bug-gnubg
[Top][All Lists]
Advanced

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[Bug-gnubg] Bug in importing .mat files


From: Holger
Subject: [Bug-gnubg] Bug in importing .mat files
Date: Sat, 05 Oct 2002 21:40:48 +0200

Hi GNUbg team,

First of all I'd like to congratulate and thank you for making a great
program and offering it for free. But like every non-trivial program it
might contain bugs. And (I think) I found one.

I'm writing a match converter (only for personal use so far) that directly
converts JavaFIBS' internal format into SGF FF4. As JavaFIBS comes with mat
export, that I believe is correct, it's possible to compare the results
after importing in GNUbg.

The problem occurs with resignation. GNUbg doesn't give the correct result
for the game if a player resigns when it's not his turn. At FIBS this is
possible.

I have attached an example played by me on FIBS. It's a 3 pt match, where
in the last game my opponent resigned :-) when I had rolled already. GNUbg
shows an incorrect win of 1 pt for white. (I suppose because white made the
last move.) It should be 4 pts for black or in sgf-notation: RE[B+4R].

About the last 2 lines of my output (BGconvert-correct.sgf):
;DI[22]PL[B]
;W[resign])
The first line is probably a matter of taste (or the capabilities of the
reading program; GNUbg does understand it) not to write ";B[22]". As I read
the docs of SGF "B[]" would be a move, that in this case couldn't be made.
But this would mean predicting an information and might influence the
decision whether to double or not to.

The last line is not covered by the SGF standard. However, imo it's
important for evaluation, especially if one adds information about whether
a gammon or a backgammon is offered. Besides, then the other player might
reject the offer to resign, for which there is neither a property in the
SGF standard.

If you could comment on these thoughts and how to solve it, please?

TIA and regards,

        Holger
(;FF[4]GM[6]AP[BGconvert:0.1]MI[length:3][game:0][ws:0][bs:0]PW[refi]PB[tryout]RU[Crawford]DT[2002-09-05]RE[B+1]GS[M:0
 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000][C:0 0 0 
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000][D:0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000]
;W[23mkmj]
;B[13qtst]
;W[24hdfd]
;B[25aclq]
;W[31kjfc]
;B[33yclosvsv]
;W[22ywmkmkmk]
;B[44osquququ]
;W[52wrrp]
;B[66agciioou]
;W[26xrrp]
;B[15gluv]
;W[62xrrp]
;B[41lmmq]
;W[14kgfe]
;B[63lrqt]
;W[45kgkf]
;B[11tuuvvwvw]
;W[65pjje]
;B[53sxux]
;W[54hcgc]
;B[34loos]
;W[56hbgb]
;B[41lmmq]
;W[46pjjf]
;B[24rtqu]
;W[43pmjf]
;B[51tzxz]
;W[41miih]
;B[double]
;W[drop])
(;FF[4]GM[6]AP[BGconvert:0.1]MI[length:3][game:1][ws:0][bs:1]PW[refi]PB[tryout]RU[Crawford]DT[2002-09-05]RE[B+1]GS[M:0
 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000][C:0 0 0 
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000][D:0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000]
;W[16mghg]
;B[32aclo]
;W[35hcfc]
;B[52yeln]
;W[12gefe]
;B[22ybnpsusu]
;W[66mghbgaga]
;B[22ybybbdbd]
;W[15ytfe]
;B[61stou]
;W[26ywmg]
;B[55lqlqqvqv]
;W[32wtge]
;B[35]
;W[16mlmg]
;B[22ybybprrt]
;W[32ywwt]
;B[26ybbh]
;W[42lhhf]
;B[26ybbh]
;W[33fcfcfc]
;B[43dgdh]
;W[23ywwt]
;B[31hihk]
;W[31xwwt]
;B[33gjilknnq]
;W[22trrppnnl]
;B[26yfjl]
;W[13yx]
;B[31fiij]
;W[31xwwt]
;B[25qsqv]
;W[51xwwr]
;B[54lqqu]
;W[66tntntnrl]
;B[22jlsuuwuw]
;W[66]
;B[45bglp]
;W[64]
;B[25bguw]
;W[24]
;B[double]
;W[drop])
(;FF[4]GM[6]AP[BGconvert:0.1]MI[length:3][game:2][ws:0][bs:2]PW[refi]PB[tryout]RU[Crawford:CrawfordGame]DT[2002-09-05]RE[W+1]GS[M:0
 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000][C:0 0 0 
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000][D:0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000]
;B[61lrqr]
;W[11hghgfefe]
;B[14ablp]
;W[23mjjh]
;B[61ablr]
;W[34xtmj]
;B[13qtst]
;W[56]
;B[16pqlr]
;W[43yuxu]
;B[11bcbccdcd]
;W[16mllf]
;B[35ycrw]
;W[56mgje]
;B[52rtsx]
;W[61mggf]
;B[64ciim]
;W[63fcga]
;B[62mstv]
;W[64uoea]
;B[33rurusvsv]
;W[41yxok]
;B[56]
;W[21feec]
;B[15]
;W[33heheebeb]
;B[46ydqw]
;W[42kgge]
;B[63djjm]
;W[46xrrn]
;B[23mpvx]
;W[56nhhc]
;B[33psqtsvtw]
;W[62gega]
;B[53svsx]
;W[44fbfbfbea]
;B[31dggh]
;W[42bzea]
;B[42hlln]
;W[53ezeb]
;B[44dhhllppt]
;W[52czbz]
;B[31nqqr]
;W[26czbz]
;B[51rstz]
;W[54czbz]
;B[61szxz]
;W[55bzbzazaz]
;B[22uwwzwzwz]
;W[36azaz]
;B[13vzxz]
;W[56az])
(;FF[4]GM[6]AP[BGconvert:0.1]MI[length:3][game:3][ws:1][bs:2]PW[refi]PB[tryout]RU[Crawford]DT[2002-09-05]RE[B+4R]GS[M:0
 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000][C:0 0 0 
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000][D:0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000]
;B[65aggl]
;W[double]
;B[take]
;W[65mhmg]
;B[11qrqrstst]
;W[44mimihdhd]
;B[26agqs]
;W[31yvhg]
;B[64]
;W[13hefe]
;B[44]
;W[26xvmg]
;B[11yalmlmst]
;W[32xuig]
;B[13rutu]
;W[53yvid]
;B[11abbclmrs]
;W[14gcdc]
;B[55]
;W[11fefeeddc]
;B[24ybsw]
;W[14vrcb]
;B[23ybmp]
;W[54]
;B[56lrrw]
;W[42]
;B[35lolq]
;W[63yv]
;B[24qspt]
;W[45]
;B[42mqoq]
;W[21yxxv]
;B[43mqqt]
;W[66vpvppjpj]
;B[32sutw]
;W[55jejegbgb]
;B[36]
;W[63vppm]
;B[31yasv]
;W[51yxmh]
;B[23tvux]
;W[65]
;B[34quux]
;W[23]
;B[43quux]
;W[63]
;B[25susx]
;W[36yshe]
;B[51wx]
;W[54snea]
;B[31yaux]
;W[54]
;B[56aggl]
;W[41]
;B[55lqqvtztz]
;W[61yssr]
;DI[22]PL[B]
;W[resign])
(;FF[4]GM[6]AP[GNU 
Backgammon:0.12]MI[length:3][game:0][ws:0][bs:0]PW[refi]PB[You]RU[Crawford]RE[B+1]GS[M:0
 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000][C:0 0 0 
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000][D:0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000]
;W[23mkmj]
;B[13qtst]
;W[24hdfd]
;B[25aclq]
;W[31kjfc]
;B[33yclosvsv]
;W[22ywmkmkmk]
;B[44osquququ]
;W[52wrrp]
;B[66agciioou]
;W[26xrrp]
;B[15gluv]
;W[62xrrp]
;B[41lmmq]
;W[14kgfe]
;B[63lrqt]
;W[45kgkf]
;B[11tuuvvwvw]
;W[65pjje]
;B[53sxux]
;W[54hcgc]
;B[34loos]
;W[56hbgb]
;B[41lmmq]
;W[46pjjf]
;B[24qurt]
;W[43pmjf]
;B[51tzxz]
;W[41miih]
;B[double]
;W[drop])
(;FF[4]GM[6]AP[GNU 
Backgammon:0.12]MI[length:3][game:1][ws:0][bs:1]PW[refi]PB[You]RU[Crawford]RE[B+1]GS[M:0
 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000][C:0 0 0 
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000][D:0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000]
;W[16mghg]
;B[32aclo]
;W[35hcfc]
;B[52yeln]
;W[12gefe]
;B[22ybnpsusu]
;W[66mghbgaga]
;B[22ybybbdbd]
;W[15ytfe]
;B[61oust]
;W[26ywmg]
;B[55lqlqqvqv]
;W[32wtge]
;B[35]
;W[16mlmg]
;B[22ybybprrt]
;W[32ywwt]
;B[26ybbh]
;W[42lhhf]
;B[26ybbh]
;W[33fcfcfc]
;B[43dgdh]
;W[23ywwt]
;B[31hihk]
;W[31xwwt]
;B[33gjilknnq]
;W[22trrppnnl]
;B[26yfjl]
;W[13yx]
;B[31fiij]
;W[31xwwt]
;B[25qsqv]
;W[51xwwr]
;B[54lqqu]
;W[66tntntnrl]
;B[22jlsuuwuw]
;W[66]
;B[45bglp]
;W[64]
;B[25bguw]
;W[24]
;B[double]
;W[drop])
(;FF[4]GM[6]AP[GNU 
Backgammon:0.12]MI[length:3][game:2][ws:0][bs:2]PW[refi]PB[You]RU[Crawford:CrawfordGame]RE[W+1]GS[M:0
 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000][C:0 0 0 
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000][D:0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000]
;B[61lrqr]
;W[11hghgfefe]
;B[14ablp]
;W[23mjjh]
;B[61ablr]
;W[34xtmj]
;B[13qtst]
;W[56]
;B[16lrpq]
;W[43yuxu]
;B[11bcbccdcd]
;W[16mllf]
;B[35ycrw]
;W[56mgje]
;B[52rtsx]
;W[61mggf]
;B[64ciim]
;W[63gafc]
;B[62mstv]
;W[64uoea]
;B[33rurusvsv]
;W[41yxok]
;B[56]
;W[21feec]
;B[15]
;W[33heheebeb]
;B[46ydqw]
;W[42kgge]
;B[63djjm]
;W[46xrrn]
;B[23mpvx]
;W[56nhhc]
;B[33psqtsvtw]
;W[62gega]
;B[53svsx]
;W[44fbfbfbea]
;B[31dggh]
;W[42eabz]
;B[42hlln]
;W[53ebez]
;B[44dhhllppt]
;W[52czbz]
;B[31nqqr]
;W[26czbz]
;B[51rstz]
;W[54czbz]
;B[61szxz]
;W[55bzbzazaz]
;B[22uwwzwzwz]
;W[36azaz]
;B[13vzxz]
;W[56az])
(;FF[4]GM[6]AP[GNU 
Backgammon:0.12]MI[length:3][game:3][ws:1][bs:2]PW[refi]PB[You]RU[Crawford]RE[W+1]GS[M:0
 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000][C:0 0 0 
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000 0.000000 0.000000][D:0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 
0.000000]
;B[65aggl]
;W[double]
;B[take]
;W[65mhmg]
;B[11qrqrstst]
;W[44mimihdhd]
;B[26agqs]
;W[31yvhg]
;B[64]
;W[13hefe]
;B[44]
;W[26xvmg]
;B[11yalmlmst]
;W[32xuig]
;B[13rutu]
;W[53yvid]
;B[11abbclmrs]
;W[14gcdc]
;B[55]
;W[11fefeeddc]
;B[24ybsw]
;W[14vrcb]
;B[23ybmp]
;W[54]
;B[56lrrw]
;W[42]
;B[35lolq]
;W[63yv]
;B[24ptqs]
;W[45]
;B[42mqoq]
;W[21yxxv]
;B[43mqqt]
;W[66vpvppjpj]
;B[32sutw]
;W[55jejegbgb]
;B[36]
;W[63vppm]
;B[31yasv]
;W[51yxmh]
;B[23tvux]
;W[65]
;B[34quux]
;W[23]
;B[43quux]
;W[63]
;B[25susx]
;W[36yshe]
;B[51wx]
;W[54snea]
;B[31yaux]
;W[54]
;B[56aggl]
;W[41]
;B[55lqqvtztz]
;W[61yssr])
JavaFIBS internal match representation v1.0
13:refi: 
6:You:refi
11:refi:2 3
1:refi: 13-10 13-11
0:You:1 3
1:You:17-20 19-20 
0:refi:2 4
1:refi: 8-4 6-4
0:You:2 5
1:You:12-17 1-3 
0:refi:3 1
1:refi: 6-3 11-10
0:You:3 3
1:You:bar-3 19-22 19-22 12-15 
0:refi:2 2
1:refi: bar-23 13-11 13-11 13-11
0:You:4 4
1:You:17-21 17-21 17-21 15-19 
0:refi:5 2
1:refi: 23-18 18-16
0:You:6 6
1:You:3-9 9-15 15-21 1-7 
0:refi:2 6
1:refi: 24-18 18-16
0:You:1 5
1:You:7-12 21-22 
0:refi:6 2
1:refi: 24-18 18-16
0:You:4 1
1:You:12-13 13-17 
0:refi:1 4
1:refi: 11-7 6-5
0:You:6 3
1:You:12-18 17-20 
0:refi:4 5
1:refi: 11-6 11-7
0:You:1 1
1:You:21-22 22-23 22-23 20-21 
0:refi:6 5
1:refi: 16-10 10-5
0:You:5 3
1:You:19-24 21-24 
0:refi:5 4
1:refi: 8-3 7-3
0:You:3 4
1:You:12-15 15-19 
0:refi:5 6
1:refi: 8-2 7-2
0:You:4 1
1:You:12-13 13-17 
0:refi:4 6
1:refi: 16-10 10-6
0:You:2 4
1:You:17-21 18-20 
0:refi:4 3
1:refi: 10-6 16-13
0:You:5 1
1:You: 20-o 24-o
0:refi:4 1
1:refi: 13-9 9-8
2:You: 
5:refi:
7:You:1
14:tryout-1:refi-0
13:refi: 
6:You:refi
11:refi:1 6
1:refi: 12-18 17-18
0:You:3 2
1:You:13-10 24-22 
0:refi:3 5
1:refi: 17-22 19-22
0:You:5 2
1:You:bar-20 13-11 
0:refi:1 2
1:refi: 18-20 19-20
0:You:2 2
1:You:bar-23 6-4 6-4 11-9 
0:refi:6 6
1:refi: 12-18 18-24 18-24 17-23
0:You:2 2
1:You:bar-23 bar-23 23-21 23-21 
0:refi:1 5
1:refi: bar-5 19-20
0:You:6 1
1:You:10-4 6-5 
0:refi:2 6
1:refi: bar-2 12-18
0:You:5 5
1:You:13-8 8-3 8-3 13-8 
0:refi:3 2
1:refi: 2-5 18-20
0:You:3 5
15:You: 
0:refi:1 6
1:refi: 12-13 12-18
0:You:2 2
1:You:bar-23 bar-23 9-7 7-5 
0:refi:3 2
1:refi: bar-2 2-5
0:You:2 6
1:You:bar-23 23-17 
0:refi:4 2
1:refi: 13-17 17-19
0:You:2 6
1:You:bar-23 23-17 
0:refi:3 3
1:refi: 19-22 19-22 19-22
0:You:4 3
1:You:21-18 21-17 
0:refi:2 3
1:refi: bar-2 2-5
0:You:3 1
1:You:17-14 17-16 
0:refi:3 1
1:refi: 1-2 2-5
0:You:3 3
1:You:14-11 11-8 16-13 18-15 
0:refi:2 2
1:refi: 5-7 7-9 9-11 11-13
0:You:2 6
1:You:bar-19 15-13 
0:refi:1 3
1:refi: bar-1
0:You:3 1
1:You:19-16 16-15 
0:refi:3 1
1:refi: 1-2 2-5
0:You:2 5
1:You:8-3 8-6 
0:refi:5 1
1:refi: 1-2 2-7
0:You:5 4
1:You:13-8 8-4 
0:refi:6 6
1:refi: 7-13 5-11 5-11 5-11
0:You:2 2
1:You:15-13 4-2 4-2 6-4 
0:refi:6 6
15:refi: 
0:You:4 5
1:You:13-9 23-18 
0:refi:6 4
15:refi: 
0:You:2 5
1:You:23-18 4-2 
0:refi:2 4
15:refi: 
2:You: 
5:refi:
7:You:1
14:tryout-2:refi-0
13:refi: 
6:You:refi
11:You:6 1
1:You:13-7 8-7 
0:refi:1 1
1:refi: 17-18 17-18 19-20 19-20
0:You:1 4
1:You:13-9 24-23 
0:refi:2 3
1:refi: 12-15 15-17
0:You:6 1
1:You:13-7 24-23 
0:refi:3 4
1:refi: 1-5 12-15
0:You:1 3
1:You:8-5 6-5 
0:refi:5 6
15:refi: 
0:You:1 6
1:You:13-7 9-8 
0:refi:4 3
1:refi: bar-4 1-4
0:You:1 1
1:You:23-22 23-22 22-21 22-21 
0:refi:1 6
1:refi: 12-13 13-19
0:You:3 5
1:You:bar-22 7-2 
0:refi:5 6
1:refi: 15-20 12-18
0:You:5 2
1:You:6-1 7-5 
0:refi:6 1
1:refi: 12-18 18-19
0:You:6 4
1:You:22-16 16-12 
0:refi:6 3
1:refi: 18-24 19-22
0:You:6 2
1:You:12-6 5-3 
0:refi:6 4
1:refi: 20-24 4-10
0:You:3 3
1:You:7-4 7-4 6-3 6-3 
0:refi:4 1
1:refi: bar-1 10-14
0:You:5 6
15:You: 
0:refi:2 1
1:refi: 19-20 20-22
0:You:1 5
15:You: 
0:refi:3 3
1:refi: 17-20 17-20 20-23 20-23
0:You:4 6
1:You:bar-21 8-2 
0:refi:4 2
1:refi: 14-18 18-20
0:You:6 3
1:You:21-15 15-12 
0:refi:4 6
1:refi: 1-7 7-11
0:You:2 3
1:You:12-9 3-1 
0:refi:5 6
1:refi: 11-17 17-22
0:You:3 3
1:You:9-6 6-3 8-5 5-2 
0:refi:6 2
1:refi: 18-24 18-20
0:You:5 3
1:You:6-1 6-3 
0:refi:4 4
1:refi: 19-23 19-23 19-23 20-24
0:You:3 1
1:You:21-18 18-17 
0:refi:4 2
1:refi: 20-24 23-off
0:You:4 2
1:You:17-13 13-11 
0:refi:5 3
1:refi: 20-off 20-23
0:You:4 4
1:You:21-17 17-13 13-9 9-5 
0:refi:5 2
1:refi: 22-off 23-off
0:You:3 1
1:You:11-8 8-7 
0:refi:2 6
1:refi: 22-off 23-off
0:You:5 1
1:You:7-6 5-off 
0:refi:5 4
1:refi: 22-off 23-off
0:You:6 1
1:You: 6-o 1-o
0:refi:5 5
1:refi: 23-off 23-off 24-off 24-off
0:You:2 2
1:You:2-off 2-off 2-off 4-2 
0:refi:3 6
1:refi: 24-off 24-off
0:You:1 3
1:You: 3-o 1-o
0:refi:5 6
1:refi: 24-off
7:refi:1
14:refi-1:tryout-2
13:refi: 
6:You:refi
11:You:6 5
1:You:1-7 7-12 
2:refi: 
4:You:
0:refi:6 5
1:refi: 13-7 13-8
0:You:1 1
1:You:19-20 19-20 17-18 17-18 
0:refi:4 4
1:refi: 8-4 8-4 13-9 13-9
0:You:2 6
1:You:1-7 17-19 
0:refi:3 1
1:refi: bar-22 8-7
0:You:6 4
15:You: 
0:refi:1 3
1:refi: 8-5 6-5
0:You:4 4
15:You: 
0:refi:2 6
1:refi: 13-7 24-22
0:You:1 1
1:You:bar-1 12-13 12-13 19-20 
0:refi:3 2
1:refi: 9-7 24-21
0:You:1 3
1:You:18-21 20-21 
0:refi:5 3
1:refi: bar-22 9-4
0:You:1 1
1:You:18-19 1-2 2-3 12-13 
0:refi:1 4
1:refi: 7-3 4-3
0:You:5 5
15:You: 
0:refi:1 1
1:refi: 6-5 5-4 4-3 6-5
0:You:2 4
1:You:bar-2 19-23 
0:refi:1 4
1:refi: 3-2 22-18
0:You:2 3
1:You:bar-2 13-16 
0:refi:5 4
15:refi: 
0:You:5 6
1:You:12-18 18-23 
0:refi:4 2
15:refi: 
0:You:3 5
1:You:12-17 12-15 
0:refi:6 3
1:refi: bar-22
0:You:2 4
1:You:16-20 17-19 
0:refi:4 5
15:refi: 
0:You:4 2
1:You:13-17 15-17 
0:refi:2 1
1:refi: bar-24 24-22
0:You:4 3
1:You:13-17 17-20 
0:refi:6 6
1:refi: 22-16 22-16 16-10 16-10
0:You:3 2
1:You:20-23 19-21 
0:refi:5 5
1:refi: 7-2 7-2 10-5 10-5
0:You:3 6
15:You: 
0:refi:6 3
1:refi: 22-16 16-13
0:You:3 1
1:You:bar-1 19-22 
0:refi:5 1
1:refi: bar-24 13-8
0:You:2 3
1:You:20-22 21-24 
0:refi:6 5
15:refi: 
0:You:3 4
1:You:17-21 21-24 
0:refi:2 3
15:refi: 
0:You:4 3
1:You:17-21 21-24 
0:refi:6 3
15:refi: 
0:You:2 5
1:You:19-24 19-21 
0:refi:3 6
1:refi: bar-19 8-5
0:You:5 1
1:You:23-24 
0:refi:5 4
1:refi: 5-1 19-14
0:You:3 1
1:You:bar-1 21-24 
0:refi:5 4
15:refi: 
0:You:5 6
1:You:1-7 7-12 
0:refi:4 1
15:refi: 
0:You:5 5
1:You:12-17 17-22 20-off 20-off 
0:refi:6 1
1:refi: bar-19 19-18
0:You:2 2
3:refi:4
7:You:4
9:You:3
 3 point match

 Game 1
 refi : 0                       You : 0
  1) 23: 13/10 13/11             13: 8/5 6/5
  2) 24: 8/4 6/4                 25: 13/8 24/22
  3) 31: 6/3 11/10               33: 25/22 6/3 6/3 13/10
  4) 22: 25/23 13/11 13/11 13/11 44: 8/4 8/4 8/4 10/6
  5) 52: 23/18 18/16             66: 22/16 16/10 10/4 24/18
  6) 26: 24/18 18/16             15: 18/13 4/3
  7) 62: 24/18 18/16             41: 13/12 12/8
  8) 14: 11/7 6/5                63: 13/7 8/5
  9) 45: 11/6 11/7               11: 4/3 3/2 3/2 5/4
 10) 65: 16/10 10/5              53: 6/1 4/1
 11) 54: 8/3 7/3                 34: 13/10 10/6
 12) 56: 8/2 7/2                 41: 13/12 12/8
 13) 46: 16/10 10/6              24: 8/4 7/5
 14) 43: 10/6 16/13              51: 5/0 1/0
 15) 41: 13/9 9/8                 Doubles => 2
 16)  Drops                       Wins 1 point

 Game 2
 refi : 0                       You : 1
  1) 16: 13/7 8/7                32: 13/10 24/22
  2) 35: 8/3 6/3                 52: 25/20 13/11
  3) 12: 7/5 6/5                 22: 25/23 6/4 6/4 11/9
  4) 66: 13/7 7/1 7/1 8/2        22: 25/23 25/23 23/21 23/21
  5) 15: 25/20 6/5               61: 10/4 6/5
  6) 26: 25/23 13/7              55: 13/8 8/3 8/3 13/8
  7) 32: 23/20 7/5               35: 
  8) 16: 13/12 13/7              22: 25/23 25/23 9/7 7/5
  9) 32: 25/23 23/20             26: 25/23 23/17
 10) 42: 12/8 8/6                26: 25/23 23/17
 11) 33: 6/3 6/3 6/3             43: 21/18 21/17
 12) 23: 25/23 23/20             31: 17/14 17/16
 13) 31: 24/23 23/20             33: 14/11 11/8 16/13 18/15
 14) 22: 20/18 18/16 16/14 14/12 26: 25/19 15/13
 15) 13: 25/24                   31: 19/16 16/15
 16) 31: 24/23 23/20             25: 8/3 8/6
 17) 51: 24/23 23/18             54: 13/8 8/4
 18) 66: 18/12 20/14 20/14 20/14 22: 15/13 4/2 4/2 6/4
 19) 66:                         45: 13/9 23/18
 20) 64:                         25: 23/18 4/2
 21) 24:                          Doubles => 2
 22)  Drops                       Wins 1 point

 Game 3
 refi : 0                       You : 2
  1)                             61: 13/7 8/7
  2) 11: 8/7 8/7 6/5 6/5         14: 13/9 24/23
  3) 23: 13/10 10/8              61: 13/7 24/23
  4) 34: 24/20 13/10             13: 8/5 6/5
  5) 56:                         16: 13/7 9/8
  6) 43: 25/21 24/21             11: 23/22 23/22 22/21 22/21
  7) 16: 13/12 12/6              35: 25/22 7/2
  8) 56: 10/5 13/7               52: 6/1 7/5
  9) 61: 13/7 7/6                64: 22/16 16/12
 10) 63: 7/1 6/3                 62: 12/6 5/3
 11) 64: 5/1 21/15               33: 7/4 7/4 6/3 6/3
 12) 41: 25/24 15/11             56: 
 13) 21: 6/5 5/3                 15: 
 14) 33: 8/5 8/5 5/2 5/2         46: 25/21 8/2
 15) 42: 11/7 7/5                63: 21/15 15/12
 16) 46: 24/18 18/14             23: 12/9 3/1
 17) 56: 14/8 8/3                33: 9/6 6/3 8/5 5/2
 18) 62: 7/1 7/5                 53: 6/1 6/3
 19) 44: 6/2 6/2 6/2 5/1         31: 21/18 18/17
 20) 42: 5/1 2/0                 42: 17/13 13/11
 21) 53: 5/0 5/2                 44: 21/17 17/13 13/9 9/5
 22) 52: 3/0 2/0                 31: 11/8 8/7
 23) 26: 3/0 2/0                 51: 7/6 5/0
 24) 54: 3/0 2/0                 61: 6/0 1/0
 25) 55: 2/0 2/0 1/0 1/0         22: 2/0 2/0 2/0 4/2
 26) 36: 1/0 1/0                 13: 3/0 1/0
 27) 56: 1/0                     
 Wins 1 point

 Game 4
 refi : 1                       You : 2
  1)                             65: 24/18 18/13
  2)  Doubles => 2                Takes
  3) 65: 13/7 13/8               11: 6/5 6/5 8/7 8/7
  4) 44: 8/4 8/4 13/9 13/9       26: 24/18 8/6
  5) 31: 25/22 8/7               64: 
  6) 13: 8/5 6/5                 44: 
  7) 26: 13/7 24/22              11: 25/24 13/12 13/12 6/5
  8) 32: 9/7 24/21               13: 7/4 5/4
  9) 53: 25/22 9/4               11: 7/6 24/23 23/22 13/12
 10) 14: 7/3 4/3                 55: 
 11) 11: 6/5 5/4 4/3 6/5         24: 25/23 6/2
 12) 14: 3/2 22/18               23: 25/23 12/9
 13) 54:                         56: 13/7 7/2
 14) 42:                         35: 13/8 13/10
 15) 63: 25/22                   24: 9/5 8/6
 16) 45:                         42: 12/8 10/8
 17) 21: 25/24 24/22             43: 12/8 8/5
 18) 66: 22/16 22/16 16/10 16/10 32: 5/2 6/4
 19) 55: 7/2 7/2 10/5 10/5       36: 
 20) 63: 22/16 16/13             31: 25/24 6/3
 21) 51: 25/24 13/8              23: 5/3 4/1
 22) 65:                         34: 8/4 4/1
 23) 23:                         43: 8/4 4/1
 24) 63:                         25: 6/1 6/4
 25) 36: 25/19 8/5               51: 2/1
 26) 54: 5/1 19/14               31: 25/24 4/1
 27) 54:                         56: 24/18 18/13
 28) 41:                         55: 13/8 8/3 5/0 5/0
 29) 61: 25/19 19/18             22:  Wins 4 points and the match

reply via email to

[Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread]