bug#11220: uniq -d and -Du bug?

[Jim Meyering]

phil colbourn wrote:

> What should this print?
>
> echo -e 'aa\naa\naa\n' | uniq -d

It's better to avoid echo -e.  Use printf instead:

    printf 'aa\naa\naa\n' | uniq -d

> To me this says:
>
> 1. uniqueness is defined by whole line so there is 1 unique value 'aa';
> 2. -d option say to 'only print duplicate lines';

When in doubt, follow the advice at the bottom of the man page
and read the "real" (texinfo) documentation:

       The full documentation for uniq is maintained as a Texinfo manual.   If
       the  info  and  uniq  programs are properly installed at your site, the
       command

              info coreutils 'uniq invocation'

       should give you access to the complete manual.

> 3. 1st 'aa' is (so far) unique so it should NOT be printed;
> 4. 2nd 'aa' is not unique so it SHOULD be printed; and
> 5. 3rd 'aa' is not unique so it SHOULD also be printed.
>
> I think I should get this:
>
> aa
> aa
>
> But I get this:
>
> aa

Thanks for the report.
The problem is that the description in the man page is too succinct,
perhaps because -d means different things, depending on what other
options you use it with.

How is what you see inconsistent with the documentation?
(info coreutils uniq)

`-d'
`--repeated'
     Discard lines that are not repeated.  When used by itself, this
     option causes `uniq' to print the first copy of each repeated line,
     and nothing else.