Re: CDN performance

[Meiyo Peng]

Hi Chris,

Chris Marusich <address@hidden> writes:

> Meiyo Peng <address@hidden> writes:
>
>> After careful thought, I realized the new CDN won't benefit China
>> residents as planned. Any popular CDN outside China is significantly
>> throttled by ISP/GFW and the situation is worse every year. A CDN will
>> be a great improvement for western countries but not for many asia
>> countries.
>
> Could you try running the measure_get shell function I included in the
> following email?
>
> https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/guix-devel/2018-12/msg00192.html
>
> For convenience, here is the definition:
>
> measure_get () {
> curl -L \
>      -o /dev/null \
>      -w "url_effective: %{url_effective}\\n\
> http_code: %{http_code}\\n\
> num_connects: %{num_connects}\\n\
> num_redirects: %{num_redirects}\\n\
> remote_ip: %{remote_ip}\\n\
> remote_port: %{remote_port}\\n\
> size_download: %{size_download} B\\n\
> speed_download: %{speed_download} B/s\\n\
> time_appconnect: %{time_appconnect} s\\n\
> time_connect: %{time_connect} s\\n\
> time_namelookup: %{time_namelookup} s\\n\
> time_pretransfer: %{time_pretransfer} s\\n\
> time_redirect: %{time_redirect} s\\n\
> time_starttransfer: %{time_starttransfer} s\\n\
> time_total: %{time_total} s\\n" \
> "$1"
> }
>
> Specifically, I am curious to know what performance you get when you run
>
>   measure_get 
> https://berlin-mirror.marusich.info/nar/gzip/1bq783rbkzv9z9zdhivbvfzhsz2s5yac-linux-libre-4.19
>
> from a computer in China.  Please be sure to run it two times in a row,
> to ensure that CloudFront has cached the object.
>
> CloudFront has edge locations in Hong Kong, so I am curious to know what
> performance improvement, if any, you observe.

Sorry for the delay. My computer was reinstalled with Windows and taken
away by my girlfriend. So I have been waiting for my new computer that I
bought online to arrive. Finally, it arrived yesterday and I
successfully installed Guix on it.

I tested your script several times.

1. Tested today at home. China Unicom home broadband. 50Mb/s.

The result is slow as usual. curl failed once.
berlin-mirror.marusich.info is resolved to Seattle, WA, US.

#+BEGIN_EXAMPLE
  ➜  ~ measure_get 
https://berlin-mirror.marusich.info/nar/gzip/1bq783rbkzv9z9zdhivbvfzhsz2s5yac-linux-libre-4.19
    % Total    % Received % Xferd  Average Speed   Time    Time     Time  
Current
                                   Dload  Upload   Total   Spent    Left  Speed
   55 66.6M   55 36.9M    0     0  17926      0  1:04:59  0:36:02  0:28:57 17733
  url_effective: 
https://berlin-mirror.marusich.info/nar/gzip/1bq783rbkzv9z9zdhivbvfzhsz2s5yac-linux-libre-4.19
  http_code: 200
  num_connects: 1
  num_redirects: 0
  remote_ip: 52.85.158.151
  remote_port: 443
  size_download: 38764357 B
  speed_download: 17926.000 B/s
  time_appconnect: 6.078850 s
  time_connect: 3.006821 s
  time_namelookup: 2.659785 s
  time_pretransfer: 6.079097 s
  time_redirect: 0.000000 s
  time_starttransfer: 9.626001 s
  time_total: 2162.379211 s
  curl: (92) HTTP/2 stream 0 was not closed cleanly: INTERNAL_ERROR (err 2)

  ➜  ~ measure_get 
https://berlin-mirror.marusich.info/nar/gzip/1bq783rbkzv9z9zdhivbvfzhsz2s5yac-linux-libre-4.19
    % Total    % Received % Xferd  Average Speed   Time    Time     Time  
Current
                                   Dload  Upload   Total   Spent    Left  Speed
  100 66.6M  100 66.6M    0     0   109k      0  0:10:25  0:10:25 --:--:--  241k
  url_effective: 
https://berlin-mirror.marusich.info/nar/gzip/1bq783rbkzv9z9zdhivbvfzhsz2s5yac-linux-libre-4.19
  http_code: 200
  num_connects: 1
  num_redirects: 0
  remote_ip: 52.85.158.22
  remote_port: 443
  size_download: 69899433 B
  speed_download: 111816.000 B/s
  time_appconnect: 3.507528 s
  time_connect: 2.650373 s
  time_namelookup: 2.261801 s
  time_pretransfer: 3.507637 s
  time_redirect: 0.000000 s
  time_starttransfer: 5.995298 s
  time_total: 625.129571 s

  ➜  ~ measure_get 
https://berlin-mirror.marusich.info/nar/gzip/1bq783rbkzv9z9zdhivbvfzhsz2s5yac-linux-libre-4.19
    % Total    % Received % Xferd  Average Speed   Time    Time     Time  
Current
                                   Dload  Upload   Total   Spent    Left  Speed
  100 66.6M  100 66.6M    0     0   109k      0  0:10:23  0:10:23 --:--:--  141k
  url_effective: 
https://berlin-mirror.marusich.info/nar/gzip/1bq783rbkzv9z9zdhivbvfzhsz2s5yac-linux-libre-4.19
  http_code: 200
  num_connects: 1
  num_redirects: 0
  remote_ip: 52.85.158.22
  remote_port: 443
  size_download: 69899433 B
  speed_download: 112187.000 B/s
  time_appconnect: 2.280972 s
  time_connect: 1.407197 s
  time_namelookup: 1.056180 s
  time_pretransfer: 2.281234 s
  time_redirect: 0.000000 s
  time_starttransfer: 3.167703 s
  time_total: 623.061584 s
#+END_EXAMPLE


2. Tested 3 days ago at my office. China Telecom enterprise broadband. 50Mb/s.

Unusually fast! berlin-mirror.marusich.info is resolved to Seattle, WA,
US. I have no idea why it's so fast that day.

#+BEGIN_EXAMPLE
  ➜  ~ measure_get 
https://berlin-mirror.marusich.info/nar/gzip/1bq783rbkzv9z9zdhivbvfzhsz2s5yac-linux-libre-4.19
    % Total    % Received % Xferd  Average Speed   Time    Time     Time  
Current
                                   Dload  Upload   Total   Spent    Left  Speed
  100 66.6M  100 66.6M    0     0  1364k      0  0:00:50  0:00:50 --:--:-- 1352k
  url_effective: 
https://berlin-mirror.marusich.info/nar/gzip/1bq783rbkzv9z9zdhivbvfzhsz2s5yac-linux-libre-4.19
  http_code: 200
  num_connects: 1
  num_redirects: 0
  remote_ip: 13.35.20.109
  remote_port: 443
  size_download: 69899433 B
  speed_download: 1397429.000 B/s
  time_appconnect: 2.432387 s
  time_connect: 0.200842 s
  time_namelookup: 0.000446 s
  time_pretransfer: 2.432659 s
  time_redirect: 0.000000 s
  time_starttransfer: 2.673045 s
  time_total: 50.020945 s

  ➜  ~ measure_get 
https://berlin-mirror.marusich.info/nar/gzip/1bq783rbkzv9z9zdhivbvfzhsz2s5yac-linux-libre-4.19
    % Total    % Received % Xferd  Average Speed   Time    Time     Time  
Current
                                   Dload  Upload   Total   Spent    Left  Speed
  100 66.6M  100 66.6M    0     0  1592k      0  0:00:42  0:00:42 --:--:-- 2506k
  url_effective: 
https://berlin-mirror.marusich.info/nar/gzip/1bq783rbkzv9z9zdhivbvfzhsz2s5yac-linux-libre-4.19
  http_code: 200
  num_connects: 1
  num_redirects: 0
  remote_ip: 13.35.20.109
  remote_port: 443
  size_download: 69899433 B
  speed_download: 1630687.000 B/s
  time_appconnect: 0.653270 s
  time_connect: 0.209455 s
  time_namelookup: 0.001582 s
  time_pretransfer: 0.658399 s
  time_redirect: 0.000000 s
  time_starttransfer: 0.883126 s
  time_total: 42.865868 s
#+END_EXAMPLE


3. Tested today at my office. China Telecom enterprise broadband. 50Mb/s.

Slow as usual. berlin-mirror.marusich.info is still resolved to Seattle,
WA, US. I killed the program several times because it hung there with no
data transfer for a few minutes. The TCP connection was probably closed
by GFW. This is very common here.

#+BEGIN_EXAMPLE
  ➜  ~ measure_get 
https://berlin-mirror.marusich.info/nar/gzip/1bq783rbkzv9z9zdhivbvfzhsz2s5yac-linux-libre-4.19
    % Total    % Received % Xferd  Average Speed   Time    Time     Time  
Current
                                   Dload  Upload   Total   Spent    Left  Speed
  100 66.6M  100 66.6M    0     0  48110      0  0:24:12  0:24:12 --:--:-- 41808
  url_effective: 
https://berlin-mirror.marusich.info/nar/gzip/1bq783rbkzv9z9zdhivbvfzhsz2s5yac-linux-libre-4.19
  http_code: 200
  num_connects: 1
  num_redirects: 0
  remote_ip: 52.85.158.151
  remote_port: 443
  size_download: 69899433 B
  speed_download: 48110.000 B/s
  time_appconnect: 0.872926 s
  time_connect: 0.282048 s
  time_namelookup: 0.000524 s
  time_pretransfer: 0.873099 s
  time_redirect: 0.000000 s
  time_starttransfer: 1.187467 s
  time_total: 1452.904154 s

  ➜  ~ measure_get 
https://berlin-mirror.marusich.info/nar/gzip/1bq783rbkzv9z9zdhivbvfzhsz2s5yac-linux-libre-4.19
    % Total    % Received % Xferd  Average Speed   Time    Time     Time  
Current
                                   Dload  Upload   Total   Spent    Left  Speed
    2 66.6M    2 1809k    0     0   5760      0  3:22:15  0:05:21  3:16:54     
0^C%

  ➜  ~ measure_get 
https://berlin-mirror.marusich.info/nar/gzip/1bq783rbkzv9z9zdhivbvfzhsz2s5yac-linux-libre-4.19
    % Total    % Received % Xferd  Average Speed   Time    Time     Time  
Current
                                   Dload  Upload   Total   Spent    Left  Speed
   52 66.6M   52 34.9M    0     0  16772      0  1:09:27  0:36:26  0:33:01     
0^C%

  ➜  ~ measure_get 
https://berlin-mirror.marusich.info/nar/gzip/1bq783rbkzv9z9zdhivbvfzhsz2s5yac-linux-libre-4.19
    % Total    % Received % Xferd  Average Speed   Time    Time     Time  
Current
                                   Dload  Upload   Total   Spent    Left  Speed
  100 66.6M  100 66.6M    0     0  58181      0  0:20:01  0:20:01 --:--:-- 87975
  url_effective: 
https://berlin-mirror.marusich.info/nar/gzip/1bq783rbkzv9z9zdhivbvfzhsz2s5yac-linux-libre-4.19
  http_code: 200
  num_connects: 1
  num_redirects: 0
  remote_ip: 52.85.158.22
  remote_port: 443
  size_download: 69899433 B
  speed_download: 58181.000 B/s
  time_appconnect: 2.297713 s
  time_connect: 1.904176 s
  time_namelookup: 1.727602 s
  time_pretransfer: 2.297974 s
  time_redirect: 0.000000 s
  time_starttransfer: 2.503263 s
  time_total: 1201.408929 s
#+END_EXAMPLE


Well. As you see, the network in China is both slow and unstable.