only scripts passed to  
outside_slur_callback().

This does not look like a bug, but a design issue.

The accent is set to go 'around' slurs, the tenuto is set to go 'inside'  
them, but LilyPond also promises to put the first-specified script closer  
to the note head, accent inside tenuto.  (Same error if the  
accent's 'avoid-slur' is set to 'outside'.)

LilyPond breaks the interdependence between these inconsistent requirements  
in a satisfactory way (for this case).  Maybe the trap for such  
interdependencies should raise a warning rather than an error.