Re: rests under beams do not work correctly with \voicexxx

[Luc]

Graham Percival <gpermus <at> gmail.com> writes:

> 
> Luc wrote:
> > rests under/over beams do not work correctly with \voicexxx
> > 
> > \version "2.9.28" % on windows XP
> > 
> > \layout {ragged-right = ##t}
> > 
> > { \voiceTwo r4 r16 r a'8[ r16 d''] }
> 
> Sorry, what's the problem?  The rest is moved up to avoid colliding with 
> the notes or beam.  What did you expect?
> 
> Cheers,
> - Graham
> 

I have extended my example to 4 octaves which now shows better how the rests 
are positioned.

The \oneVoice style looks perfect to me - lilypond avoids the collision with 
the beams by moving slightly up or down whereas with \voiceXXX the rests under 
the beam stick to the middle of the staff and therefore fall out of the 
notegroup they belong to.

\version "2.9.28" % on windows XP

\layout {ragged-right = ##t}

notes = { a, 8[ r16 d   ] r4
     a  8[ r16 d'  ] r4
     a' 8[ r16 d'' ] r4
     a''8[ r16 d'''] r4 }

{ \oneVoice \notes }
{ \voiceOne \notes }
{ \voiceTwo \notes }

Cheers
Luc