[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
[gNewSense-users] Add/Remove... suggestion to install or work, with non-
[gNewSense-users] Add/Remove... suggestion to install or work, with non-free software
Mon, 01 Jun 2009 12:22:54 +0200
Thunderbird 188.8.131.52 (X11/20090318)
As ndiswrapper issue has been discussed a long time without a definitive
choice on whether removing it or not, Samy and i wrote to RMS to have
his opinion on the subject.
address@hidden a écrit :
> Bonjour Christophe, Richard,
>>Christophe Jarry wrote:
>>>I'm a gNewSense user and contributer and there is currently a debate
>>> (or not) ndiswrapper software. The latest message in this thread
can be found
>>>My personal opinion is, as ndiswrapper is free software and doesn't
>>>you to install non-free stuff (as non-free blobs do), it should stay
>>> repo. Hence, freedom 0 is respected: i can do whatever i want with
>>> load non-free windows drivers.
>>>What do you think we should do?
> Selon rms <address@hidden>:
>> diswrapper is free software, but if I understand right, its only
>> use is for running non-free drivers. Is that correct?
>> If that is true, then even though the program is free, we might want
>> to remove it so as not to grant legitimacy to the use of those
>> non-free drivers.
> ndiswrapper is a practical workaround aimed to make possible the use of
> unsupported driver (e.g. for wireless chips). However, it's a short term
> workaround, and, in my opinion, a no-solution, considering the
avantages of open
> licensed alternatives. Since the source of the technical problem is the
> no-disclosure of the source code of the wifi-drivers by the
> - make pressure on the manufacturers and convince them to free their
> - reverse engineer that code
> - test, document, and debug free solutions
> - give the preference to alternative chips
> - promote alternative hardware sold with free (wireless, etc.) devices
> - etc.
> Therefore, including ndiswrapper in gnewsense doesnt make sense, if
we want to
> be coherent with the objectives of the project.
> Kind regards
http://www.gnu.org - http://kokopelli.asso.fr
|[Prev in Thread]
||[Next in Thread]|
- [gNewSense-users] Add/Remove... suggestion to install or work, with non-free software,
Christophe Jarry <=